The Lede

Will the New Democratic Majority Get Off the Ground?

新的民主党多数派能顺利起飞吗?
After a wave of midterm wins, thousands of party operatives, elected officials, and Friends of the Pod gathered to do something unusual: celebrate.
在一波中期选举胜利之后,数千名党内工作人员、民选官员和“播客之友”齐聚一堂,做了一件不寻常的事:庆祝。
A bundle of blue balloons is tethered to a donkey.
Illustration by Ben Kothe / The New Yorker; Source photographs from Getty

When the Federal Aviation Administration instituted a nationwide ground stop of all flights on Friday, Ruben Gallego, a senator from Arizona, learned about it not from a government official but from his mother. “I just got a text message saying, ‘Why are all the planes stopped?’ I’m, like, ‘Uh-oh.’ ” Gallego had travelled to Denver along with thirty-five hundred professional Democrats, elected officials, and assorted Friends of the Pod who convened at Mission Ballroom, an enormous music venue, to celebrate the Party’s midterm victories and to begin positioning themselves as the heralds of a new liberal moment in American politics. Onstage, the senator had delivered a short speech about what he called “big-ass-truck politics”: the notion that what voters really want is to be able to afford their own version of the American Dream. (Gallego, for his part, drives a Jeep Grand Cherokee.)

周五,当美国联邦航空管理局在全国范围内对所有航班实施地面停飞时,来自亚利桑那州的参议员鲁本·加列戈(Ruben Gallego)不是从政府官员那里得知这一消息的,而是从他母亲那里。“我刚收到一条短信,写着‘为什么所有飞机都停了?’我心想,‘糟了。’”加列戈与三千五百名职业民主党人、民选官员以及形形色色的“播客之友”一同来到丹佛,聚集在巨大的音乐场馆“使命舞厅”(Mission Ballroom),庆祝民主党的中期选举胜利,并开始将自己定位为美国政治中新一轮自由主义时刻的先行者。在台上,这位参议员发表了一篇简短演讲,谈到了他所谓的“大皮卡政治”:选民真正想要的是能够负担得起属于他们自己的美国梦。(加列戈本人开的是一辆吉普大切诺基。)

After it became clear that he was stranded a mile above sea level, Gallego returned to the concert venue for more glad-handing. The ground stop, which resulted in nearly twenty thousand flight cancellations, turned out to be the most dramatic since 9/11; the posturing and influencing continued unabated. Rumored Presidential candidates such as Pete Buttigieg, Josh Shapiro, Elissa Slotkin, and Gallego mostly tried to sidestep the question of whether they would run in 2028, while not so subtly suggesting that they should. “Should I? Time will tell,” Gallego told me. “I think someone like me, who has seen the things I’ve seen, who’s worked at the factories, who has really understood the struggle that everyday Americans feel—someone like me should run because I think they’ll be successful.”

在明确自己被困在海拔一英里的地方之后,加列戈又回到音乐会场地继续与人握手寒暄。这次地面停飞导致近两万架次航班取消,成为自“9·11”事件以来最严重的一次;而会上的姿态展示和影响力运作丝毫未减。皮特·布蒂吉格(Pete Buttigieg)、乔什·夏皮罗(Josh Shapiro)、艾丽莎·斯洛特金(Elissa Slotkin)和加列戈等传闻中的总统候选人大多试图回避自己是否会参加2028年竞选的问题,同时又毫不含蓄地暗示自己应该参选。“我该不该?时间会给出答案,”加列戈对我说。“我认为像我这样见过我所见之事、在工厂里工作过、真正理解普通美国人挣扎的人——像我这样的人应该参选,因为我觉得他们会成功。”

The three-day conference, titled “What’s Next,” was hosted by Majority Democrats, an organization whose leaders are basking in victory. Fifteen of the sixteen candidates that the group supported—a slate branded as “the Bench”—have won their races. Onstage, the governor-elect of Iowa, an erstwhile Prada model named Rob Sand, quoted St. Francis of Assisi as he talked about handing the microphone at town halls to Republican voters. Senator-elect James Talarico, of Texas, emerged to rousing cheers from the audience, and told them that Democrats had a mandate the size of his state. Still, the partisans were evidently unaccustomed to celebrating good news. Stephanie Valencia, a co-founder and C.E.O. of the polling and research firm Equis and the first Latina speaker of the program, was giving a speech about Democrats’ seismic gains with Latino voters when a staffer backstage started ringing a cowbell to signal that she’d gone over time. She kept talking—“I wasn’t going to get cut off,” she told me, “because this was our moment.”

这场为期三天的会议名为“接下来怎么办”(What’s Next),由“多数派民主党人”(Majority Democrats)主办,该组织的领导人正沉浸在胜利的喜悦中。该组织支持的十六名候选人——这批人被打造成名为“板凳席”(the Bench)的阵容——中有十五人赢得了选举。台上,艾奥瓦州当选州长、曾做过普拉达模特的罗布·桑德(Rob Sand)在谈到把市政厅活动中的话筒交给共和党选民时,引用了阿西西的圣方济各的话。得克萨斯州当选参议员詹姆斯·塔拉里科(James Talarico)在观众热烈的欢呼声中登场,并告诉他们,民主党获得的授权之大,堪比他的州。不过,这些党众显然还不习惯庆祝好消息。斯蒂芬妮·瓦伦西亚(Stephanie Valencia)是民调与研究公司Equis的联合创始人兼首席执行官,也是本次议程的首位拉丁裔演讲者。她正在发表关于民主党在拉丁裔选民中取得重大进展的演讲时,后台一名工作人员开始摇牛铃,示意她超时了。她继续讲了下去——“我可不会被打断,”她对我说,“因为这是属于我们的时刻。”

After Anderson Clayton, the chair of the North Carolina Democratic Party, emerged to feeble applause, she bellowed into the mike, “That doesn’t sound like we just won an election last Tuesday!” Sarah Longwell, the publisher of The Bulwark, watched Clayton’s speech on a giant screen set up in a courtyard outside the concert hall, where people mingled. “That’s what I’m talking about! Let’s act like we just had a huge win!” she said. I heard guests variously refer to the gathering as a mini-convention, “modcon” (for “moderate conference”), and “Libchella.” It felt like a corner of LinkedIn had come to life. Why do Democrats have a hard time celebrating? “Because we feel in our bones we’re gonna fuck it up,” Amanda Litman, a co-founder of Run for Something, told me. Because we don’t trust good things. Because we don’t know how to metabolize joy.”

北卡罗来纳州民主党主席安德森·克莱顿(Anderson Clayton)在稀稀拉拉的掌声中登场后,对着麦克风吼道:“这听起来可不像我们上周二刚赢了一场选举!”《堡垒》(The Bulwark)出版人莎拉·朗韦尔(Sarah Longwell)在音乐厅外庭院里一块巨型屏幕上观看了克莱顿的演讲,那里人们正在互相交谈。“这才是我说的!让我们表现得像刚取得了一场大胜一样!”她说。我听到与会者对这次聚会有各种称呼:小型全国代表大会、“温和派大会”(“modcon”,即“温和派会议”的缩写),以及“自由派音乐节”(Libchella)。感觉就像是领英的一个角落活了过来。为什么民主党人很难庆祝?“因为我们骨子里觉得我们会把事情搞砸,”为某事而竞选(Run for Something)的联合创始人阿曼达·利特曼(Amanda Litman)对我说。“因为我们不相信好事。因为我们不知道如何消化快乐。”

On Friday morning, Lis Smith, one of the Democratic strategists behind the conference, was nursing a headache. She was slumped on a chair outside “Camp Searchlight”—a brewery taken over by the Searchlight Institute, a centrist think tank founded by the political operative Adam Jentleson—with a bottle of water and a mixed-berry Celsius, and reminiscing on headaches she’d get as a kid on ski trips. (“Telluride,” she said. “Anyway. I wasn’t on, like, Mt. Everest.”) The wave of wins seemed to vindicate Smith’s theory of change. “We can’t just put up candidates who are just going to barely eke by in the quote-unquote blue wall. We’ve got to put up candidates who can win or give us a real shot in places like Iowa, Texas, North Carolina, some of these other states that we’ve left,” she told me. Sitting across from her was Rohan Patel, a former Tesla executive who now works as the executive director of Majority Democrats. “The candidates that did the best usually had to run the farthest away from the Democratic Party itself,” he said. “They had to show independence.” Majority Democrats, Smith said, would try to expand the Party by lifting candidates “who are of a different opinion, who have no top-down litmus tests, and orient around what we stand for versus just being against Trump.”

周五早上,会议背后的民主党策略师之一利斯·史密斯(Lis Smith)正忍着头痛。她瘫坐在“探照灯营地”(Camp Searchlight)外面的一把椅子上——那是一家被“探照灯研究所”(Searchlight Institute)包下的啤酒厂,该研究所是由政治操盘手亚当·詹特尔森(Adam Jentleson)创立的中间派智库——手里拿着一瓶水和一罐混合莓果味的Celsius能量饮料,回忆起小时候滑雪旅行时犯过的头痛。(“特柳赖德,”她说。“算了。我又不是在珠穆朗玛峰上。”)这波胜利似乎印证了史密斯的变革理论。“我们不能只推出那些在所谓的‘蓝墙’里勉强险胜的候选人。我们得推出能在艾奥瓦、得克萨斯、北卡罗来纳这些我们曾经放弃的州里获胜、或者至少给我们真正机会的候选人,”她对我说。坐在她对面的罗汉·帕特尔(Rohan Patel)是特斯拉前高管,现任“多数派民主党人”执行董事。“表现最好的候选人,通常不得不跑得离民主党本身最远,”他说。“他们必须展现出独立性。”史密斯说,“多数派民主党人”将试图通过扶持“持有不同意见、没有自上而下政治审查标准、围绕我们所代表的立场而非仅仅反对特朗普”的候选人来扩大民主党。

The midterm victory against Donald Trump was so decisive that every faction of the Party can credibly claim it won. Smith and Patel played no small role in cultivating a political environment in which moderates are celebrated as rock stars. This cycle, their strategy was to hire many young digital and communication consultants to help campaigns with the mechanics of running for office, such as pitching stories to journalists or sending out press releases. These services—and others, like building mailing lists or filling out income disclosures—address hurdles that inexperienced candidates face; larger consulting firms might consider them extraneous loss leaders. Campaigns, Patel explained, paid Majority Democrats a monthly retainer and the consultants would, in some cases, functionally work as campaign staffers—on at least one campaign, a consultant for the Bench coördinated all media, the way a communications director might. Patel underlined that Majority Democrats is not driven by profit, and that the candidates it supported were not wealthy. When Smith and others in the Majority Democrats movement speak of what they have in common, they avoid placing the candidates on a left-to-right spectrum and speak instead of a new style of politics. Her group, she said, had supported Democrats who called for greater border security as well as a winning Connecticut candidate who called for abolishing ICE. “How do we change the Party so that it can grow in more places?” Patel said.

这场对唐纳德·特朗普的中期选举胜利如此具有决定性,以至于党内每个派系都可以理直气壮地宣称自己赢了。史密斯和帕特尔在营造一种将温和派当作摇滚明星来推崇的政治环境方面,发挥了不小的作用。这个周期里,他们的策略是聘请许多年轻的数字与传播顾问,帮助竞选团队处理参选的具体事务,比如向记者推介报道或发布新闻稿。这些服务——以及建立邮件列表或填写收入申报等其他服务——解决的是缺乏经验的候选人面临的障碍;大型咨询公司可能会认为这些是无关紧要的赔本业务。帕特尔解释说,竞选团队每月向“多数派民主党人”支付一笔聘用费,而这些顾问在某些情况下实际上会像竞选工作人员一样工作——至少在一个竞选团队中,一位“板凳席”顾问统筹了所有媒体事务,就像传播总监那样。帕特尔强调,“多数派民主党人”并非以盈利为驱动,而且它所支持的候选人都不是富人。当史密斯和“多数派民主党人”运动中的其他人谈到他们的共同点时,他们避免把候选人放在从左到右的光谱上,而是谈论一种新的政治风格。她说,她的组织既支持过呼吁加强边境安全的民主党人,也支持过康涅狄格州一位呼吁废除移民及海关执法局(ICE)的获胜候选人。“我们如何改变这个党,让它能在更多地方发展壮大?”帕特尔说。

“Loosening up a bit is the general idea here,” Jentleson told me. The bar of the Ritz-Carlton in downtown Denver (the conference’s hotel of choice for some elected officials) made for a striking tableau of the new Democratic big tent: Smith chatted with Juleanna Glover, Dick Cheney’s former press secretary and now a crisis-communications consultant; Sarah McBride, the first trans member of Congress, greeted Tim Miller, Jeb Bush’s former communications director turned Never Trump podcaster for The Bulwark. Jentleson has spent at least two years espousing the virtues of heterodoxy, which he characterizes as an independence of thought that shows a candidate isn’t simply a Party stooge. He’d drawn ire online for suggesting, on “The Ezra Klein Show,” that candidates could signal their values to voters by, among other things, “being open to things like spanking.” “I don’t spank my kids—I would not support that,” Jentleson told me. “But we’ve seen what happens when the left gets overly judgmental and censorious towards people whose views they disagree with.”

“总体思路就是稍微放松一点,”詹特尔森对我说。丹佛市中心丽思卡尔顿酒店(这是部分民选官员为本次会议选择的酒店)的酒吧构成了一幅新民主党大帐篷的醒目画面:史密斯与迪克·切尼的前新闻秘书、现为危机沟通顾问的朱莉安娜·格洛弗(Juleanna Glover)交谈;国会首位跨性别议员莎拉·麦克布莱德(Sarah McBride)与杰布·布什的前通讯总监、现为《堡垒》反特朗普播客主播的蒂姆·米勒(Tim Miller)打招呼。詹特尔森至少花了两年时间宣扬异端思想的价值,他把这种异端描述为一种思想上的独立性,表明候选人不仅仅是党的傀儡。他曾在《埃兹拉·克莱因秀》上建议,候选人可以通过“对打屁股之类的事情持开放态度”等方式向选民传递自己的价值观,这在网上招来了愤怒。“我不打我的孩子——我不会支持那种做法,”詹特尔森对我说。“但我们已经看到,当左派对他们不认同的观点变得过度苛责和审查时,会发生什么。”

“Dems are always, like, ‘What’s wrong? What can we analyze? What can we fix?’ Republicans party. They celebrate,” Yemisi Egbewole, a Democratic strategist and senior fellow at the think tank Third Way, told me. “And, for once, we’re the ones that get to celebrate.” Egbewole landed in Denver around noon Friday, as the ground stop began, and she told me she headed straight for an espresso Martini at the conference. She later hit up another hotel bar before heading to the Ritz, where, at around eleven, a bartender screamed “LAST CALL!” so loudly that it made the room fall silent. “In this economy, I’d have probably kept the bar open,” Egbewole told me.

“民主党人总是说,‘出了什么问题?我们能分析什么?我们能解决什么?’共和党人则开派对。他们庆祝,”民主党策略师、智库“第三条道路”(Third Way)高级研究员耶米西·埃格贝沃勒(Yemisi Egbewole)对我说。“而这一次,轮到我们来庆祝了。”埃格贝沃勒在周五中午地面停飞开始时抵达丹佛,她告诉我,她直奔会场去喝了一杯浓缩咖啡马提尼。后来她又去了另一家酒店的酒吧,然后前往丽思卡尔顿,大约十一点时,一位调酒师大喊“最后点单!”声音大得让整个房间都安静了下来。“在这种经济形势下,我大概会让酒吧继续营业,”埃格贝沃勒对我说。

It wouldn’t be a conference of Democrats without some disagreement, and, by the end of the weekend, the old debates remained unresolved. While Hakeem Jeffries spoke of the priorities of the next Congress, protesters were escorted out for yelling “Stop the genocide now!” and “You owe us!” One Democratic strategist, who stayed at the Ritz, told me that the price tag of the conference—three million dollars, according to Majority Democrats—had been on her mind. “I asked someone how much they thought the conference cost, and their answer was ‘the Democrats’ fifty-seventh Senate seat,’ ” she said. Angie Nixon, the former Florida state legislator who came close to flipping that state’s Senate seat, said she’d been struck by how few Black strategists from the South she’d seen, and said she felt that the conference needed more people who were closer to the working class. “I think I only saw one union leader. I’m, like, ‘What’s going on?’ ” she told me. (Speaking of unions: some commentators online criticized Jentleson’s Searchlight Institute for not using union labor to make their merchandise. “Whatever,” Jentleson said. “Maybe next time. We had to turn stuff around in a week.”)

没有分歧就不算民主党人的会议,而到周末结束时,那些老辩论仍未解决。当哈基姆·杰弗里斯(Hakeem Jeffries)谈到下一届国会的优先事项时,抗议者因高喊“现在就停止种族灭绝!”和“你欠我们的!”而被带离现场。一位住在丽思卡尔顿的民主党策略师告诉我,会议的花费——据“多数派民主党人”称是三百万美元——一直萦绕在她心头。“我问一个人觉得这场会议花了多少钱,他们的回答是‘民主党人的第五十七个参议院席位’,”她说。差点翻转佛罗里达州参议院席位的前州议员安吉·尼克松(Angie Nixon)说,她对自己见到的来自南方的黑人策略师如此之少感到震惊,并表示她觉得会议需要更多更贴近工人阶级的人。“我想我只见到了一位工会领袖。我心想,‘这是怎么回事?’”她对我说。(说到工会:一些评论人士在网上批评詹特尔森的“探照灯研究所”没有使用工会劳工来制作他们的周边商品。“无所谓,”詹特尔森说。“也许下次吧。我们得在一周内把东西赶出来。”)

To critics, the conference’s sleek branding could seem to belie old tactics; Majority Democrats is funded by donors including Kathryn and James Murdoch. But several of the candidates they supported ran on platforms of getting money out of politics—the kind of populist, anti-billionaire sentiment that could, hypothetically, legislate Majority Democrats out of existence. “If that impacts us, no problem,” Patel told me, clarifying that they supported candidates who were on board with undoing the Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision. (On one of the panels, Smith also called for banning members of Congress from trading stock.) Patel figured that if the effort to reform campaign finance got far enough to hurt their group, it would hurt Republican ones, too.

在批评者看来,这场会议光鲜的品牌形象似乎掩盖了老一套的做法;“多数派民主党人”的资金来源包括凯瑟琳·默多克和詹姆斯·默多克等捐赠者。但他们支持的几位候选人却以把金钱赶出政治为竞选纲领——这种民粹主义、反亿万富翁的情绪,假设性地看,可能会通过立法让“多数派民主党人”不复存在。“如果那影响到我们,没问题,”帕特尔对我说,并澄清说,他们支持的候选人都赞成推翻最高法院的“联合公民案”裁决。(在其中一场小组讨论中,史密斯还呼吁禁止国会议员炒股。)帕特尔估计,如果竞选财务改革的努力推进到足以伤害他们这个组织的地步,那它也会同样伤害共和党的组织。

Almost unanimously, the panelists at the conference seemed to agree that the old paradigms of left and right, progressives and moderates, were over. Instead, many of the ascendant centrists parried to a top-versus-bottom, wealthy-versus-few framing. But there’s no great equalizer like the Federal Aviation Administration. As cancellations compounded, I asked Gallego about his plans to spend an extra night at the Ritz—only he didn’t feel like talking about it. “I’m staying at the Motel 8,” he joked, apparently mixing up the Motel 6 and Super 8 chains. He managed to get out of town that night. ♦

几乎一致地,会上的小组讨论嘉宾似乎都认同,左与右、进步派与温和派的旧范式已经终结。相反,许多正在崛起的中间派人士转而采用了一种上层对下层、富人对少数人的框架。但没有什么比联邦航空管理局更能拉平差距了。随着航班取消不断累积,我问加列戈他打算如何在丽思卡尔顿多住一晚——只是他不想谈这件事。“我住的是8号汽车旅馆,”他开玩笑说,显然把6号汽车旅馆和速8连锁店搞混了。他当晚还是设法离开了丹佛。♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month