The Lede

The Right-Wing Nonprofit Serving A.I. Slop for America’s Birthday

为美国生日献上人工智能垃圾的右翼非营利组织
PragerU, a fount of Judeo-Christian edutainment, is now a key partner in the Trump Administration’s “civic education” campaign.
普拉格大学(PragerU)——一个犹太-基督教教育娱乐内容的重要来源——如今已成为特朗普政府“公民教育”运动的关键合作伙伴。
Illustration of trucks and American flags.
Illustration by George Wylesol

In his new book, “If There Is No God: The Battle Over Who Defines Good and Evil,” the right-wing radio host and edutainment impresario Dennis Prager spends a couple of pages discussing the killing, in 1989, of a sixteen-year-old American girl by her parents, one of whom was Muslim and born in the West Bank. “I’m not picking on them because they’re Muslim or because they’re Palestinian,” Prager writes. “It just happens that this story was about them.” In the next paragraph, Prager seems to change his mind about why he’s picking on them: “In many parts of the Arab world, parents essentially own their children, especially daughters.”

右翼电台主持人、寓教于乐节目制作人丹尼斯·普拉格(Dennis Prager)在新书《如果没有上帝:善恶定义权之争》中,用数页篇幅讨论了1989年一对父母杀害十六岁美国女儿的案件——其中一位家长是穆斯林,出生于约旦河西岸。“我并非因为他们是穆斯林或巴勒斯坦人才提及此事,”普拉格写道,“只是这个故事恰好与他们有关。”但在下一段,普拉格似乎改变了说法:“在阿拉伯世界的许多地区,父母实质上拥有对子女的所有权,尤其是女儿。”

Ostensibly, Prager is recounting this awful crime because it illustrates a central question taken up by his book, which is “Why do people hurt other people?” The answer, by and large, turns out to be secularism. “The death of God has led to massive deaths of men, women, and children,” Prager writes, citing the “secular doctrines” of Nazism and communism. Secular creep, he goes on, “also appears to be leading to the death of Western civilization.” One might wonder why Prager would choose a thirty-seven-year-old murder, which he implies is linked to monotheistic religious extremism, to build his case against secularism. But the God he has in mind is specifically that of “the Judeo-Christian outlook.” The sole “source of objective morality,” Prager suggests, is the Bible. Prager does not mention that the murdered girl’s mother, who held her down while her father stabbed her to death, was Catholic and from Brazil, a country whose most famous landmark is a hundred-and-twenty-four-foot statue called “Christ the Redeemer.”

普拉格表面上重提这桩骇人罪行,是因为它引出了其著作的核心命题:“人们为何伤害他人?”答案归根结底指向世俗主义。“上帝之死导致了无数男女老幼的死亡,”普拉格在书中写道,并举出纳粹主义与共产主义这两种“世俗信条”为证。他继而指出,世俗主义的蔓延“似乎也将导致西方文明的消亡”。人们或许会疑惑:为何普拉格要选择一桩他暗示与一神教极端主义相关的三十七年前凶杀案,来论证反世俗主义的观点?但他心目中的上帝特指“犹太-基督教世界观”中的神。普拉格宣称,唯一的“客观道德源泉”唯有《圣经》。他未曾提及的是:当父亲持刀刺杀时按住受害少女的母亲是位天主教徒,来自巴西——这个国家最著名的地标正是高达124英尺的“基督救世主”雕像。

“If There Is No God” is not the worst thing Prager has ever written. (That honor may go to a two-part op-ed from 2008, titled “When a Woman Isn’t in the Mood,” in which he explains why wives should have sex with their husbands even when they don’t feel like it.) That said, if Prager’s new book were a term paper, his teacher would have a lot to say. She might flag, for instance, that lack of symmetry between his argument and his choice of grisly anecdote. She might object to the tautological reasoning, or to the flagrant cultural animus and Islamophobia. Using terminology from the education world, she might say, politely, that Prager has many “areas of growth” as a student, or that his progress toward grade level is “emerging.”

《如果没有上帝》并非普拉格写过的最糟糕的东西。(这项“殊荣”可能要颁给他2008年发表的两篇专栏文章,题为《当妻子没有心情时》,文中他解释了为什么妻子即使没有心情也应该与丈夫发生性关系。)话虽如此,如果普拉格的新书是一篇学期论文,他的老师会有很多话要说。比如,老师可能会指出他的论点与所选骇人轶事之间缺乏对称性。她或许会反对其循环论证的逻辑,或是公然的文化敌意与伊斯兰恐惧症。借用教育界的术语,她可能会礼貌地说,普拉格作为学生还有许多“成长空间”,或者说他朝着年级水平的进步“正在显现”。

Yet Prager, a co-founder of the conservative education-media nonprofit PragerU, is one of the most influential voices in education in the United States today. PragerU is not an accredited university, but curriculum materials from its PragerU Kids division, on American history, civics, and financial literacy, are approved for optional classroom use in eleven mostly right-leaning states. (One of those states, Oklahoma, also worked with PragerU to develop a short-lived multiple-choice test intended to screen teachers for signs of “woke indoctrination.”) Last year, PragerU unveiled the Founders Museum, a “partnership” with the White House and the U.S. Department of Education featuring A.I.-generated video testimonials from luminaries of the American Revolution. These include a digitized John Adams who ventriloquizes the words of the right-wing influencer Ben Shapiro, almost verbatim: “Facts do not care about our feelings.”

然而,作为保守派教育媒体非营利组织“普拉格大学”(PragerU)的联合创始人,普拉格仍是当今美国教育界最具影响力的人物之一。普拉格大学并非认证高校,但其旗下“普拉格儿童”部门开发的美国历史、公民教育和财商素养课程材料,已在十一个偏保守派州获准作为选修教材使用。(其中俄克拉荷马州还曾与普拉格大学合作开发过一套昙花一现的标准化测试,旨在筛查教师是否存在“觉醒主义灌输”倾向。)去年,普拉格大学更与美国白宫及教育部“合作”推出了“建国者博物馆”,其中呈现由人工智能生成的美国开国元勋视频证言——包括数字化呈现的约翰·亚当斯,其口型竟与右翼网红本·夏皮罗的言论完全同步:“事实从不理会我们的感受。”

PragerU is also supplying the multimedia content for the Freedom Truck Mobile Museums, a travelling exhibition of touch-screen displays, Revolutionary War artifacts, and A.I. slop that will chug across the country on tractor-trailers throughout 2026, in celebration of the two-hundred-and-fiftieth anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. It seems that the battle over who defines good and evil—or, at least, over who defines American history—will be waged, in part, from the helm of an eighteen-wheeler.

普拉格大学还为“自由卡车移动博物馆”提供多媒体内容。这个巡回展览将配备触摸屏显示器、独立战争文物和人工智能生成的内容,计划在2026年驾驶半挂卡车穿越美国,以庆祝《独立宣言》发布二百五十周年。看来,关于谁定义善恶——或者至少是谁定义美国历史——的争夺战,将部分地在十八轮大卡车的驾驶座上展开。

Prager, who is seventy-seven, is an observant Jew who sees evangelical Christians as natural allies in his pursuit of “transforming America into a faith-based nation,” as he once wrote. (He has also lamented what he termed Jewish “bigotry” toward evangelical Christians, whose “support, and often even love, of the Jewish people and Israel is the most unrequited love I have ever seen on a large scale.”) In 2009, decades into a successful career in conservative talk radio, he co-founded PragerU, in order to provide what he called a “free alternative to the dominant left-wing ideology in culture, media, and education.” PragerU has received major funding from hard-right benefactors, including Betsy DeVos’s family foundation and the billionaire fracking brothers Dan and Farris Wilks. According to its most recent tax filing—which describes PragerU’s purpose as “marketing and producing educational content for all ages, 4-104, with a focus on a pro-American, Judeo-Christian message”—it received more than sixty-six million dollars in donations in 2024. (In November of that year, Prager sustained a severe spinal-cord injury in a fall that left him paralyzed below the shoulders; he has since resumed making video content for the PragerU website, and composed part of “If There Is No God” by dictation.)

现年七十七岁的普拉格是位虔诚的犹太教徒,他曾撰文将福音派基督徒视为实现“将美国转变为信仰之国”目标的天然盟友。(他也曾哀叹某些犹太人对待福音派基督徒的“偏见”,称后者“对犹太民族和以色列的支持乃至热爱,是我所见最大规模的无私奉献”。)2009年,在保守派谈话电台事业成功数十年后,他联合创立了普拉格大学,旨在提供“对抗文化、媒体和教育领域主导性左翼意识形态的免费替代方案”。该机构获得了极右翼资助者的大笔捐款,包括贝琪·德沃斯家族基金会及从事水力压裂业的亿万富豪威尔克斯兄弟——丹与法里斯。根据最新税务申报文件显示,普拉格大学2024年获得逾六千六百万美元捐款,其宗旨被描述为“面向4至104岁全年龄段人群制作推广教育内容,核心在于传递亲美立场与犹太-基督教价值观”。(同年11月,普拉格因跌倒导致严重脊髓损伤,肩部以下瘫痪;此后他仍持续为机构网站制作视频内容,并通过口述方式完成了《如果没有上帝》的部分章节。)

Prager’s nonprofit is just one of dozens of conservative organizations, many of them Christian, that are named as “partners” in the America 250 Civics Education Coalition, which is overseen by Linda McMahon, the Education Secretary. The coalition has the secular task of developing programming for America’s birthday, such as PragerU’s Founders Museum and the Freedom Trucks, the latter of which received a fourteen-million-dollar grant from the federal Institute of Museum and Library Services. (In March, President Trump signed executive orders to dismantle both the I.M.L.S. and the D.O.E.; they remain alive, albeit in shrunken, ideologized versions of their former selves.) Other America 250 partners include both of the major pro-Trump think tanks (the America First Policy Institute and the Heritage Foundation), a Christian liberal-arts school (Hillsdale College), the Supreme Court’s favorite conservative-Christian legal-advocacy group (the Alliance Defending Freedom), the Christian-right-aligned church of Charlie Kirk (Turning Point USA), and something called Priests for Life.

普拉格的非营利组织只是“美国250公民教育联盟”中数十个保守派组织之一,其中许多具有基督教背景。该联盟由教育部长琳达·麦克马洪监督,承担着为美国建国纪念日开发教育项目的世俗任务,例如普拉格大学的“建国者博物馆”和“自由卡车”项目——后者曾获得联邦博物馆与图书馆服务研究院1400万美元的拨款。(今年三月,特朗普总统签署行政令试图解散该研究院和教育部;目前这两个机构虽得以保留,却已规模缩减且意识形态色彩浓厚。)联盟其他合作伙伴还包括两大亲特朗普智库(美国优先政策研究所和传统基金会)、一所基督教文理学院(希尔斯代尔学院)、最高法院偏爱的保守派基督教法律倡导组织(捍卫自由联盟)、与基督教右翼结盟的查理·柯克所属教会(美国转折点),以及一个名为“生命祭司”的组织。

According to a D.O.E. press release, the America 250 coalition is “dedicated to renewing patriotism, strengthening civic knowledge, and advancing a shared understanding of America’s founding principles in schools across the nation.” Of course, one of America’s founding principles, taught in every civics class, is the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, which might seem to frown on the knitting together of so many religious organizations and public funds intended to advance civic education.

根据美国能源部的一份新闻稿,“美国250联盟”致力于“在全国各地的学校重振爱国主义、加强公民知识、推进对美国建国原则的共同理解”。当然,每个公民课都会讲授的美国建国原则之一,便是《第一修正案》中的政教分离条款——该条款似乎会对如此多宗教组织与旨在推进公民教育的公共资金紧密交织的状况表示不赞同。

“Real patriotic education,” McMahon said, at the opening of the Founders Museum last year, “means that, just as our founders loved and honored America, so we should honor them, while deeply learning and earnestly debating, still, their ideas.” One way to take McMahon up on this challenge is to deeply learn what James Madison wrote, in 1785, after a bill arose in Virginia’s General Assembly to establish a taxpayer provision for “Teachers of the Christian Religion.” In a petition to his colleagues in the Assembly, Madison asked, “Who does not see that the same authority which can establish Christianity, in exclusion of all other Religions, may establish with the same ease any particular sect of Christians, in exclusion of all other Sects?” He abhorred the proposal as “a melancholy mark” of “sudden degeneracy.” “Instead of holding forth an Asylum to the persecuted,” he wrote, “it is itself a signal of persecution.” A governing body that would permit such an incursion on the free exercise of religion was one that “may sweep away all our fundamental rights,” Madison warned. The bill died.

“真正的爱国主义教育,”麦克马洪去年在创始人博物馆开幕式上说,“意味着正如我们的建国先贤热爱并尊崇美国,我们也应当尊崇他们,同时深刻学习并认真辩论他们的思想。”回应麦克马洪这一挑战的方式之一,是深入研读詹姆斯·麦迪逊在1785年写下的文字——当时弗吉尼亚州议会提出一项法案,要为“基督教教师”设立纳税人供养条款。麦迪逊在致议会同僚的请愿书中质问道:“谁人不知,今日能以确立基督教而排斥其他一切宗教之权柄,他日便能以同等便利确立基督教中任一特定教派而排斥其他所有教派?”他痛斥该提案是“突然堕落”的“可悲标志”,并写道:“这非但未能为受迫害者提供庇护所,其本身正是迫害的信号。”麦迪逊警告说,一个允许如此侵犯宗教自由行使权的统治机构,终将“可能席卷我们所有基本权利”。该法案最终未能通过。

Although PragerU has won fans at the highest levels of federal and state government, its educational content and short-form videos are reviled across many chambers of the internet, where the Prager name—attached to videos with titles such as “DEI Must Die,” “Preferred Pronouns or Prison,” “Multiculturalism: A Bad Idea,” and “Is Fascism Right or Left?”—has become synonymous with MAGA-brand disinformation. (PragerU claims that its videos receive tens of millions of views per quarter, but these metrics have not been independently verified.) A PragerU Kids video called “How to Think Objectively,” which was reportedly shown in Houston public schools, provides the thinnest façade for a lesson in climate-change denial. Democratic socialism and, especially, immigration are scourges of the Prager-verse, which has attempted to undermine the constitutional provision of birthright citizenship and cranked out endless pro-ICE videos since the Department of Homeland Security began its violent occupations of Minneapolis and other major U.S. cities.

尽管普拉格大学在联邦和州政府最高层赢得了拥趸,其教育内容和短视频却在互联网的许多角落遭到唾弃——那些冠以“DEI必须消亡”、“用代词还是进监狱”、“多元文化主义:一个坏主意”、“法西斯主义是左还是右?”等标题的视频,已使“普拉格”这个名字成为“MAGA式虚假信息”的同义词。(普拉格大学宣称其视频每季度获得数千万观看量,但这些数据未经独立核实。)一部名为《如何客观思考》的普拉格儿童教育视频,在休斯顿公立学校播放时,为否认气候变化的课程内容披上了最单薄的外衣。在普拉格宇宙中,民主社会主义尤其是移民问题被视为灾祸——该机构不仅试图破坏宪法规定的出生公民权条款,更自国土安全部暴力进驻明尼阿波利斯等美国主要城市以来,源源不断地制作支持移民及海关执法局的宣传视频。

The most noxious PragerU videos often involve slavery. In the PragerU Kids series “Leo & Layla’s History Adventures,” animated versions of Frederick Douglass and Booker T. Washington are deputized to play down the historical significance of slavery; Christopher Columbus goes a step further, using slavery to introduce children to the concept of moral relativism. (“How can you come here to the fifteenth century and judge me by your standards in the twenty-first century?” Columbus asks.) A now deleted video—as bland as a corporate-compliance webinar, and scored to a generic hip-hop beat—gives Robert E. Lee a thumbs-up for crushing the attempted rebellion of enslaved people at Harper’s Ferry. The video also uncritically shares Lee’s view that slavery was harder on whites than on Black people, since “Blacks are immeasurably better off here than in Africa.”

普拉格大学最有害的视频往往涉及奴隶制。在普拉格大学儿童系列《利奥与莱拉的历史冒险》中,动画版弗雷德里克·道格拉斯和布克·T·华盛顿被征召来淡化奴隶制的历史意义;克里斯托弗·哥伦布则更进一步,用奴隶制向孩子们介绍道德相对主义的概念。(“你怎么能来到十五世纪,用你们二十一世纪的标准来评判我?”哥伦布问道。)一段现已删除的视频——平淡得像企业合规网络研讨会,配着千篇一律的嘻哈节拍——为罗伯特·E·李镇压哈珀斯费里奴隶起义的企图点赞。该视频还不加批判地分享了李的观点,即奴隶制对白人的伤害比对黑人更大,因为“黑人在这里比在非洲好得多”。

In terms of historical facts and narrative, the A.I. videos that PragerU produced for the Founders Museum offer nothing so repugnant. In fact, they offer close to nothing at all. Like a poorly trained large language model, John Adams filibusters on his bona fides, calling himself a “voice for independence” who believed in “telling the truth” and who “stood on principle.” The content is oddly content-free, and then it repeats. Thomas Jefferson, who never blinks, says, “We must guard liberty with learning.” Adams, who seems to be reading off a teleprompter, tells us, “Guard liberty well, for, once lost, it is lost forever.” Ben Franklin agrees: “Respect this founding, friend. It is your inheritance, hard-won and fragile. Guard it well.”

就历史事实与叙事而言,普拉格大学为创始人博物馆制作的AI视频并未呈现任何令人反感的内容。事实上,它们几乎什么内容都没有呈现。就像一个训练不足的大型语言模型,约翰·亚当斯滔滔不绝地自证清白,称自己是“为独立发声的人”,坚信“要说出真相”,且“坚守原则”。这些内容奇怪地空洞无物,随后又不断重复。从不眨眼的托马斯·杰斐逊说:“我们必须用学识守护自由。”似乎在读提词器的亚当斯告诉我们:“好好守护自由,因为一旦失去,就永远失去了。”本杰明·富兰克林附和道:“尊重这个建国基业吧,朋友。这是你们来之不易且脆弱的遗产。好好守护它。”

A commonality across all the PragerU videos, and distinctly those in the PragerU Kids catalogue, is their total aesthetic bankruptcy, their absence of beauty or joy or wit. It’s impossible to imagine anyone enjoying any of this or electing to watch it, not because it’s factually wrong or propagandistic but because it’s ugly and boring. The intentionality of the misinformation—or the absence of information—coupled with the laziness of the execution ties a perfect knot of contempt. The various characters in “How to Think Objectively” grimace and vocalize as if the woke mob had dosed them with tainted ketamine. The “Leo & Layla” render-farm animation of Martin Luther King, Jr., sways back and forth affectlessly, like a puppet on a stick, voiced by an actor doing a bad Jay-Z impression. Perhaps Dr. King is dissociating, and the viewer should follow his lead.

普拉格大学(PragerU)的所有视频,尤其是儿童目录下的那些,都有一个共同点:它们完全缺乏美学价值,毫无美感、乐趣或智慧可言。很难想象有人会喜欢这些东西,或者主动选择观看,不是因为它们事实错误或带有宣传色彩,而是因为它们丑陋又乏味。这种蓄意的误导——或者说信息的缺失——加上制作上的敷衍,完美地拧成了一股轻蔑的绳索。《如何客观思考》中的各色人物龇牙咧嘴、念念有词,仿佛被觉醒暴民灌了掺了氯胺酮的迷魂汤。在《利奥与莱拉》中,马丁·路德·金(Martin Luther King, Jr.)的渲染农场动画形象面无表情地左右摇摆,像根棍子上的提线木偶,配音演员则模仿着蹩脚的Jay-Z腔调。或许金博士正在神游天外,而观众也该学学他的样子。

In the Founders Museum, PragerU’s Chuck E. Cheese-ification of Presidents is hideous enough, but the animation deteriorates further as you click through to lesser-known revolutionaries, their mouths taking on the shape and muscular coördination of a Wombo A.I. The merchant Francis Lewis blankly recounts the death of his wife after her imprisonment by the British, and concludes, “Freedom demands much of us, but what it gives in return is everything.” Another Founder, Roger Sherman, intones, “I did my part. Now you must do yours.” It’s entirely unclear what the viewer is being asked to do, which may be the point. Dennis Prager once admitted that he didn’t mind accusations that PragerU indoctrinates its young viewers, saying, “We bring doctrines to children. That’s a very fair statement.” But perhaps indoctrination and stupefaction go hand in hand. Maybe reaching patriotic Judeo-Christian nirvana should feel like the unbearable lightness of an emptied mind. ♦

在“建国先贤博物馆”里,普拉格大学对总统们的查克芝士式呈现已经足够骇人,但当你点击那些不太知名的革命者时,动画质量更是急转直下——他们的嘴型与肌肉协调性简直像极了Wombo人工智能。商人弗朗西斯·刘易斯面无表情地讲述妻子被英军囚禁致死的经历,最后总结道:“自由向我们索求甚多,但它回馈的是一切。”另一位建国者罗杰·谢尔曼则用单调的语调宣告:“我已尽己所能。现在轮到你了。”观众完全不清楚自己被要求做什么——或许这正是关键所在。丹尼斯·普拉格曾坦言,他并不介意外界指责普拉格大学向年轻观众灌输思想,他说:“我们确实在向孩子们传授教义。这个说法非常公允。”但或许灌输教义与愚化心智本就是一体两面。通往爱国式犹太-基督教涅槃的体验,大概就该像被掏空思想的灵魂那般轻盈得令人难以承受。♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month