Infinite Scroll

The A.I.-Design Aesthetic That’s Taking Over the Internet

正在席卷互联网的AI设计美学
How Anthropic’s new tool, Claude Design, is creating overnight web-design clichés.
Anthropic的新工具Claude Design,如何在一夜之间制造出网页设计的陈词滥调。
Illustration of a conveyor belt producing a boring Claude website
Illustration by Ariel Davis

Matt Ström-Awn, an independent designer, works mostly with startups in their early stages. Recently, two different clients proudly showed him sales decks that they had produced to court customers. Both decks had a bright-colored first slide with a mission statement, written in three declarative bullet points. Both had second slides featuring four rectangles laying out “the playing field”—the market in which the startup was operating—and both had third slides with a centered line of text reading “our move” and describing the startup’s disruptive tactic. “They actually look like they were generated by the same company,” Ström-Awn told me. “The logo is different, but the design is the same.” The decks looked the same because both were made using Claude Design, an A.I. tool that Anthropic launched in April. The new technology, Ström-Awn said, “defaults to the same aesthetic for every single person that’s using it.”

独立设计师马特·斯特罗姆-奥恩(Matt Ström-Awn)的客户大多是早期创业公司。最近,两位不同的客户得意地向他展示了自己制作的销售演示文稿。两份文稿的第一页都是亮色背景,上面用三条宣言式的要点写着使命陈述;第二页都有四个矩形框,勾勒出“竞技场”——也就是这家创业公司所处的市场;第三页都有一行居中文字写着“我们的招数”,描述这家公司的颠覆性策略。“它们看起来简直像同一家公司做的,”斯特罗姆-奥恩告诉我,“Logo不同,但设计一模一样。”这两份演示文稿之所以雷同,是因为它们都是用Claude Design制作的——这是Anthropic今年四月推出的一款AI工具。斯特罗姆-奥恩说,这项新技术“给每个使用者都默认套上了同一种美学”。

As Claude Design catches on among Anthropic users, a generic-design aesthetic is emerging that’s as noticeable as text-based A.I. tics such as overenthusiastic em-dash usage or “not X . . . but Y” constructions. In slide decks and on website interfaces, there’s a predominance of beige- and cream-colored backgrounds, rusty orange-hued accents, and large serif typefaces that are italicized and highlighted in zealous attempts to emphasize. Subheadings are often “tracked out,” in design parlance, with spaces between the letters, and there’s an inexplicable prevalence of ticker-like text bars, as if the website were a cable-news show. Another designer I spoke to, David McGillivray, pointed out how Claude often creates dashboard elements with multiple rounded rectangular outlines, sometimes with a neon glow underneath for good measure. The designer and writer Celine Nguyen identified a combination of “tasteful, slightly askew primary colors,” desaturated hues redolent of mid-century modernist design. Such qualities might be unobjectionable, even desirable, in and of themselves, but their ubiquitous appearance across the internet has turned them into instant design clichés. “Now I find myself instinctively repulsed by the warm tones even though I love this kind of color palette,” Nguyen said.

随着Claude Design在Anthropic用户中流行起来,一种千篇一律的设计美学正在浮现,其显眼程度不亚于文本类AI的那些癖好——比如过度热衷使用破折号,或者“不是X……而是Y”的句式。在演示文稿和网站界面上,米色和奶油色的背景铺天盖地,铁锈橙色的点缀随处可见,大号衬线字体被斜体加粗,以一种近乎狂热的姿态试图强调重点。用设计行话来说,小标题常常被“拉开字距”,字母之间留有空格;还有一种令人费解的普遍现象——滚动文字条泛滥,仿佛每个网站都是有线新闻频道。我采访的另一位设计师大卫·麦吉利夫雷(David McGillivray)指出,Claude经常创建带有多个圆角矩形边框的仪表盘元素,有时还会在底下加上一层霓虹光晕,生怕不够醒目。设计师兼作家赛琳·阮(Celine Nguyen)则识别出一种“雅致而略微偏斜的原色”组合,那些低饱和度的色调让人想起二十世纪中叶的现代主义设计。这些特质本身或许无可指摘,甚至值得追求,但当它们在整个互联网上无处不在时,就瞬间变成了设计的陈词滥调。“现在我发现自己本能地对这些暖色调感到排斥,尽管我其实很喜欢这种配色,”阮说。

Newsletrix, a newsletter-analytics dashboard; Wesley Wang Media, a production house; GrassDX, a tool for diagnosing problems with your lawn; Haute Living, a real-estate-agent directory; and DeployGraph, a research firm on A.I. companies—these are just a few of the companies whose sites bear a Claudian sameness. This is not an entirely new problem in web design. In the early days of the internet, HTML code and the need to design simple, small-size sites downloadable on dial-up led many hosts to adhere to a strict, basic palette. Eventually, website-building services such as WordPress, Squarespace, and Wix offered templates that became popular clichés of their own (think of sans-serif text over full-bleed splash images). But A.I. tools instill a particularly swift and stubborn genericism. Anthropic concedes as much in its guidance documents, noting that, when left to its own devices, Claude’s model “has strong design instincts, with a consistent default house style. . . . This default is persistent.” Not coincidentally, this default has a lot in common with Anthropic’s own branding—beigey backgrounds, off-red highlight colors, big typefaces, lots of serifs and underlines. The company notes that giving the program “generic instructions” such as “don’t use cream” is likely to “shift the model to a different fixed palette rather than producing variety.” In other words, the user has to fight to produce visuals that stray from the formula. As Ström-Awn put it, “The preferences and tendencies and aesthetics are deeply baked into its machinery; it is always going to struggle to produce something that doesn’t look like A.I.” (An Anthropic spokesperson told The New Yorker that Claude Design should ideally be able to deviate from a “standard look,” when users prefer it. “This doesn’t always happen the way we’d like and the team is working hard to improve it,” he said.)

Newsletrix,一个新闻通讯分析仪表盘;Wesley Wang Media,一家制作公司;GrassDX,一个诊断草坪问题的工具;Haute Living,一个房地产经纪人目录;DeployGraph,一家研究AI公司的调研机构——这些只是众多网站中的几个例子,它们都带有一种克劳德式的雷同。这在网页设计中并非全新问题。互联网早期,HTML代码的限制,以及设计出能通过拨号上网下载的简洁小尺寸网站的需求,让许多主机服务商固守一套严格而基础的调色板。后来,WordPress、Squarespace和Wix等建站服务提供了模板,这些模板也成了风靡一时的陈词滥调(想想全屏 splash 图片上叠加无衬线文字的样式)。但AI工具催生了一种格外迅速且顽固的通用性。Anthropic在自己的指导文件中也不讳言这一点,指出当放任自流时,Claude的模型“有着强烈的设计直觉,带有一贯的默认风格……这种默认是持久不变的”。并非巧合的是,这种默认风格与Anthropic自身的品牌形象有很多共通之处——米色背景、偏红的强调色、大号字体、大量的衬线和下划线。该公司指出,给程序下达“通用指令”,比如“不要用奶油色”,很可能只会“让模型切换到另一套固定的调色板,而不是产生多样性”。换句话说,用户必须费一番力气,才能产出偏离公式的视觉作品。正如斯特罗姆-奥恩所说:“那些偏好、倾向和美学已经深深嵌入它的机制之中;它永远都会挣扎于产出不像AI的东西。”(Anthropic的一位发言人告诉《纽约客》,理想情况下,当用户希望时,Claude Design应该能够偏离“标准外观”。“这并不总能如我们所愿地实现,团队正在努力改进,”他说。)

In addition to reinforcing graphic-design tropes, Claude Design tends to direct all of its users toward the same libraries of open-source code, the tools behind user-interface design. Shadcn UI and Radix UI provide ready-made building blocks for websites; Drizzle manages databases. Lucas Gelfond, a software engineer, likened the uniformity that these products encourage to the effects of mass manufacturing following the Industrial Revolution. Automated industrial processes left signatures: “seams on injection-molded plastic, industrial saw marks in wood,” Gelfond said. “I think about a lot of the tells in L.L.M.-generated software—bright accent serifs, overuse of dots, dividing characters, and emojis, high-contrast indicators—as similar marks of the tool.”

除了强化平面设计的套路,Claude Design还倾向于将所有用户引向相同的开源代码库——那些用户界面设计背后的工具。Shadcn UI和Radix UI为网站提供现成的构建模块;Drizzle负责管理数据库。软件工程师卢卡斯·盖尔方德(Lucas Gelfond)将这类产品所鼓励的千篇一律,比作工业革命后大规模制造带来的影响。自动化工业流程留下了痕迹:“注塑塑料上的接缝,木材上的工业锯痕,”盖尔方德说。“我认为大语言模型生成的软件中,很多破绽——亮色的衬线强调、过度使用的圆点、分隔符和表情符号、高对比度的指示符——都是类似的工具印记。”

The advent of A.I. has caused Silicon Valley types to fixate on the concept of “taste”; when machines can spit out images and words instantaneously, the thinking goes, humans must be discerning enough to separate the quality output from the slop. Ström-Awn described Claude’s default design choices as a mark of complacency, “a filtering mechanism” that exposes “people who didn’t spend the time” creating something unique. Nguyen brought up a credo of the mid-century American designers Charles and Ray Eames that defined the ideals of modernism: “The best for the most for the least.” What Claude Design offers, Nguyen said, is “the pretty good for the most for the least effort, and pretty low cost.” She continued, “You’re just paying a twenty dollar a month Claude Pro subscription instead of hiring a designer. Is this the modernist world we wanted?”

AI的出现让硅谷人士痴迷于“品味”这个概念;他们的逻辑是,当机器能瞬间吐出图像和文字时,人类必须足够有辨别力,才能将优质产出与垃圾区分开来。斯特罗姆-奥恩将Claude的默认设计选择描述为一种自满的标志,“一个过滤机制”,暴露了“那些没有花时间”去创造独特东西的人。阮提到了二十世纪中叶美国设计师查尔斯·伊姆斯和蕾·伊姆斯夫妇(Charles and Ray Eames)的一句信条,它定义了现代主义的理想:“以最少的花费,为最多的人提供最好的东西。”阮说,Claude Design所提供的,是“以最少的努力和相当低的成本,为最多的人提供还不错的东西”。她接着说:“你只是每月花二十美元订阅Claude Pro,而不是雇一个设计师。这就是我们想要的现代主义世界吗?”

Notably, none of the designers I spoke to are against A.I. altogether. All of them said that the technology is unavoidable, and shared that it’s possible to use A.I. tools such as Claude Design and OpenAI’s Codex to achieve a distinctive look, if you’re willing to put in the labor. Hilary Gridley is the founder of Writerbuilder, a newsletter focussed on A.I., and she previously worked as the head of core product at the A.I. wearable company Whoop. “Most people don’t want to go through a full creative process,” she told me, adding, “There’s no easy button for good work.” Gridley sometimes uses A.I.-generated bird illustrations in her own branding. To produce a finished product, she assembles mood boards of inspirational material and sketches out drafts of the illustrations by hand, then she feeds that material into an image generator along with a description of the final art she envisions. The result is highly textured A.I. imagery that could be mistaken for handmade. Loredana Crisan, the chief design officer of Figma, a popular digital product-design app that integrates A.I. features, told me, “The job of the designer is to stay with uncertainty long enough to discover something new.”

值得注意的是,我采访的设计师中没有一个人完全反对AI。他们都说这项技术不可避免,并且都认同,只要你愿意付出劳动,是有可能用Claude Design和OpenAI的Codex这类AI工具实现独特视觉风格的。希拉里·格里德利(Hilary Gridley)是专注于AI的新闻通讯Writerbuilder的创始人,此前曾在AI可穿戴设备公司Whoop担任核心产品负责人。“大多数人并不想经历完整的创作过程,”她告诉我,并补充道,“做好工作没有捷径按钮。”格里德利有时会在自己的品牌设计中使用AI生成的鸟类插画。为了产出成品,她会先收集灵感素材的情绪板,手绘出插画草图,然后将这些素材连同对最终画面构想的描述,一起输入图像生成器。最终得到的是质感丰富、可能被误认为是手工作品的AI图像。热门数字产品设计应用Figma整合了AI功能,其首席设计官洛雷丹娜·克里桑(Loredana Crisan)告诉我:“设计师的职责,就是在不确定性中停留足够长的时间,以发现新的东西。”

Anthropic’s recent branding choices suggest an effort to sidestep its own visual clichés. Its latest model, Fable 5—launched this month, then quickly suspended after the U.S. government cited national-security concerns—features marketing imagery comprising collaged vintage illustrations of insects, flowers, and other scientific ephemera. They call to mind the nineteenth-century moth illustrations of the French botanist and geologist Charles Dessalines d’Orbigny, source material that is redolent of human knowledge and the organic world. Even that new aesthetic is liable to become absorbed by the machine, however. As Gridley put it, “I wouldn’t be surprised if we saw that design showing up everywhere.” ♦

Anthropic近期的品牌选择,似乎是在努力避开自己制造的视觉陈词滥调。其最新模型Fable 5——本月发布,后因美国政府以国家安全为由而迅速暂停——的宣传图像采用了拼贴风格的复古插画,内容包含昆虫、花卉和其他科学相关的短暂事物。它们让人想起十九世纪法国植物学家兼地质学家夏尔·德萨林·多比尼(Charles Dessalines d’Orbigny)的飞蛾插画,这些原始素材散发着人类知识和有机世界的气息。然而,即便是这种新美学,也难逃被机器吸收的命运。正如格里德利所说:“如果看到那种设计到处出现,我一点也不会惊讶。” ♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month