This Week in Fiction

Min Jin Lee on Exams and Hagwons

李敏金谈考试与补习班
The author discusses her story “Testing.”
作者谈她的短篇小说《应试》。
A photo of Min Jin Lee in blue. The background has some cursive writing on a green background.
Illustration by The New Yorker; Source photograph by Hae Ran

In your story “Testing,” Bo Koh, a young Korean man who has grown up partly in the U.S. and Australia, is studying for the Suneung, an intensive, daylong university-entrance exam that dictates not only which university a student can attend but often the entire course of that student’s professional life. What made you want to take a look at the Suneung process in fiction?

在你的小说《应试》中,高博是一个在韩国、美国和澳大利亚长大的年轻韩裔男子,正在备战修能考试——一场决定学生能上哪所大学、甚至往往决定其整个职业生涯的密集型全天大学入学考试。是什么让你想在虚构作品中审视修能考试的过程?

Taking the Suneung is a rite of passage for a Korean high-school student who wants to obtain a four-year college education. Although there are ways to be accepted into a four-year college without taking the Suneung, it is the primary path for regular admissions. Despite sensationalized accounts of “killer questions,” planes being grounded for thirty-five minutes so that the nation can be silent during the examinees’ English-listening-comprehension sections, and mothers praying fervently on the third Thursday of November, the Suneung is not necessarily an impossible exam for everyone; its challenges depend on which university the student wishes to attend.

参加修能考试,是韩国高中生想要获得四年制大学教育的一场成人礼。虽然不参加修能也有办法被四年制大学录取,但它是正规招生的主要途径。尽管媒体对“杀手级题目”、为让考生在英语听力部分享有绝对安静而让全国飞机停飞三十五分钟、以及母亲们在十一月第三个星期四虔诚祈祷等现象进行了耸人听闻的报道,修能对每个人来说未必是一场不可能完成的考试;它的挑战取决于学生想上哪所大学。

The exam is indisputably difficult for highly selective schools such as Seoul National, Korea University, and Yonsei, which are collectively referred to by the acronym SKY. While I was writing my novel “American Hagwon,” from which this story was adapted—a novel about family, modern parenting, and education in an era circumscribed by global economic shocks and rapid change—every ethnic Korean I encountered questioned the value of higher education and its human cost. Taking the Suneung is a very different experience from taking the SAT or the ACT, and I wanted to portray the drama of this test through my character, Bo, who felt that he had to get into a SKY school.

对于首尔大学、高丽大学和延世大学这类选拔极其严格的名校——它们被合称为“SKY”——这场考试的难度是无可争议的。我在写长篇小说《美国补习班》(这篇故事即改编自该小说)期间——这是一部关于家庭、现代育儿以及在全球经济震荡和快速变革时代下的教育的小说——我遇到的每一位韩裔都在质疑高等教育的价值及其人力代价。参加修能考试与参加SAT或ACT考试是完全不同的体验,我想通过我的角色博来描绘这场考试中的戏剧性,他觉得自己必须考上SKY级别的学校。

Bo spends three years preparing for and taking the Suneung (three times). His persistence doesn’t make a lot of sense to those around him, given that he has U.S. citizenship and could pursue his education in a much less restrictive environment there. Why do you think he insists on it?

博花了三年时间备考并参加了修能考试(共三次)。他的坚持在周围人看来不太合理,因为他有美国公民身份,完全可以在一个限制少得多的环境中求学。你觉得他为什么执意如此?

Bo was born in New Jersey while his father, John, was working in the New York area. Owing to his father’s career, Bo and his two siblings went to school in New Jersey, Sydney, and Seoul. Bo, the eldest, identifies strongly with Korea, and although he is by birth a U.S. citizen, he wants to know what his life would have been like if he had been born in Seoul and stayed put there. Bo seeks a kind of stamp to prove his authenticity as a Korean, and he feels that going through with this exam, which even some native-born Koreans are loath to take, will provide that. Bo is a deeply principled young person, and I admire him enormously, but the high-achieving student can sometimes suffer from hubris, rigidity, and impracticality. That said, I respect his stubbornness and anxieties.

博出生在新泽西州,当时他父亲约翰在纽约地区工作。由于父亲的职业,博和他的两个弟妹先后在新泽西、悉尼和首尔上学。作为长子,博对韩国有着强烈的认同感,尽管他生来就是美国公民,但他想知道如果自己出生在首尔并一直留在那里,生活会是什么样子。博在寻求一种印记,来证明自己作为韩国人的真实性,他觉得坚持考完这场连一些土生土长的韩国人都不愿参加的考试,就能提供这种证明。博是一个极有原则的年轻人,我非常欣赏他,但成绩优异的学生有时也会因骄傲、僵化和不切实际而受苦。话虽如此,我尊重他的固执和焦虑。

In South Korea, almost eighty per cent of children regularly attend a hagwon—a private-tutoring center that supplements their schooling and prepares them for tests—which means that many kids are spending up to twelve hours a day in a classroom. Hagwons are central to “Testing,” and to “American Hagwon,” which comes out in late September. What do you think of the hagwon system?

在韩国,近八成孩子定期参加补习班——一种补充学校课程、帮学生备考的私人辅导机构——这意味着许多孩子每天在教室里待的时间长达十二小时。补习班是《应试》以及将于九月底出版的《美国补习班》的核心内容。你对补习班制度怎么看?

I didn’t attend Korean hagwons as a child. My mother, a former music teacher, believes that you cannot force a child to study. My sisters and I were allowed to decide how we wanted to learn. In my junior year of high school, I asked my parents for money to take a Princeton Review course, because several students I knew were preparing with Princeton Review materials, and my parents gave it to me. In college, I taught the verbal section of the SAT for the Princeton Review company for one semester as a part-time job. Kumon, Princeton Review, and Stanley Kaplan are commonly known hagwons in the U.S., and most students from middle- to upper-income families at some point encounter them.

我小时候没有上过韩式补习班。我母亲曾是一名音乐老师,她认为不能强迫孩子学习。我和姐妹们被允许自己决定怎么学。高二那年,我问父母要钱去上普林斯顿评论的课程,因为我认识的几个学生都在用普林斯顿评论的教材备考,父母把钱给了我。大学期间,我在普林斯顿评论公司教了一个学期的SAT语文部分,作为兼职。公文式、普林斯顿评论和斯坦利·卡普兰在美国是广为人知的补习机构,大多数来自中高收入家庭的学生在某个阶段都会接触到它们。

In Korea, hagwons are far more integrated into society—for children at a much younger age and not necessarily for one specific exam. Hagwons, which are for-profit learning centers, are often seen as a kind of “shadow education” to formal schools. Many people criticize hagwons but, as an American, I feel reluctant to do so. Korea’s fast-changing society requires a great deal from parents and families, without providing many social protections, and I think hagwons are a by-product of that society’s growing demands, of globalization, of neoliberalism, and of a Confucian culture that is still attached to the meritocratic value found in exams. There are many, many different kinds of hagwon, and the more I visited them and observed the communities around them the less I could generalize their role in Korean society. Some were unappealing, and others made a great deal of sense, but each addressed a specific kind of need for children, parents, families, tutors, consultants, educators, and schools. The hagwon economy is also a multibillion-dollar business that employs many people.

在韩国,补习班与社会的融合程度要高得多——面向年龄小得多的孩子,而且未必是为了某一场特定考试。补习班是营利性学习中心,常被视为正规学校的一种“影子教育”。很多人批评补习班,但作为一个美国人,我不太愿意这样做。韩国快速变化的社会对父母和家庭提出了极高要求,却没有提供多少社会保护,我认为补习班是这个社会日益增长的需求、全球化、新自由主义,以及一种仍然依附于考试中的贤能主义价值观的儒家文化的副产品。补习班有非常多种不同的类型,我越是走访它们、观察它们周围的社群,就越难笼统地概括它们在韩国社会中的角色。有些令人反感,另一些则非常合理,但每一种都回应了孩子、父母、家庭、辅导老师、顾问、教育者和学校的某种特定需求。补习班经济也是一个价值数十亿美元、雇佣了大量人员的产业。

“American Hagwon” follows Bo and his family, the Kohs, through many stages of their lives—economic difficulties, educational struggles, the complications of emigration and immigration, and more. Did you know from the start that the novel would focus on one family?

《美国补习班》跟随博和他的高氏一家,经历了他们人生的许多阶段——经济困难、教育挣扎、移居与移民的复杂处境等等。你从一开始就知道这部小说会聚焦于一个家庭吗?

From the beginning, I knew that there would be a hagwon in America with two spirited teachers, and that they would have a specific philosophy about education. From them, I found the Kohs, my central family, and their community.

从一开始,我就知道会有一所位于美国的补习班,里面有两位充满热情的老师,他们对教育有一套特定的理念。从他们出发,我找到了高氏一家,我的核心家庭,以及他们的社群。

Were you at all inspired by your own family’s trajectory when thinking about the Kohs’ journey?

在构思高氏一家的历程时,你是否从自己家庭的轨迹中获得了启发?

I am continually inspired by my family’s trajectory, because I remain interested in the condition of diaspora, its causes and effects. My family has experienced numerous socioeconomic changes, and now that I am fifty-seven years old with a family of my own, I am humbled by how my parents and ancestors managed so many unexpected, cataclysmic events and somehow kept us together.

我不断从自己家庭的轨迹中获得启发,因为我始终对流散的状态、它的成因和后果感兴趣。我的家庭经历了无数次社会经济变迁,如今我五十七岁,有了自己的家庭,想到我的父母和祖辈如何应对那么多意想不到的灾难性事件,还设法把我们凝聚在一起,我深感谦卑。

“Testing” is both a work of fiction and, to some degree, a social commentary. Which comes first for you, the story or the sociology?

《应试》既是一部虚构作品,在某种程度上也是一篇社会评论。对你来说,故事和社会学,哪个先来?

For me, the metaphysical questions always come first, and the story emerges organically from the questions. I grew up reading social novels from the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, and they made me curious about what would happen to each of us in a society. I find that I can best explore my questions by following characters as they make choices and take actions, even as events beyond their control disrupt their best-laid plans. My characters have desires, obstacles, and time, but, like us, they live in an organized society, and I am fascinated by how they relate to their world and their fate within it.

对我来说,形而上的问题总是先来,故事则从这些问题中有机地生长出来。我从小读十九世纪和二十世纪初的社会小说,它们让我好奇我们每个人在一个社会中会遭遇什么。我发现,通过跟随人物做出选择和采取行动,即使在他们无法控制的事件打乱他们精心制定的计划时,我也能最好地探索我的问题。我的人物有欲望、有障碍、有时间,但和我们一样,他们生活在一个有组织的社会中,我着迷于他们如何与自己的世界相处,以及他们在其中的命运。

As much as I love literature, art, classics, languages, music, religion, and history, the more I read and write the more I want to understand how those abiding loves relate to the social sciences—sociology, psychology, economics, politics, and anthropology. I believe that literature is interdisciplinary, and, when I write social novels, this integration becomes clearer to me. ♦

尽管我热爱文学、艺术、古典学、语言、音乐、宗教和历史,但我读得越多、写得越多,就越想理解这些持久的爱如何与社会科学——社会学、心理学、经济学、政治学和人类学——相关联。我相信文学是跨学科的,而当我写社会小说时,这种融合对我来说变得更加清晰。 ♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month