Profiles

How Paweł Pawlikowski Learned to Film Europe’s Fractures

帕维尔·帕夫利科夫斯基如何学会拍摄欧洲的裂痕
The Polish director has made a career out of examining the mysteries of borders, both spiritual and political.
这位波兰导演的职业生涯,始终在审视边界的奥秘——无论是精神上的,还是政治上的。
A portrait of a person.
Photograph by Yiorgos Kaplanidis for The New Yorker

The first thing you notice about the film director Paweł Pawlikowski is that he looks like a movie star. This is an unusual state of affairs. As a rule, if you happen to be—as Pawlikowski is—demonstrably tall, dark, and handsome, with a flexible sense of humor, a yen for cinema, and industrial quantities of charisma, your rightful spot is smack dab in front of the camera. So why go and lurk behind it? Why didn’t Pawlikowski become an actor? “Oh, no, I’m a terrible actor,” he says. “I never know what to do with my eyebrows.”

你注意到电影导演帕维尔·帕夫利科夫斯基(Paweł Pawlikowski)的第一件事,是他长得像电影明星。这是件不寻常的事。通常来说,如果你像帕夫利科夫斯基那样——显而易见地高大、黝黑、英俊,幽默感灵活多变,痴迷电影,魅力值达到工业级——你理所当然的位置是正对摄影机。那为什么要躲到摄影机后面去呢?帕夫利科夫斯基为什么没当演员?“哦,不行,我是个糟糕透顶的演员,”他说,“我从来不知道该怎么处理我的眉毛。”

These days, having recently turned sixty-nine, Pawlikowski has a dusting of gray in his hair and his stubble—the annoying effect of which is to render him more, not less, like the very model of a leading man. It made complete sense, as we walked together down a street in Sarajevo, in Bosnia, when a young woman in a white dress ran ahead of us, turned around, explained that she was an actress at the National Theatre, and professed her adoration for Pawlikowski’s work. He smiled, thanked her graciously, and moved on. That kind of thing must happen all the time to Keanu Reeves, but few directors—especially middle-aged Polish directors—can be guaranteed the same treatment.

如今,刚过六十九岁的帕夫利科夫斯基,头发和胡茬里添了一层灰白——恼人的效果是让他看起来更像男主角的典范,而非相反。我们在波斯尼亚的萨拉热窝街头同行时,一个穿白裙的年轻女子跑到我们前面,转过身来,解释自己是国家剧院的演员,并表达了对帕夫利科夫斯基作品的崇拜。他微笑着,彬彬有礼地道谢,然后继续前行。这种事对基努·里维斯来说肯定天天发生,但很少有导演——尤其是中年的波兰导演——能保证享受同等待遇。

We were in Sarajevo, in the middle of August, because Pawlikowski’s latest movie, “Fatherland,” was opening the city’s annual film festival. On the first evening, it showed in multiple venues. The screening times were staggered, allowing Pawlikowski to hurry from one place to the next and introduce his film. I caught it outside, at the refreshingly named Coca-Cola Open Air Cinema, after night fell. Arriving onstage, in a white shirt and jeans, Pawlikowski bade welcome to “the people in the balcony over there,” who were watching for free from nearby apartments. He told us that “Fatherland” is “about history, how it repeats itself, about family, love, betrayal, and so on. And the good thing is, it’s not very long.” Eighty-two minutes, to be exact. These days, when a visit to the cinema can be an endurance test, such brevity puts “Fatherland” ahead of the pack before it’s even begun.

八月中旬,我们来到萨拉热窝,因为帕夫利科夫斯基的新片《祖国》(Fatherland)正在为这座城市的年度电影节揭幕。首晚,影片在多个场地放映。场次错开安排,让帕夫利科夫斯基可以从一个地方赶到另一个地方,逐一介绍他的电影。夜幕降临后,我在名字令人神清气爽的可口可乐露天影院看了这部片子。帕夫利科夫斯基穿着白衬衫和牛仔裤走上舞台,向“那边阳台上的观众”致意——他们正从附近的公寓里免费观看。他告诉我们,《祖国》“关于历史,关于它如何重演,关于家庭、爱情、背叛,等等。好消息是,它不太长。”确切地说,八十二分钟。如今,去电影院可能是一场耐力考验,这样的简洁让《祖国》还没开场就已领先一筹。

The family that Pawlikowski had in mind is the family of Mann—the novelist and Nobel laureate Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler), that is, who, in 1949, heads back to his native Germany from the United States, where he has spent the wartime years. One reason for his return is the bicentenary of the birth of Goethe, on whom Mann has been invited to lecture. Now in his seventies, he is accompanied throughout the trip by his eldest daughter, Erika. (She is played by Sandra Hüller, whom American audiences last saw in “Project Hail Mary,” a movie almost twice as long as “Fatherland.”) She shaves her father in the morning, picks out his clothes, and drives him around in a stately Buick, as black and as gleaming as a hearse. Starting in West Germany, in Frankfurt, they cross to the Communist East, making for Goethe’s home town of Weimar. Wherever he goes, Mann is exhorted to pledge his allegiance. The choice confronting him is voiced, with sardonic fatigue, by his son Klaus (August Diehl), during a phone call with Erika, near the start of the film: “Stalin or Mickey Mouse?”

帕夫利科夫斯基心中的那个家庭,是曼氏家族——即小说家、诺贝尔奖得主托马斯·曼(汉斯·齐施勒 Hanns Zischler 饰)。1949年,他从度过了战争岁月的美国返回祖国德国。他此行的一个原因是歌德诞辰两百周年,曼受邀就此发表演讲。年过七旬的他,全程由长女艾丽卡陪同。(艾丽卡由桑德拉·惠勒 Sandra Hüller 饰演,美国观众上次见到她是在《万福玛利亚计划》中,那部电影的时长几乎是《祖国》的两倍。)她早上为父亲刮脸,挑选衣服,开着一辆气派的别克车带他四处奔波——那车漆黑锃亮,像一辆灵车。他们从西德的法兰科夫出发,穿越到共产党治下的东德,前往歌德的故乡魏玛。无论走到哪里,曼都被敦促表态效忠。摆在他面前的选择,由他的儿子克劳斯(奥古斯特·迪尔 August Diehl 饰)在影片开头与艾丽卡通电话时,以一种疲惫的讽刺口吻道出:“斯大林还是米老鼠?”

“Fatherland,” which opens in America on October 23rd, is the third in a triptych of works in which Pawlikowski has explored the mystery of borders, geographical and spiritual, like a doctor tenderly probing an unhealed wound. Before “Fatherland” came “Cold War” (2018), and before that was “Ida” (2014). All three films last less than an hour and a half. All three are in black-and-white, and shot in the Academy ratio—a squarish format that tightens the action and pulls it about as far from IMAX as you can get. And all three make minimal use of a moving camera; one of Pawlikowski’s inspirations for “Ida,” he told me, was his family photograph albums, five of which he has borne with him throughout a peripatetic existence. Lives can be distilled into stills.

《祖国》将于10月23日在美国上映,是帕夫利科夫斯基三联画中的第三部。在这组作品中,他像一位医生温柔地探查未愈的伤口,探索地理与精神边界的奥秘。在《祖国》之前是《冷战》(2018),再之前是《修女艾达》(2014)。三部影片都不到一个半小时。三部都是黑白片,采用学院比例拍摄——一种接近方形的画幅,收紧画面动作,把观众拉到离IMAX尽可能远的地方。三部影片都极少使用运动镜头;帕夫利科夫斯基告诉我,《修女艾达》的灵感之一来自他的家庭相册,五本相册伴随他度过了漂泊的一生。人生可以被浓缩为静照。

“Cold War,” like “Fatherland,” sets off in 1949. It traces the progress of a lengthy love affair, difficult and torn, from Poland to Berlin, Paris, and Yugoslavia, before circling back to Poland. The film earned Pawlikowski the prize for Best Director at the Cannes Film Festival, and was nominated for three Academy Awards, including Best Foreign Film. By then, it’s fair to say, he was getting full value from his tuxedo. “Ida,” the all-consuming tale of a Polish novice nun who discovers, before taking her vows, that her heritage is Jewish, and who travels in search of her past in the company of her formidable aunt, had been nominated for the same Oscar four years before. On the big night, February 22, 2015, “Ida” struck gold. Pawlikowski accepted his statuette from Chiwetel Ejiofor and Nicole Kidman, wiped his brow, and addressed the shining throng. “Oh, God, how did I get here?” he said. Good question.

《冷战》与《祖国》一样,从1949年开始。它追溯一段漫长恋情的轨迹,艰难而撕裂,从波兰到柏林、巴黎、南斯拉夫,最后绕回波兰。这部电影为帕夫利科夫斯基赢得了戛纳电影节最佳导演奖,并获得三项奥斯卡提名,包括最佳外语片。到那时,可以说,他的燕尾服已经物尽其用了。《修女艾达》——一个令人全神贯注的故事,讲述一位波兰见习修女在宣誓前发现自己有犹太血统,在令人生畏的姨妈陪伴下踏上寻访过去之旅——四年前就获得了同一项奥斯卡提名。2015年2月22日那个大日子,《修女艾达》摘得金像。帕夫利科夫斯基从切瓦特·埃加福特和妮可·基德曼手中接过小金人,擦了擦额头,对满堂璀璨的宾客说:“天哪,我是怎么走到这里的?”问得好。

Pawlikowski was born in Warsaw in 1957. His mother, Zula, was a ballet dancer from a Catholic background. As he told me, “All my Christmases, everything with my mother’s family, was very old-fashioned, high bourgeoisie.” Later, Zula became a lecturer in English at the University of Warsaw. His father, Wiktor, was a doctor, “funny guy, very witty,” and, to all appearances, entirely secular. “I didn’t have a clue my father was actually Jewish,” Pawlikowski said. Not until he was in his teens did he learn that his father’s mother had died in Auschwitz. Apart from one relative who later moved to Israel, he told me, “they were all wiped out in the war.”

帕夫利科夫斯基1957年生于华沙。母亲祖拉(Zula)是芭蕾舞演员,出身天主教家庭。他告诉我:“我所有的圣诞节,和母亲家人在一起的一切,都非常老派,高级资产阶级做派。”后来,祖拉成为华沙大学的英语讲师。父亲维克托(Wiktor)是医生,“有趣的人,非常机智”,从表面上看,完全世俗化。“我完全不知道我父亲其实是犹太人,”帕夫利科夫斯基说。直到十几岁,他才得知父亲的母亲死于奥斯维辛。除了一个后来移居以色列的亲戚,他告诉我,“他们全都在战争中丧生了。”

To judge by photographs of Zula and Wiktor in the Pawlikowski family albums, they made a radiant couple. In one formal portrait, they pose together in sunlight, lifting their bronzed faces to the rays. As befits the only child of such deities, the young Paweł, glimpsed in a series of snapshots, is all smiles. This, you tell yourself, is not someone who grew up with no handle on happiness. Some of the films that he went on to create, as an adult, may be dark to behold, and shaded with desolation, but the darkness is never willful or worked up. At the same time, you get the sense that only a fool would not expect paradise to get lost.

从帕夫利科夫斯基家庭相册中祖拉和维克托的照片来看,他们是一对光彩照人的夫妻。在一张正式肖像中,他们并肩站在阳光下,仰起古铜色的脸庞迎向光线。作为这样一对神祇的独子,小帕维尔在一系列快照中总是笑容满面。你告诉自己,这个人不是在没有幸福感的童年中长大的。他成年后创作的一些电影或许看起来晦暗,笼罩着荒凉,但那晦暗从不刻意为之,也不矫揉造作。与此同时,你会感觉到,只有傻瓜才不预期天堂终将失落。

Part of the paradise was onscreen. “I was obsessed with movies when I was a kid. Every time we went skiving”—playing hooky—“I went to see movies. In Communist times, in Poland, there were screenings from ten o’clock in the morning, for the late-shift working classes,” Pawlikowski said. “Poland had a really good distribution of Western cinema—a unique country in the Communist bloc.” To reap the full benefits of this blessing, you had to schlep. “I remember, there was a cinema in the distant suburbs of Warsaw showing ‘The Fall of the Roman Empire’ ”—the 1964 epic with Alec Guinness and Sophia Loren. Taking a tram, as a much loved boy, to revel in ancient battles: there are far worse ways to grow up.

天堂的一部分在银幕上。“我小时候对电影着迷。每次逃学,我都去看电影。在共产主义时期的波兰,上午十点就有放映,为晚班工人阶级服务,”帕夫利科夫斯基说。“波兰对西方电影的引进做得非常好——是共产主义阵营中独一无二的国家。”要充分享受这份恩赐,你得跑远路。“我记得华沙远郊有一家电影院在放《罗马帝国沦亡录》”——那部1964年的史诗片,有亚利科·吉尼斯和索菲亚·罗兰出演。一个备受宠爱的小男孩,坐着有轨电车去纵情观赏古代战争:成长的方式比这糟糕的多得是。

Another source of rapture was music. As an English teacher, Pawlikowski’s mother was permitted to travel to the U.K., and she would return with treasures for her son. One was the Beatles’ “All My Loving” (with “Money” on the B-side), plus, he says, “a wet-look jacket.” Memory is not so much a flow, sometimes, as a series of bumps and scrapes. “In winter 1965 we went to see ‘A Hard Day’s Night’ at our local cinema, Moskwa. We queued for hours,” Pawlikowski told me, in an e-mail. “When we finally got the tickets and had time to kill, I went sliding on ice with other kids in front of the cinema. I fell and cut my head and watched the film with a bandage on my head.” Fifty-three years later, when asked by Criterion to name his favorite movies, Pawlikowski put “A Hard Day’s Night” at the top of the list. Pain and pleasure are wrapped up tight.

另一个令他心醉神迷的源泉是音乐。作为英语教师,帕夫利科夫斯基的母亲获准前往英国,她会带回给儿子的珍宝。其中之一是披头士的《我所有的爱》(B面是《钱》),还有,他说,“一件亮面夹克。”记忆有时与其说是流动,不如说是一连串的磕碰和擦伤。“1965年冬天,我们去本地电影院莫斯科影院看《一夜狂欢》。我们排了好几个小时的队,”帕夫利科夫斯基在一封电子邮件中告诉我。“终于买到票后,还有时间要打发,我就和别的孩子在电影院门前滑冰。我摔倒了,磕破了头,头上缠着绷带看完了电影。”五十三年后,当标准收藏公司请他列出最喜欢的电影时,帕夫利科夫斯基把《一夜狂欢》排在首位。痛苦与快乐紧紧缠绕。
Woman looking at thankyou note in display case in museum.
Cartoon by David Sipress
Copy link to cartoon
Shop

I first met Pawlikowski early this summer, in London, where we ate lunch and went to an exhibition of paintings by the seventeenth-century Spanish painter Francisco de Zurbarán: a strange environment in which to contemplate Poland in the nineteen-sixties. Pawlikowski feels he was lucky to be raised then, “when Communism went a bit softer.” In the air of his parents’ generation, he claimed, “there was so much poetic wit.” The writings of the period were “subtle, funny, ironic, with a sense of paradox,” and some of that pliability left its mark. Infusing almost every Pawlikowski film is a strain of gloomy relish. “People say to me, ‘What’s your Polish influence? Is it Polish cinema of the fifties and stuff?’ No, it’s more that kind of humor—humor with a kind of melancholy, you know?” The implication being that, in his words, “we’re all fucked anyway.”

今年初夏,我在伦敦第一次见到帕夫利科夫斯基。我们一起吃了午饭,去看了一场十七世纪西班牙画家弗朗西斯科·德·苏巴朗的画展:一个用来思考六十年代波兰的奇特环境。帕夫利科夫斯基觉得自己很幸运在那个年代长大,“那时共产主义变得温和了一些。”他声称,在父母那一代人的氛围中,“有那么多诗意的机智。”那个时期的作品“微妙、有趣、讽刺,充满悖论感”,其中一些柔韧灵活的特质留下了印记。几乎每一部帕夫利科夫斯基的电影都浸透着一种阴郁的兴味。“人们对我说,‘你的波兰影响是什么?是五十年代的波兰电影之类的吗?’不,更多是那种幽默——带着一种忧郁的幽默,你知道吗?”言下之意是,用他的话说,“反正我们都完蛋了。”

Proof of that principle came in early 1968, when Władysław Gomułka, the leader of the Communist Party in Poland, was losing his grip on power. A scapegoat was required. In March, he gave a televised speech in which he split the country’s Jews into three categories. There were “patriotic Jews,” who were firmly embedded in Polish society, “Zionists,” and “cosmopolitans”—the slyest of anti-Jewish slurs. (Which group Gomułka’s wife, who was Jewish, fell into was not clear.) “Basically, the antisemitic Party campaign was a distraction from the student demonstrations,” Pawlikowski told me. Tear gas must have been deployed against the crowds, because he remembers “some gassed students of my mother’s seeking refuge in our flat.” He used to be sent to buy newspapers at a kiosk, but his father now told him not to go, saying, “Prasa kłamie”—the press lies.

这一原则的证明出现在1968年初,当时波兰共产党领导人瓦迪斯瓦夫·哥穆尔卡正在失去权力。需要一只替罪羊。三月,他发表电视讲话,把波兰的犹太人分成三类。有“爱国犹太人”,他们牢固地融入波兰社会;有“犹太复国主义者”;还有“世界主义者”——最阴险的反犹蔑称。(哥穆尔卡的妻子是犹太人,她属于哪一类并不清楚。)“基本上,反犹的党内运动是为了转移对学生示威的注意力,”帕夫利科夫斯基告诉我。当局肯定对人群使用了催泪瓦斯,因为他记得“我母亲的一些被瓦斯熏到的学生躲到我们公寓里避难。”他以前常被派去报亭买报纸,但父亲现在不让他去了,说:“Prasa kłamie”——报纸在撒谎。

One upshot of Gomułka’s initiative was a purge of Jewish citizens from what he called “responsible and high positions.” Another was a mass departure of Polish Jews, among them Wiktor Pawlikowski, who left in 1969. The rift was traumatizing; in the words of his son, “He truly suffered in exile.” Nothing was ever quite the same again. Wiktor and Zula divorced. She married an Englishman and, in 1971, she, too, left Poland behind, moving to England with the bewildered Paweł, who had never been there. “Me not speaking English, being into rock and roll, not having the right gear and the language—that was my main drama,” Pawlikowski told me. “I was fourteen, when you’re kind of already formed, so you can’t be molded into something completely different.”

哥穆尔卡行动的一个后果,是对他所称“负责的和高级的职位”上的犹太公民进行清洗。另一个后果是波兰犹太人的大规模出走,其中包括维克托·帕夫利科夫斯基,他于1969年离开。这场裂痕造成了创伤;用他儿子的话说,“他在流亡中真正地受苦。”一切再也回不到从前。维克托和祖拉离了婚。她嫁给了一个英国人,1971年,她也离开了波兰,带着茫然的帕维尔移居英国——他从未去过那里。“我不会说英语,痴迷摇滚乐,没有合适的行头和语言——那是我主要的困境,”帕夫利科夫斯基告诉我。“我十四岁,那时候你已经基本定型了,没法被塑造成完全不同的样子。”

Zula found a job at a department store in London. Pawlikowski, whose immersion in English culture had hitherto been largely musical—“Beatles, Stones, Kinks”—was packed off to “a school for Polish expatriates, called Divine Mercy College, in Henley-on- Thames. Mass every morning.” The experiment did not succeed. “The more they tried to reëducate me, the more I hated it,” Pawlikowski told me. “Then they taught me how to use a telephone, as if I’d never used a telephone in Poland: that kind of shit. Poland back then was seen by the Polish in England as a Communist nightmare, one big Gulag, whereas I had had a normal childhood.” As he recalled, there wasn’t enough to eat at the school. Worse still, “I was told to play cricket, and nobody explained to me what the fuck it was.” (He was not the first to hit that wall.) All in all, Pawlikowski said, “My problem was not with my Jewish heritage. My problem was being Polish, in the West. That was bad enough.”

祖拉在伦敦一家百货商店找到了工作。帕夫利科夫斯基此前对英国文化的浸染主要限于音乐——“披头士、滚石、奇想”——被送进了“一所波兰侨民学校,叫神圣慈悲学院,在泰晤士河畔亨利。每天早晨做弥撒。”这个实验没有成功。“他们越想改造我,我就越恨它,”帕夫利科夫斯基告诉我。“然后他们教我如何使用电话,好像我在波兰从没用过电话似的:那种破事。当时在英国的波兰人把波兰看作共产主义噩梦,一个大古拉格,而我其实有过一个正常的童年。”据他回忆,学校里吃不饱。更糟的是,“我被叫去打板球,但没人向我解释那到底是什么鬼东西。”(他不是第一个撞上这堵墙的人。)总而言之,帕夫利科夫斯基说:“我的问题不在于我的犹太血统。我的问题是在西方做一个波兰人。那已经够糟了。”

Having faltered academically, the teen-age Paweł was thrown out of Divine Mercy and sent to a boarding school in Kent. He had to leave that place, too, after which the story line of his life—it’s too fragmentary and misshapen to call it a plot—was folded back on itself. He moved to Wuppertal, in northwest Germany, where his father had settled. What’s more, Zula later joined them, and the family was, for a while, reconstituted. Pawlikowski stayed in Germany for five years, from 1972 to 1977, dug in deep, and passed his exams. Wuppertal was, among other things, the home base of the Pina Bausch dance company, to which Wiktor introduced his son. “I loved her shows, though I had no idea what was going on,” Pawlikowski remembered. “When a rhinoceros appeared onstage, my father turned to me and explained that this meant the arrival of Fascism.” It made for a change from cricket.

学业受挫后,少年帕维尔被逐出神圣慈悲学院,送进了肯特郡的一所寄宿学校。他不得不离开那里,之后他的人生线索——太零碎、太不成形,没法称之为情节——折回了原点。他搬到德国西北部的伍珀塔尔,父亲已在那里定居。而且,祖拉后来也来了,这个家庭一度重新聚合。帕夫利科夫斯基在德国待了五年,从1972年到1977年,扎下根来,通过了考试。伍珀塔尔还是皮娜·鲍什舞蹈团的基地,维克托带儿子去看了演出。“我爱她的作品,虽然我完全不知道台上在发生什么,”帕夫利科夫斯基回忆道。“当一头犀牛出现在舞台上时,我父亲转向我,解释说这意味着法西斯主义的到来。”这比板球有意思多了。

And so the rhythm persisted: migrate, remigrate, and take it from there. Pawlikowski returned to London for a degree at Westfield College. He then went to Oxford and began to study for a Ph.D. on the Austrian Expressionist poet Georg Trakl, who died young, in 1914. That plan was interrupted by a “defection,” as Pawlikowski calls it: he fled to Turin, partly for the sake of a woman he had met but mainly, he told me, as “a way of getting away from Oxford and my ball and chain of a thesis.” The unshackling was worth it: “I ended up having the best year of my life.” It also allowed him to add to his heap of languages. By my count, Pawlikowski now speaks Polish, English, French, German, Italian, Spanish, and Russian. If he ever switches to sci-fi movies, he could probably get by in Martian.

于是节奏持续着:迁移,再迁移,然后从那里继续。帕夫利科夫斯基回到伦敦,在韦斯特菲尔德学院攻读学位。之后他去了牛津,开始攻读博士学位,研究奥地利表现主义诗人格奥尔格·特拉克尔——诗人英年早逝,卒于1914年。这个计划被一次“叛逃”打断了——帕夫利科夫斯基这样称呼它:他逃到了都灵,部分是为了一个他认识的女人,但主要是,他告诉我,作为“一种逃离牛津和那篇如镣铐般沉重的论文的方式。”挣脱枷锁是值得的:“结果我度过了人生中最美好的一年。”这也让他又添了几门语言。据我统计,帕夫利科夫斯基现在会说波兰语、英语、法语、德语、意大利语、西班牙语和俄语。如果他哪天改拍科幻片,大概连火星语也能应付。

Back in England, Pawlikowski realized that he didn’t want to be an academic or a full-time writer and that, despite his musical hunger, he was unlikely to cut it as a musician. (He played piano, “imitating Chick Corea and Keith Jarrett.”) He signed up for a course at a local filmmaking workshop, unconnected with the university. This remains his only practical training in the craft. As he said to the audience at a master class in Sarajevo, “Here was a medium in which I could combine all my failures.” There, you might say, is the authentic tone of Mitteleuropa—amused, highly inquisitive, lightly despairing, and unimaginable on the lips of anyone applying, for instance, to film school at U.C.L.A. What Pawlikowski needed was somewhere eccentric enough to accommodate his ambitions, whatever they might be. So it was that, in 1986, after much drifting, and approaching thirty, he washed up on the shores of the BBC.

回到英国后,帕夫利科夫斯基意识到自己不想当学者或全职作家,而且尽管对音乐如饥似渴,他不太可能成为音乐家。(他弹钢琴,“模仿奇克·科里亚和基思·贾勒特。”)他报名参加了当地一个电影制作工作坊的课程,与大学无关。这仍是他唯一接受过的实用技艺训练。正如他在萨拉热窝大师班上对观众所说:“这是一个我可以把所有失败结合起来的媒介。”可以说,这正是中欧地道的腔调——饶有兴味、极度好奇、略带绝望,你无法想象这种话会从申请加州大学洛杉矶分校电影学院的人嘴里说出来。帕夫利科夫斯基需要的是一个足够古怪的地方,能容纳他的雄心,无论那雄心是什么。就这样,1986年,在漂泊多年、年近三十之际,他登上了BBC的海岸。

For the many moviegoers who became conscious of Pawlikowski only at the time of “Ida,” the range of films that preceded it may come as a surprise. Not that it’s easy to get hold of the damn things, even with the aid of Vimeo and YouTube. A few remain elusive, including “Václav Havel: A Czech Drama” (1989), which is not a drama but a documentary, made in what was then Czechoslovakia before the Communist regime caved in. In short, we could use a full retrospective to plug the gaps.

对于许多直到《修女艾达》才认识帕夫利科夫斯基的影迷来说,此前那些电影的广度可能会令人惊讶。不过,即便借助Vimeo和YouTube,要找到这些该死的东西也不容易。有几部仍然难以寻觅,包括《瓦茨拉夫·哈维尔:一部捷克戏剧》(1989)——那不是戏剧,而是一部纪录片,拍摄于当时的捷克斯洛伐克,在共产党政权垮台之前。简而言之,我们需要一场完整的回顾展来填补空白。

True to form, Pawlikowski is modest about some of his efforts as a tyro. “Of all the directors I worked with, he was the most talented and the most self-questioning.” So says Nigel Williams, a British novelist and playwright who was a producer on “Bookmark,” a BBC documentary series that ran from 1983 to 1999. Did Pawlikowski simply come knocking on his door? “The door was never closed,” Williams told me, in late August, over lunch in London. “He just turned up in the office one day. And he’d made a film about satanism.” (Correct. It’s a short documentary called “Lucifer Over Lancashire.”) “I said, ‘I’m not really into satanism, but let’s take a look at it.’ I liked him instantly.”

一如既往,帕夫利科夫斯基对自己初出茅庐时的一些作品颇为谦虚。“在我合作过的所有导演中,他是最有才华、也最善于自我质疑的。”说这话的是奈杰尔·威廉姆斯(Nigel Williams),英国小说家、剧作家,曾担任BBC纪录片系列《书签》(Bookmark)的制片人,该系列从1983年播出到1999年。帕夫利科夫斯基是直接来敲他的门吗?“门从来就没关过,”威廉姆斯八月下旬在伦敦吃午饭时告诉我。“他有一天就出现在办公室里。而且他拍了一部关于撒旦崇拜的电影。”(没错。那是一部叫《兰开夏上空的路西法》的短纪录片。)“我说,‘我对撒旦崇拜不太感兴趣,不过看看吧。’我立刻就喜欢上了他。”

Pawlikowski began as a TAP—a trainee assistant producer. “The BBC in those days was an amazing place,” Williams said. “There was total freedom.” Pawlikowski, who refers to it as “a real mensch situation,” took maximum and, it appears, nerveless advantage of such liberty. “He has complete balls, that guy,” Williams said. He remembers asking how the footage for the Havel film was going to be smuggled out of Czechoslovakia. Pawlikowski had the solution: “I’ll put it down my trousers.” One detail that you spot in all this early work is that he is credited as “Paul Pawlikowski.” Not until 2000 did he revert to “Paweł.” According to Williams, we shouldn’t read too much into this slippage of identity: “He didn’t give a shit.”

帕夫利科夫斯基从TAP做起——实习助理制片人。“那时的BBC是个了不起的地方,”威廉姆斯说。“有完全的自由。”帕夫利科夫斯基称那是“真正的君子环境”,他最大限度地、而且似乎毫无畏惧地利用了这种自由。“那家伙胆子大得很,”威廉姆斯说。他记得曾问哈维尔那部电影的素材要怎么偷运出捷克斯洛伐克。帕夫利科夫斯基有办法:“我把它塞进裤子里。”在这些早期作品中你会注意到一个细节:他的署名是“保罗·帕夫利科夫斯基”(Paul Pawlikowski)。直到2000年他才改回“帕维尔”(Paweł)。据威廉姆斯说,我们不必对这种身份的滑动过度解读:“他根本不在乎。”
People around a table.
Pawlikowski on the set of “Fatherland,” directing Sandra Hüller and Hanns Zischler, as Erika and Thomas Mann.
帕夫利科夫斯基在《父辈的土地》片场执导桑德拉·惠勒和汉斯·齐施勒,二人分别饰演埃里卡和托马斯·曼。
Photograph by Agata Grzybowska / Courtesy MUBI

The roster of “Bookmark” films shows you the kinds of story that Pawlikowski felt impelled to tell. There was “In the Blood” (1987), set in Northern Ireland; “Palace Life” (1988), about a banned dissident Polish writer named Tadeusz Konwicki, which marked the director’s return to his native land; and “Extraordinary Adventures: The Life of Vladimir Voinovich” (1989), about a brazen Russian satirist. Then came a trio of mini-masterpieces: “From Moscow to Pietushki: A Journey with Benedict Yerofeyev” (1990), “Dostoevsky’s Travels” (1991), and “Serbian Epics” (1992). All three, as their titles suggest, confirmed the tenacity of Pawlikowski’s eastward gaze.

《书签》系列的电影清单显示出帕夫利科夫斯基感到非讲不可的故事类型。有《血脉之中》(1987),背景设在北爱尔兰;有《宫殿生活》(1988),讲述被禁的波兰异见作家塔德乌什·孔维茨基,标志着导演重返故土;还有《非凡历险:弗拉基米尔·沃伊诺维奇的一生》(1989),关于一位胆大妄为的俄罗斯讽刺作家。接着是三连迷你杰作:《从莫斯科到佩图什基:与本尼迪克特·叶罗费耶夫同行》(1990)、《陀思妥耶夫斯基的旅行》(1991)和《塞尔维亚史诗》(1992)。三部作品,正如片名所示,都印证了帕夫利科夫斯基向东凝视的执着。

Yerofeyev was a hell of a creature: not just a drunkard and a writer but a visionary writer about drinking, whose headlong and scabrous prose poem, “From Moscow to Pietushki,” circulated in typescript for years before it was finally published, in 1989. “It was a cult book between me and my father,” Pawlikowski told me. In his tribute, he reconstructs the train journey described in its pages and, to the viewer’s amazement, tracks down the reclusive author not long before his death. (With a voice wrecked by throat cancer, Yerofeyev speaks through a laryngophone.) The film finds lyrical scraps at the damp and tattered edges of society, listening to a boozer on a park bench as he fondly recites the recipe for a Yerofeyev cocktail: “Anti-dandruff shampoo and cologne. Add a hundred grams of vodka. Stir it with a honeysuckle twig and drink it up, in God’s name.”

叶罗费耶夫是个了不起的人物:不仅是酒鬼和作家,更是一位关于饮酒的幻想型作家。他那奔放而粗粝的散文诗《从莫斯科到佩图什基》以打字稿形式流传多年,直到1989年才正式出版。“那是我和我父亲之间的崇拜之书,”帕夫利科夫斯基告诉我。在他的致敬之作中,他重构了书中所描述的火车旅程,并令观众惊叹地找到了那位深居简出的作者——就在他去世前不久。(因喉癌嗓音尽毁,叶罗费耶夫通过喉头送话器说话。)影片在社会潮湿而褴褛的边缘拾取抒情的碎片,聆听公园长椅上的一个酒鬼深情地背诵叶罗费耶夫鸡尾酒的配方:“去屑洗发水和古龙水。加一百克伏特加。用金银花枝搅拌,以上帝之名一饮而尽。”

As for “Dostoevsky’s Travels,” it originated when Pawlikowski rang Williams late at night from a phone booth in St. Petersburg. “I’ve just been bitten by a stray dog,” he said, adding that he had met a man who claimed to be Dostoevsky’s great-grandson. And so it proved. The film follows Dmitri Dostoevsky, a humble tram driver, as he journeys to Western Europe, now open to visitors from former Communist lands. The whole expedition turns on a delectable irony: those who host Dmitri, in Germany and elsewhere, want him to pronounce on the consciousness of modern man, as enshrined in his great-grandfather’s fiction, whereas the one thing that he wants, more than anything, is a Mercedes.

至于《陀思妥耶夫斯基的旅行》,它的缘起是帕夫利科夫斯基深夜从圣彼得堡的一个电话亭给威廉姆斯打电话。“我刚被一条流浪狗咬了,”他说,还补充说他遇到了一个自称是陀思妥耶夫斯基曾孙的人。事实果然如此。影片跟随德米特里·陀思妥耶夫斯基——一位谦卑的电车司机——前往西欧,那里如今对前共产主义国家的访客开放了。整个旅程围绕着一个令人愉悦的反讽展开:在德国等地接待德米特里的人,希望他就现代人的意识发表高见,正如其曾祖父小说中所铭刻的那样;而他最想要的,胜过一切的,是一辆奔驰。

In case you were wondering, the Mercedes functions as “an object of both symbolic and monetary value.” That’s how it was analyzed, at any rate, in “ReFocus: The Films of Paweł Pawlikowski,” an academic study published last year. Pawlikowski has not been able to bring himself to read it, although he does like the cover. (Rightly so; it makes him look like the Terminator, striding along in shades.) One oddity of the book is that, despite its inquiries into the director’s interrogation of “hegemonic national discourses,” not once does it observe how funny those interrogations can be. In person, Pawlikowski is wry and convivial, with a taste for good food and for absurdities both fleeting and profound, and his geniality carries over into even his most wounded works. The hapless hero of “Dostoevsky’s Travels” is savored rather than roasted by the movie, and this grants him a certain shrewd dignity. That difficult balance is sustained, under far more testing conditions, in “Serbian Epics.”

如果你好奇的话,那辆奔驰的功能是“兼具象征价值和货币价值的物件。”至少,《重新聚焦:帕维尔·帕夫利科夫斯基的电影》——去年出版的一本学术研究——是这样分析的。帕夫利科夫斯基一直没能让自己去读这本书,不过他喜欢封面。(理应如此;封面上的他看起来像终结者,戴着墨镜大步前行。)这本书的一个奇特之处在于,尽管它探究了导演对“霸权性国家话语”的质询,却从未注意到那些质询可以多么有趣。帕夫利科夫斯基本人风趣而随和,喜欢美食,也喜欢转瞬即逝和意味深长的荒诞之事,他的和蔼可亲甚至渗透进他最伤痛的作品中。《陀思妥耶夫斯基的旅行》中那位倒霉的主人公,被电影细细品味而非炙烤,这赋予了他某种精明的尊严。这种艰难的平衡,在远为严峻的条件下,在《塞尔维亚史诗》中得以维持。

Not many literary documentaries are set in an active war zone. In the case of “Serbian Epics,” however, literature was the way in—or, as Pawlikowski has said, a Trojan horse. A major character in the film is the Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadžić, who is introduced with an onscreen title: “Poet and Psychiatrist.” He solemnly sits in front of the camera playing the gusla, a bowed musical instrument that makes a noise like a baritone bee, and singing along: “There were thirty chieftains drinking wine /Among the vast crags of the Romanija Mountain.” Karadžić, in his own eyes, is upholding the oral tradition of his people, whose territorial claims, mythologized in verse and blessed by the Church, must, if necessary, be defended in blood; where better to unfold such grandeur than to a BBC program called “Bookmark”?

没有多少文学纪录片是在活跃的战区拍摄的。然而就《塞尔维亚史诗》而言,文学是进入的途径——或者如帕夫利科夫斯基所说,是一匹特洛伊木马。影片中的一个主要人物是波斯尼亚塞族领导人拉多万·卡拉季奇,他的出场配以字幕:“诗人与精神病学家。”他庄重地坐在摄影机前,弹奏古斯拉——一种弓弦乐器,发出的声音像男中音蜜蜂——并随之吟唱:“三十位酋长在饮酒/在罗马尼亚山的巨崖之间。”在卡拉季奇自己看来,他在维护本民族的口述传统,其领土主张在诗歌中被神话化,并得到教会的祝福,必要时必须以鲜血捍卫;还有什么地方比BBC一档叫《书签》的节目更适合展现这种宏大呢?

The access that Pawlikowski managed to get, on this basis, is dumbfounding. He sits in on a meeting of the Serbian war cabinet, chaired by Karadžić, who points at a map of the conflict, on which thick black lines show the areas claimed by the Serbs—geopolitics by Sharpie. “It’s not right that Croatia should have all the coast and we have none,” he proclaims, as if a coastline were cake at a children’s birthday party. We hear no commentary in this or any other scene; forsaking voice-overs, Pawlikowski lets his camera do all the moral work. Bathos is not hard to come by. Up on a hill overlooking Sarajevo, Karadžić, the proud champion of his nation, huddles inside a little red pod, formerly part of a cable car, trying to make a phone call to his wife while petting a puppy that larks around at his feet.

帕夫利科夫斯基在此基础上获得的接触机会令人瞠目。他列席了塞尔维亚战时内阁的一次会议,会议由卡拉季奇主持,后者指着冲突地图,上面用粗黑线标出塞族人主张的地区——用记号笔划定的地缘政治。“克罗地亚拥有全部海岸而我们一寸都没有,这不公平,”他宣称,仿佛海岸线是儿童生日派对上的蛋糕。在这个场景以及所有其他场景中,我们听不到任何解说;帕夫利科夫斯基放弃画外音,让摄影机承担全部道德工作。突降法并不难寻。在俯瞰萨拉热窝的山上,卡拉季奇——这位自豪的民族捍卫者——蜷缩在一个红色小舱里(曾是缆车的一部分),试图给妻子打电话,同时抚摸着一只在他脚边嬉闹的小狗。

On a hot Saturday, Pawlikowski and I revisited those heights—the slopes from which, for almost four years, starting in the spring of 1992, Serbian artillery pounded Sarajevo, which lies vulnerably cupped in the valley below. We had coffee at Sunnyland, a playground with a gentle roller coaster and a giant swing. “Adventure Awaits You,” a poster announced. Around us, other customers were enjoying the weekend at their leisure, including many Muslim families, the women in head scarves. “It’s Karadžić’s nightmare!” Pawlikowski said, with visible delight.

一个炎热的周六,帕夫利科夫斯基和我重访了那些高地——从1992年春天开始的近四年里,塞尔维亚炮兵从这些山坡上轰击萨拉热窝,这座城市脆弱地蜷伏在下面的山谷中。我们在阳光乐园喝了咖啡,那是一个游乐场,有一条温和的过山车和一个巨型秋千。“冒险在等着你,”一张海报宣告。我们周围,其他顾客正悠闲地享受周末,包括许多穆斯林家庭,女人们戴着着头巾。“这是卡拉季奇的噩梦!”帕夫利科夫斯基说,脸上带着明显的愉悦。

Nearby was the city’s Jewish graveyard, where the tombs are laid out around a steep flight of steps. There, in the early nineties, the living fought fiercely among the dead. One of the combatants was a poet. “He didn’t know the war had started, because he was hungover or drunk or something,” Pawlikowski told me. “So the first thing he did was try to flee to his home town of Han Pijesak to stay with his mother. He hid there, then he was dragged out by the Serb military police as a deserter—because he was a Serb, he should be fighting. And they threw his battalion straight into the Jewish cemetery, which was like a killing field.” (Pawlikowski recalled the poet’s mordant report: “There’s a layer of dead Jews, and dead Bosnians, Muslims, and then us.”) The tale took a twist: “Two military police turned up and dragged him away, so he was convinced he was going to be shot.” Another twist: “He got dragged to the press office of this colleague of his, who then nominated him as second-in-command for P.R. And this guy was totally useless, alcoholic. His hands were trembling.” Having been rescued from the teeth of death, the poet had a new complaint: “Oh, it’s so boring without the Muslims.”

附近是这座城市的犹太人墓地,坟墓沿着一道陡峭的台阶排列。九十年代初,活人在死者之间激烈交战。其中一名战斗者是位诗人。“他不知道战争已经开始了,因为他宿醉或者喝醉了什么的,”帕夫利科夫斯基告诉我。“所以他做的第一件事就是试图逃回老家汉皮耶萨克,去和母亲待在一起。他躲在那里,然后被塞族军警当作逃兵拖了出来——因为他是塞族人,应该去打仗。他们把他的营直接扔进了犹太人墓地,那里就像一个杀戮场。”(帕夫利科夫斯基回忆起诗人尖刻的报告:“有一层死去的犹太人,死去的波斯尼亚人、穆斯林,然后是我们。”)故事发生了转折:“两个军警出现,把他拖走了,所以他确信自己要被枪毙了。”又一个转折:“他被拖到了他一个同事的新闻办公室,那个同事随后提名他当公关副手。而这个人完全没用,是个酒鬼。他的手一直在抖。”从死亡的齿缝中被救出后,诗人有了新的抱怨:“哦,没有穆斯林真是太无聊了。”

Even before “Serbian Epics” was shown on TV, it caused “a huge scandal,” according to Pawlikowski. A motion in the House of Commons in December, 1992, expressed dismay at the film, or, to be precise, at a listing of the film in the BBC schedule, which hinted at pro-Serb sympathies. To anyone who had actually seen the documentary, with its droll depiction of collective self-aggrandizement, this was hogwash. What the movie thrives on is the farcical and, all too often, horrendous reach of human error; surreal episodes are not cooked up but happened upon or stumbled over. As Pawlikowski said to me, in Sarajevo, “I was being anthropological.” As we walked around the city—which, as he says, “has always had its own urban identity, accent, the way they drink, the way they celebrate”—he kept summoning up incidents and individuals from more than thirty years before. One block of buildings, opposite a soccer stadium, close to what used to be the front line, touched off a particular memory: “There was a sniper woman, a mother of three, who every day went up to the top floor somewhere and sniped. A Serbian woman, very nice. She was picking people off, you know, in Sniper’s Alley.”

据帕夫利科夫斯基说,《塞尔维亚史诗》甚至在电视播出之前就引起了“巨大的丑闻”。1992年12月,英国下议院提出一项动议,对该片表示不安——准确地说,是对BBC节目表中该片的条目表示不安,因为它暗示了亲塞倾向。对于任何真正看过这部纪录片的人来说——影片以滑稽的笔触描绘了集体的自我膨胀——这纯属胡扯。这部电影赖以蓬勃的是人类错误的荒诞以及往往骇人的波及范围;超现实的片段不是编造出来的,而是偶然遇见或跌跌撞撞碰上的。正如帕夫利科夫斯基在萨拉热窝对我说的:“我是在做人类学。”我们在城中漫步时——如他所说,这座城市“一直有自己独特的城市身份、口音、喝酒的方式、庆祝的方式”——他不断唤起三十多年前的事件和人物。足球场对面、靠近昔日前线的一排建筑,触发了一段特别的记忆:“有一个狙击手女人,三个孩子的母亲,每天爬上某栋楼的顶层去狙击。一个塞尔维亚女人,人很好。她在狙击手巷里射杀路人,你知道的。”

Like the poet in the cemetery, the sniper mother is still fresh in Pawlikowski’s mind. So is Nikola Koljević, “a scholar in Shakespeare studies at Sarajevo University, but he was part of this Serbian government besieging his own university.” When a world gets turned upside down, the people inside follow suit. Rarely, it seems to me, has Pawlikowski been roused by themes or issues or arguments. Rather, it is characters who have muscled their way to the forefront of his imagination. The question naturally arises: Why not make them up?

就像墓地里的诗人一样,那位狙击手母亲在帕夫利科夫斯基的记忆中依然鲜活。还有尼古拉·科列维奇,“萨拉热窝大学莎士比亚研究的学者,但他参与了围困自己大学的塞尔维亚政府。”当一个世界被颠倒过来,里面的人也跟着颠倒。在我看来,帕夫利科夫斯基很少被主题、议题或论点所激发。相反,是人物挤到了他想象力的最前沿。问题自然而来:为什么不虚构他们呢?

Defining the line where nonfiction fades and drama dawns is a challenge. For Pawlikowski, it was yet another border to cross. He admired Ken Loach’s “Kes” (1969)—“documentary texture, nonprofessional actors, good faces, good landscape, small story that goes a long way,” as he told me. He could be describing “Twockers” (1998), which he made for the BBC in collaboration with a friend, Ian Duncan, and which tells of a kid and his mates, in a depleted community in the North of England, who break into cars and houses. A singsong dialect binds them together; they don’t steal a TV, they steal a “teggy-veggy.”

界定非虚构消退、戏剧开始的那条线,是一个挑战。对帕夫利科夫斯基来说,这是又一条要跨越的边界。他欣赏肯·洛奇的《凯斯》(1969)——“纪录片的质感,非职业演员,好看的面孔,好看的风景,一个小故事走得很远,”他这样告诉我。他也可以是在描述《偷车贼》(1998),那是他与朋友伊恩·邓肯合作为BBC拍摄的,讲述英格兰北部一个凋敝社区里,一个孩子和他的伙伴们闯入汽车和住宅行窃的故事。一种如歌的方言把他们联结在一起;他们偷的不是电视,而是“teggy-veggy”。

Put like that, “Twockers” sounds like a burst of indignant social realism—hardly uncommon in British cinema in the period of Margaret Thatcher’s dominance and its long aftermath. The plots of Pawlikowski’s next two films, “Last Resort” (2000) and “My Summer of Love” (2004), would seem to be singing a comparable tune. The first is about a Russian woman and her son, newly arrived in England and confined by immigration authorities to a scruffy seaside town, where her sole chance of employment is to perform in online porn; the second tells of a relationship between two young women, one working class and the other (played by Emily Blunt, in her first starring role) more educated, and gilded with the languor of wealth. This being England, their love is doomed by the gulf of the social divide.

这样说来,《偷车贼》听起来像一股愤怒的社会现实主义爆发——在撒切尔夫人主导及其漫长余波时期的英国电影中并不罕见。帕夫利科夫斯基接下来两部电影的情节——《最后归宿》(2000)和《我的夏日之恋》(2004)——似乎唱着相似的调子。第一部讲述一个俄罗斯女人和她的儿子初到英国,被移民当局限制在一个破败的海滨小镇,她唯一的就业机会是在网络色情中表演;第二部讲述两个年轻女性之间的关系,一个出身工人阶级,另一个(由艾米莉·布朗特饰演,这是她的第一个主演角色)受过更多教育,镀着财富的慵懒光泽。这是在英国,她们的爱情注定被社会鸿沟所扼杀。

If you watch these movies, however, you feel more haunted than hectored. It’s true that Pawlikowski, himself an immigrant, is instinctively drawn to the lost and the marooned. (“Britain is very good for being able to stay an outsider, for not having to fit in too much,” he told me.) On the other hand, he’s not seeking to persuade us of anything, politically or otherwise; he is passing on visions, which bloom in unlikely terrain. The eye of a dead man, whose home has been burgled by a couple of lads, in “Twockers,” is filmed from inches away, with a fly crawling over the sightless orb; “My Summer of Love” kicks off with an eye being drawn on a wall, swiftly followed by two other eyes in closeup—one of a human, who is lying in grass, and the other of a horse.

然而,如果你去看这些电影,你会感到更多的是萦绕于心,而非被说教。诚然,帕夫利科夫斯基自己就是移民,本能地被失落者和困顿者所吸引。(“英国很适合保持局外人身份,不必太融入,”他告诉我。)另一方面,他并不试图在任何方面说服我们,无论是政治上还是其他方面;他在传递幻象,那些幻象在不寻常的地带绽放。《偷车贼》中,一个死人的眼睛——他的家被几个小伙子闯入过——被从几英寸外拍摄,一只苍蝇爬过那失明的眼球;《我的夏日之恋》以一只画在墙上的眼睛开场,紧接着是另外两只眼睛的特写——一只属于躺在草丛中的人,另一只属于一匹马。
One witch stirring cauldron while another holds a bag of eye of newt.
“Add enough eye of newt and it honestly becomes just as expensive as ordering in.”
“只要放够蝾螈眼,说实话,这成本就跟点外卖一样贵了。”
Cartoon by Avi Steinberg
Copy link to cartoon
Shop

Fans of Pawlikowski, inspecting his filmography, will be struck by the hiatus that opened up between “My Summer of Love” and its successor, “The Woman in the Fifth” (2011). Lord knows, there are many reasons—funding, casting, development hell—that movies fail to get made. For Pawlikowski, though, the troubles that put his professional life on hold were more private, and immeasurably sadder. In 1989, he had married a Russian pianist, Irina. They met in London, though she hailed from the Caucasus. (“She knew ‘From Moscow to Pietushki’ by heart,” he told me. “It was a sign.”) They were together for seventeen years, and had two children, Wiktor and Maria. Irina died in 2006, and Pawlikowski paused his filmmaking career to raise the children on his own.

帕夫利科夫斯基的影迷审视他的作品年表时,会注意到《我的夏日之恋》与其后继之作《第五个女人》(2011)之间出现的空白。天知道,电影拍不成的原因有很多——资金、选角、开发地狱。但对帕夫利科夫斯基来说,让他的职业生涯搁置的麻烦更为私密,也无比悲伤。1989年,他娶了一位俄罗斯钢琴家伊琳娜。他们在伦敦相识,尽管她来自高加索。(“她能背诵《从莫斯科到佩图什基》,”他告诉我。“那是一个征兆。”)他们在一起十七年,育有两个孩子,维克托和玛丽亚。伊琳娜于2006年去世,帕夫利科夫斯基暂停了电影事业,独自抚养孩子。

To learn that “The Woman in the Fifth” was made by a man who had, not long before, passed through the valley of the shadow of grief doesn’t explain the movie, yet it comes as little surprise. The atmosphere is desperate and stunned. Pawlikowski, at the master class in Sarajevo, referred to the film as “well directed, if I say so myself, but it didn’t really work.” The plot, very loosely adapted from a book by Douglas Kennedy, concerns Tom (Ethan Hawke), an American novelist who gets stranded in Paris, broke, with a gluey case of writer’s block. The most piercing verdict on his predicament is made by the enigmatic Margit (Kristin Scott Thomas), whom he encounters at a party. “You needed a good disaster to get you started,” she says. “A real tragedy, if you play your cards right.”

得知《第五个女人》是由一个不久前刚走过死亡阴影之谷的人拍出来的,并不能解释这部电影,但也并不令人意外。影片的氛围是绝望而恍惚的。帕夫利科夫斯基在萨拉热窝的大师班上称这部电影“导演得不错,如果我可以自夸的话,但它并没有真正成功。”情节非常松散地改编自道格拉斯·肯尼迪的小说,讲述美国小说家汤姆(伊桑·霍克饰)身无分文地困在巴黎,创作障碍如胶似漆。对他困境最犀利的评判来自神秘的马吉特(克里斯汀·斯科特·托马斯饰),他在一个派对上遇见了她。“你需要一场像样的灾难来让你启动,”她说。“一场真正的悲剧,如果你牌打得好。”

In what ways the life of a creative artist, and the deaths that inevitably scar it, can leak into the ensuing work—through the cracks of a poem, or a movie, or a song—is, let’s face it, a conundrum that has been worried into exhaustion. But you can’t help raising it if you warm to Pawlikowski’s films, because they are so question-strewn, and so clearly indebted to the histories, grand and minor, of his time.

一个创作艺术家的生活,以及不可避免地给它留下伤痕的死亡,能以何种方式渗入后续的作品——通过一首诗、一部电影或一首歌的裂缝——坦白说,这是一个已经被反复琢磨到精疲力竭的难题。但如果你喜欢帕夫利科夫斯基的电影,你就忍不住要提出这个问题,因为他的电影充满了疑问,而且如此明显地受惠于他所处时代的宏大与微小历史。

As a graduate student, for example, he met Helena Wolińska-Brus, the elderly Jewish wife of an Oxford professor. Years later, it was revealed that she had been a Polish military prosecutor, at whose bidding a number of former anti-Nazi freedom fighters had been arrested and tried; one hero of the wartime resistance, who refused to work with the postwar Communist administration, was executed. For that reason, the Polish government requested Wolińska-Brus’s extradition from Britain, though in vain. Pawlikowski hoped to interview her about her life. “She said no, and then she died,” he told me. Yet that was not the end of the affair. “I just kept her in my back pocket, as an idea.”

例如,读研究生时,他认识了海伦娜·沃林斯卡-布鲁斯,一位牛津大学教授的年迈犹太妻子。多年后,真相曝光:她曾是波兰军事检察官,在她的指令下,多名前反纳粹自由战士被逮捕和审判;一位战时抵抗运动的英雄因拒绝与战后共产党政府合作而被处决。因此,波兰政府要求从英国引渡沃林斯卡-布鲁斯,但未能成功。帕夫利科夫斯基希望采访她的人生。“她拒绝了,然后她就死了,”他告诉我。但事情并未就此结束。“我只是把她放在我的后兜里,作为一个想法。”

Maybe that’s what separates the born storytellers of this world from the rest of us: they have deeper back pockets. What Pawlikowski plucked out, in due course, was Wanda Gruz (Agata Kulesza), the heroine’s aunt in “Ida,” and a strong candidate for the most dauntingly memorable character in twenty-first-century cinema. As Pawlikowski is at pains to emphasize, Wanda is “not a portrait” of Wolińska-Brus. Without that living spark, though, would the invented woman have caught fire? Wanda—“Red Wanda, that’s me” she says, with a twinge of acerbic pride—is a former state prosecutor, Stalinist in her rigor, who sent people to their deaths. Now a judge, suavely dressed and robed in self-contempt, she drinks to excess and sleeps around as if to eradicate any threat of love. One morning, she sprinkles sugar on her bread and chomps like a starving child; has a bath and a smoke; then, to the calmative strain of Mozart’s “Jupiter” Symphony, stubs out her last cigarette and leaps from an open window. Watching that sequence in a movie theatre was a drama in itself. I sensed the audience rear back in their seats, as if hit by a shock wave. Horror films, you could say, throw a similar punch, but jump scares tend to be relieved by laughs. With “Ida,” there was no such release.

也许这正是天生的讲故事者与我们的区别:他们有更深的后兜。帕夫利科夫斯基最终掏出来的,是旺达·格鲁兹(阿加塔·库莱沙饰)——《修女艾达》中女主人公的姨妈,也是二十一世纪电影中最令人望而生畏、最难忘的角色的有力候选。帕夫利科夫斯基不厌其烦地强调,旺达“不是”沃林斯卡-布鲁斯的“肖像”。然而,没有那颗鲜活的火花,这个虚构的女人会燃烧起来吗?旺达——“红色旺达,就是我,”她带着一丝尖刻的自豪说——是前国家检察官,斯大林主义的严苛执行者,曾把人送上死路。如今身为法官,衣着考究,裹着自我鄙夷的长袍,她酗酒无度,滥交纵欲,仿佛要根除任何爱情的威胁。一天早晨,她在面包上撒糖,像饥饿的孩子一样大口咀嚼;洗了澡,抽了烟;然后在莫扎特《朱庇特》交响曲的镇静旋律中,摁灭最后一根香烟,从敞开的窗户纵身跃下。在电影院里观看那一幕本身就是一场戏剧。我感觉到观众在座位上向后一缩,仿佛被冲击波击中。恐怖片,可以说,也能打出类似的一拳,但惊吓之后往往有笑声来缓解。而《修女艾达》,没有这样的释放。

For someone so vivacious, Pawlikowski is an expert purveyor of mortal facts. At the end of “Cold War,” the couple who have tried and failed to live without each other come to a tranquil understanding: they will die together instead. In the broken shell of a chapel, near a remote crossroads in Poland—the same location had been used in “Ida”—Zula (Joanna Kulig) and Wiktor (Tomasz Kot) swallow a handful of pills and make their vows, as if they were getting married. They sit on a bench. “Let’s go to the other side,” she says. “The view will be better there.” They stand up and walk out of the frame. And that’s it. The words “For my parents” appear onscreen, and the circle is complete. Pawlikowski’s mother and father, also named Zula and Wiktor, whose unmanageable love had kept them tangled and disentangled for decades, took their own lives in 1989, as the Cold War that had cast its chill upon their time was beginning to thaw.

对于如此活泼的人来说,帕夫利科夫斯基是死亡事实的专业供应商。在《冷战》结尾,那对尝试过、也失败过无法离开彼此而活的恋人,达成了一个平静的共识:他们将一起赴死。在波兰一个偏远十字路口附近一座破败的小教堂里——《修女艾达》也用过同一地点——祖拉(乔安娜·库利格饰)和维克托(托马什·科特饰)吞下一把药丸,互许誓言,仿佛在举行婚礼。他们坐在长椅上。“我们去另一边吧,”她说。“那边的风景会更好。”他们站起来,走出画框。就这样。银幕上出现“献给我的父母”几个字,圆圈闭合了。帕夫利科夫斯基的母亲和父亲,同样名叫祖拉和维克托,他们那难以驾驭的爱让他们纠缠又分离了数十年,于1989年结束了自己的生命——那时,曾给他们那个时代投下寒意的冷战正开始解冻。

There is a suicide in “Fatherland,” too, although we don’t witness it. All that we see is Erika Mann, as she hears the mournful news. Like Ingmar Bergman—and “Fatherland” owes something to Bergman’s “Wild Strawberries” (1957), another bitter and reflective pilgrimage—Pawlikowski is given to measuring events by their impact on the human face. At the start of “Twockers,” as a kid is urged to stop loafing around and get a job, it’s him we see, and not his adult adviser. Likewise, in “Ida,” when the heroine (Agata Trzebuchowska) is told, “You’re a Jew,” we get a half-length shot of her in her nun’s habit, holding steady, with her dark, unblinking eyes, as she absorbs this tumultuous information. Those eyes! I asked Pawlikowski about them. “Contact lenses,” he replied.

《祖国》中也有一次自杀,尽管我们没有亲眼目睹。我们看到的只是艾丽卡·曼听到噩耗时的反应。像英格玛·伯格曼一样——《祖国》确实受惠于伯格曼的《野草莓》(1957),另一场苦涩而沉思的朝圣之旅——帕夫利科夫斯基习惯于以事件对人脸的影响来衡量它们。在《偷车贼》开头,当一个孩子被催促别再游手好闲、去找份工作时,我们看到的是他,而不是那位成年劝告者。同样,在《修女艾达》中,当女主人公(阿加塔·特热布霍夫斯卡饰)被告知“你是犹太人”时,我们得到的是一个半身镜头:她穿着修女服,稳稳地站着,用那双深色的、一眨不眨的眼睛,吸收着这石破天惊的信息。那双眼睛!我问帕夫利科夫斯基关于它们的事。“隐形眼镜,”他回答。

Ida’s stillness is shared by the whole film, which seems more confidently rooted than anything in Pawlikowski’s previous endeavors. “For the first time, I was really on firm ground with what I wanted,” he said. He was back on home turf, in Poland, with a narrow budget, discarding inessentials. “When you limit the elements and actors and locations and props, then you can drill in,” he told me. “Limit yourself, and that frees you up.” Objects become loaded with intent; a skull is unearthed and bundled inside a silk scarf. Pawlikowski describes all this as “a big breakthrough,” though it sounds more like an epiphany. “I also had this moment of rejection of cinema, you know? I said, ‘Fuck cinema.’ ” Part of the rejecting was what he calls “this radical decision not to move the camera, and to frame things in a very amateurish way, with a lot of headroom.” The aim was “to make things happen within the shot.”

艾达的静穆为整部电影所共享,它似乎比帕夫利科夫斯基此前任何作品都更自信地扎根。“第一次,我真的对自己想要什么有了坚实的把握,”他说。他回到了故土波兰,预算有限,摒弃一切非必要之物。“当你限制元素、演员、地点和道具时,你就能深入钻探,”他告诉我。“限制自己,反而让你获得自由。”物件变得充满意图;一颗头骨被挖出,裹进一条丝巾里。帕夫利科夫斯基把这一切描述为“一次重大突破”,尽管听起来更像一次顿悟。“我也有过这种拒绝电影的时刻,你知道吗?我说,‘去他妈的电影。’”拒绝的一部分是他所称的“这个激进的决定:不移动摄影机,以一种非常业余的方式构图,留出大量头顶空间。”目的是“让事情在镜头内部发生。”

To anyone viewing the result, the heavy, looming space above the characters feels like the pressure of their intolerable thoughts; to Ryszard Lenczewski, however, the director of photography on “Ida,” it was all askew, and he quit the project. Pawlikowski asked the camera operator, a young guy named Łukasz Żal, to take over temporarily. “In two days, a weight was lifted from my shoulders,” the director says. He and Żal have worked together ever since.

对于任何观看成片的人来说,人物上方沉重而迫近的空间,就像他们难以忍受的思想的压力;然而对《修女艾达》的摄影指导雷沙德·伦切夫斯基来说,这一切都是歪的,他退出了项目。帕夫利科夫斯基请摄影操作员——一个叫乌卡什·扎尔的年轻人——临时接手。“两天之内,我肩上的重担卸下了,”导演说。他和扎尔从此一直合作。
People standing near a car.
Pawlikowski and his cinematographer, Łukasz Żal, favor a still camera and shots with a lot of headroom—a heavy, looming space above the characters that Zischler calls “a narration in itself.”
帕夫利科夫斯基和他的摄影师卢卡什·扎尔偏爱固定机位和留有大片头顶空间的镜头——人物上方那片沉重、逼近的空间被齐施勒称为“一种自成一体的叙事”。
Photograph by Agata Grzybowska / Courtesy MUBI

So determined are “Ida,” “Cold War,” and “Fatherland,” in their careful dramatic momentum, that you assume they must all be _pre_determined. Not so. “I don’t like this business of writing at a desk,” Pawlikowski said to me. In recent times, he has worked in Greece, on the island of Hydra, where he has a place. But the best lines, he believes, are produced “spontaneously, in situ.” Collaborations can help, “sometimes with a co-writer. Then I do it with actors, and then I do it while I’m location scouting and rehearsing and shooting.” In other words, “the filmmaking is part of the writing.”

《修女艾达》、《冷战》和《祖国》以其精心的戏剧推进力如此坚定,以至于你会以为它们必定都是预先确定的。并非如此。“我不喜欢坐在书桌前写作这回事,”帕夫利科夫斯基对我说。近年来,他在希腊的伊兹拉岛工作,他在那里有住处。但他相信,最好的台词是“即兴产生的,在现场。”合作可以有所帮助,“有时和联合编剧一起。然后我和演员一起做,再然后在勘景、排练和拍摄时做。”换句话说,“拍电影就是写作的一部分。”

A case in point: there is a scene in “Fatherland” in which Thomas Mann is greeted by two young men at a reception. In the script, he asks, “How is your mother?”—“ihre Mutter,” in German. On set, however, Hanns Zischler, playing Mann, suggested changing the words to “ihre Frau Mutter”—“your good lady mother,” let’s say, stiffened with old-fashioned courtesy. The tweak stayed in, and one can see why. The youths are, in fact, grandsons of Wagner, and their mother is the composer’s daughter-in-law; they request that Mann assist in reviving Wagner’s reputation, which has been sullied by the Nazis’ eager embrace of his music. Polite to a fault, not raising his voice, Mann responds, “Bayreuth should be razed to the ground, and your mother should be on trial.”

一个例子:《祖国》中有一场戏,托马斯·曼在一个招待会上被两个年轻人问候。剧本中,他问:“你母亲好吗?”——德语是“ihre Mutter”。然而在片场,饰演曼的汉斯·齐施勒建议把措辞改成“ihre Frau Mutter”——姑且译为“令堂大人”,带着老派礼节的僵硬感。这个微调保留了下来,原因显而易见。那两个年轻人实际上是瓦格纳的外孙,他们的母亲是作曲家的儿媳;他们请求曼协助恢复瓦格纳的声誉——后者因纳粹热切拥抱其音乐而蒙羞。礼貌到无可挑剔,曼没有提高嗓门,回答道:“拜罗伊特应该被夷为平地,你们的母亲应该受审。”

The role of Mann fits Zischler like a handmade suit. He is the veteran of two notable films set along the fault lines of his country—Wim Wenders’s “Kings of the Road” (1976) and Jean-Luc Godard’s “Germany Year 90 Nine Zero” (1991). Moreover, he is not only an actor but an author, steeped in Goethe, and he wrote a deeply researched book on the moviegoing habits of Franz Kafka. (It’s hard to picture the writer of “The Trial” watching Chaplin’s “The Kid,” in 1922, but he did, twice.) Indeed, so erudite is Zischler that, in the midst of shooting “Fatherland,” Pawlikowski advised him, “Don’t think too much about what you know.”

曼这个角色与齐施勒的契合,就像量身定做的西装。他是两部沿德国断层线展开的重要电影的老兵——维姆·文德斯的《公路之王》(1976)和让-吕克·戈达尔的《德国九零年》(1991)。此外,他不仅是演员,还是作家,深谙歌德,并写了一本研究弗朗茨·卡夫卡观影习惯的深入著作。(很难想象《审判》的作者在1922年看卓别林的《寻子遇仙记》,但他确实看了,而且看了两遍。)事实上,齐施勒博学到如此程度,以至于在拍摄《祖国》期间,帕夫利科夫斯基建议他:“别想太多你知道的东西。”

I talked to Zischler, the soul of geniality, over tea and cakes in his apartment, in a peaceful western patch of Berlin. Pawlikowski, he told me, had issued an ominous warning before filming commenced: “He said, ‘I’m going to be cruel to you.’ But he was never cruel.” It was more a matter of being resolute. As Zischler puts it, “He knows very well what he wants.” The rapport between Pawlikowski and Żal? “Osmotic.” And that tricky space above the actors’ heads? “It’s a narration in itself.” Pay attention, Zischler proposed, to all the doors that open and close in the film—the entrances and exits that mark the progress of the tale. “It’s like turning the pages of an album,” he said. I thought of the family photograph albums, so close to Pawlikowski’s heart.

我在柏林西部一片宁静的街区,在齐施勒的公寓里,边喝茶吃点心边与他交谈。他性情极为和蔼。他告诉我,帕夫利科夫斯基在开拍前发出了一个不祥的警告:“他说,‘我会对你很残忍。’但他从来没有残忍过。”更多是一种坚定。正如齐施勒所说:“他非常清楚自己想要什么。”帕夫利科夫斯基和扎尔之间的默契?“渗透性的。”演员头顶上方那个棘手的空间呢?“它本身就是一种叙事。”齐施勒提议,注意影片中所有开开关关的门——那些标志着故事进程的进出。“就像翻动一本相册的书页,”他说。我想起了那些家庭相册,那些帕夫利科夫斯基珍藏在心的相册。

There is an extraordinary travelling shot, early in “Fatherland,” that sets the ruined scene. From inside the car, with Erika at the wheel, and a motorcyclist leading onward like a herald, we see the streets of Frankfurt passing by, still gutted by wartime bombs. Nowhere in modern Germany, it seems, was sufficiently ramshackle; Lower Silesia, in Poland, had to play the part. A related problem arose with the human backdrop. Pawlikowski told me that he and his casting assistants spent five months looking for extras, just to find the right faces for the period. Back then, “people didn’t know how they looked. That’s one reason I stopped making documentaries,” he said. Nowadays, “everyone photographs themselves all the time, so they know what photography does to them.”

《祖国》开头有一个非凡的移动镜头,奠定了满目疮痍的场景。从车内视角,艾丽卡握着方向盘,一名摩托车手像传令官一样在前引路,我们看到法兰科夫的街道从旁掠过,仍被战时炸弹掏空。现代德国似乎没有哪里足够破败;波兰的下西里西亚不得不扮演这个角色。一个相关的问题出现在人物背景上。帕夫利科夫斯基告诉我,他和选角助理花了五个月寻找群众演员,只为找到那个时代的正确面孔。那时候,“人们不知道自己长什么样。这是我停止拍纪录片的原因之一,”他说。如今,“每个人都在不停地自拍,所以他们知道摄影会对自己产生什么效果。”

“Fatherland” also plays with the puzzle of history. In reality, it was Mann’s wife, not Erika, who went with him to Germany in 1949. Pawlikowski reconfigured the journey—the emotional dynamic—to his satisfaction, and it’s hard to cavil at the outcome. Consider Erika, in Weimar, walking out of a lecture hall, unable to bear yet another speech by her famous father. Pawlikowski, surveying the city, came across a graveyard that was adorned with old statues, worn by lichen and time; and that is where Erika strolls, seeking refuge, on a bright day. Unexpectedly, like a dancer, the camera stirs and glides. Why now? Zischler has a theory: “Erika wants to prevent Thomas becoming a monument.”

《祖国》也在玩味历史的谜题。现实中,1949年陪曼去德国的是他的妻子,不是艾丽卡。帕夫利科夫斯基按照自己的意愿重新配置了这段旅程——情感动力——而结果很难让人挑剔。想想艾丽卡在魏玛,走出演讲厅,再也无法忍受她著名父亲的又一场演讲。帕夫利科夫斯基在城中勘察时,发现了一片墓地,装饰着被地衣和时间侵蚀的古老雕像;艾丽卡就在那里漫步,在一个晴朗的日子里寻求庇护。出人意料地,摄影机像舞者一样动了起来,滑行。为什么是此刻?齐施勒有一个理论:“艾丽卡想阻止托马斯变成一座纪念碑。”

It’s a fine and persuasive reading of the sequence, and, I would say, of the entire film. As Erika wisely perceives, Mann is being both honored and used, passing through a land on which he is expected to pronounce but where he no longer feels at ease. “Where is home?” he is asked by an American journalist at a press conference. “My home now is in California,” he says. “But where my Heimat is, where I belong, is a much more difficult question.”

这是对那个段落——我认为也是对整部电影——的精妙而有说服力的解读。正如艾丽卡明智地察觉到的那样,曼既在被尊崇,也在被利用,他穿过一片土地,人们期待他对这片土地发表评判,但他已不再感到自在。“家在哪里?”一位美国记者在新闻发布会上问他。“我现在的家在加利福尼亚,”他说。“但我的Heimat在哪里,我归属的地方在哪里,是一个困难得多的问题。”

That question has nagged at Pawlikowski’s output, from his earliest documentaries to the present day. Stand back, and you see a pattern emerge: a continual, delicate dialogue between fixity and flux. Think of Dmitri Dostoevsky, roaming the used-car dealerships of Germany in search of his motorized dream; of the frontiers that are tussled over in “Serbian Epics,” in the cause of ethnic bullying; of the Russian woman and her son in “Last Resort,” stuck in an England that doesn’t want them, pleading first to stay and then to leave; and, in “Cold War,” of the Polish consular official, in Paris, who says to the lovelorn hero, “You’re not French, and you’re not a Pole, either. As far as we’re concerned, you don’t exist.”

这个问题一直纠缠着帕夫利科夫斯基的作品,从最早的纪录片直到今天。退后一步,你会看到一个模式浮现:固定与流动之间持续而微妙的对话。想想德米特里·陀思妥耶夫斯基,在德国的二手车行里游荡,寻找他机动化的梦想;想想《塞尔维亚史诗》中为种族霸凌而争夺的边界;想想《最后归宿》中那个俄罗斯女人和她的儿子,困在一个不想要他们的英国,先是恳求留下,然后又恳求离开;还有《冷战》中,在巴黎的波兰领事官员对那位为情所困的主人公说:“你不是法国人,也不是波兰人。就我们而言,你不存在。”

“Fatherland” is supported by twin pillars: not just Thomas Mann but also Goethe, whose house Mann visits, in awkward reverence, and whose death mask is shown in closeup, gleaming as white as bone. It was Goethe—Germany incarnate—who declared, in a letter of 1799, “The fatherland of the man who thinks without prejudice, who can rise above his time, is nowhere and everywhere.” Whether that’s a promise or a cautionary tale is up to you.

《祖国》由两根支柱支撑:不仅是托马斯·曼,还有歌德——曼怀着局促的敬意参观了歌德的故居,歌德的死亡面具以特写呈现,白如骨骼。正是歌德——德国的化身——在1799年的一封信中宣称:“一个不带偏见地思考、能超越自己时代的人,他的祖国无处可寻,又无处不在。”这究竟是一个承诺,还是一个警示故事,由你自己判断。

And what of Pawlikowski himself? Where is his home of homes? These days, he spends time on Hydra, with his second wife, Malgorzata Bela, whom he married in 2017; last year, he made a short film with her there, titled “Muse.” When in Warsaw, he lives on the street where he grew up; he also makes frequent trips to London, where he sees his children and stays with an old friend, Alfonso Cuarón, the director of “Gravity” and “Roma.” A master of stillness, Paweł Pawlikowski is still on the move. The little boy from Warsaw is running free. Sitting in a café in Sarajevo, he said to me, “Every film has to be a roof over my head for three years.” It’s not such a bad place to live. ♦

那么帕夫利科夫斯基自己呢?他最终的归宿在哪里?如今,他有时住在伊兹拉岛,与第二任妻子玛乌戈热塔·贝拉在一起,他们于2017年结婚;去年,他和她在那里拍了一部短片,名为《缪斯》。在华沙时,他住在他长大的那条街上;他还经常去伦敦,在那里看望孩子们,并住在老朋友阿方索·卡隆——执导《地心引力》和《罗马》的导演——家里。一位静穆的大师,帕维尔·帕夫利科夫斯基仍在路上。那个华沙的小男孩在自由奔跑。坐在萨拉热窝的一家咖啡馆里,他对我说:“每一部电影都必须成为我头顶上三年的屋顶。”这地方住着,不算太糟。 ♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month