The Lede

How Could an Upgrade Cancel Eighteen Thousand Flights?

一次系统升级,何以导致一万八千架次航班取消?
The F.A.A.’s ground stop was one of the worst travel disruptions since 9/11. Here’s what does and doesn’t make sense about the Trump Administration’s story.
美国联邦航空管理局下达的地面停飞令,是自“9·11”以来最严重的出行中断之一。特朗普政府对事件的解释,哪些说得通,哪些说不通,且看下文。
Image may contain Sean Duffy Electronics Screen Computer Hardware Hardware Monitor TV Adult and Person
Photograph by Daniel Heuer / Reuters

At a press conference on Friday, Sean Duffy, the Secretary of Transportation, tried to explain why the Federal Aviation Administration prevented U.S. flights from taking off for more than four hours on Friday. The internet was quick to speculate that artificial intelligence or cyberattacks were to blame. Duffy’s story, in contrast, was almost comically mundane. He said that the failure happened after a contractor, L3Harris, replaced an old router in the national air-traffic-control system with a more modern one. He also mentioned an ongoing replacement of copper cables with fibre-optic cables. “Our switches, our routers actually got overloaded with data, and they went down. Actually, I shouldn’t say they went down. They started to give us inconsistencies,” Duffy said. The resulting ground stop caused the longest-lasting disruption in nationwide air travel since September 11, 2001. For the four largest airlines, the economic losses could add up to three hundred and forty-five million dollars, according to one estimate.

在周五的记者会上,交通部长肖恩·达菲试图解释,联邦航空管理局为何在周五让美国航班停飞超过四个小时。互联网上迅速有人猜测,罪魁祸首是人工智能或网络攻击。相比之下,达菲的说法几乎平淡得有些滑稽。他说,故障发生在承包商L3Harris用一台更先进的路由器替换了全国空中交通管制系统中一台老旧路由器之后。他还提到,铜缆正在陆续更换为光缆。“我们的交换机、我们的路由器实际上被数据过载压垮了,然后宕机了。其实,我不该说它们宕机了。它们开始给我们输出不一致的数据。”达菲说。由此引发的地面停飞,造成了自2001年9月11日以来持续时间最长的全国性航空出行中断。据一项估算,仅对四大航空公司而言,经济损失就可能累计高达三亿四千五百万美元。

Duffy, who studied marketing in college before becoming an attorney, does not have a background in planes, computers, or communications systems. Neither does Markwayne Mullin, the Secretary of Homeland Security, who appeared alongside him. Mullin, a former House representative and senator, has a degree in plumbing from Oklahoma State University Institute of Technology. Both Duffy and Mullin were quick to blame Congress, which has been controlled by Republicans since 2023, for failing to fund system-wide upgrades to the air-traffic-control system. Duffy then asked for fifty billion dollars for the Federal Aviation Administration, up from thirty billion dollars that the Trump Administration had requested previously. “I’m going to say it a million times,” Duffy said. “Congress has to give the resources to the President so he can finish this build.”

达菲大学读的是市场营销,后来才成为律师,并没有飞机、计算机或通信系统方面的背景。与他一同出席的国土安全部长马克韦恩·穆林也没有。穆林曾任众议员和参议员,拥有俄克拉荷马州立大学理工学院的水管工程学位。达菲和穆林都迅速把矛头指向国会,指责其未能为空中交通管制系统的全面升级提供资金——而国会自2023年以来一直由共和党掌控。达菲随后要求为联邦航空管理局拨款五百亿美元,高于特朗普政府此前提出的三百亿美元。“这句话我要说一百万遍,”达菲说,“国会必须把资源交给总统,好让他完成这项建设。”

To understand whether a router could down the air-control system, one needs some context. The F.A.A. has about eleven thousand certified air-traffic controllers who work at hundreds of airports and dozens of radar-control centers. They constantly receive information directly from cockpits, and from hundreds of radar installations, which either bounce electromagnetic waves off planes or communicate with beacons in the belly of aircraft. As a flight moves across the country, it passes from one air-traffic-control sector to another, meaning that a controller has to hand it off to a colleague in the next sector.

要理解一台路由器是否足以瘫痪空中交通管制系统,需要先了解一些背景。联邦航空管理局拥有约一万一千名持证空中交通管制员,分布在数百座机场和数十个雷达管制中心工作。他们持续不断地从驾驶舱以及数百套雷达装置接收信息,这些雷达要么向飞机反射电磁波,要么与机腹中的应答信标通信。当一架航班飞越全国时,它会从一个空中交通管制扇区进入另一个扇区,这意味着管制员必须把它移交给下一个扇区的同事。

With thousands of planes in the air at any hour of the day, and about thirty-five hundred flying at the time of Friday’s ground stop, the system has to be highly automated. One controller might click on a screen to initiate a handoff, and the next controller will click a screen to accept it. Then a lot of critical data—the identity of the flight, its altitude, and its airspeed—is transferred from the first controller to the second. Oral communication, over radio circuits, also has to be routed. It’s fairly common for fumbled handoffs to cause problems; if controllers don’t have reliable information about where each airplane is, or have trouble talking to crews, they have difficulty insuring that each airplane keeps its distance from every other.

一天中任何时刻都有数千架飞机在空中,而周五地面停飞令下达时,约有三千五百架飞机正在飞行,因此这套系统必须高度自动化。一位管制员可能点击屏幕发起移交,下一位管制员点击屏幕接受移交。随后,大量关键数据——航班身份、飞行高度、空速——从第一位管制员传输给第二位管制员。无线电线路上的语音通信也必须进行路由。交接失误引发问题相当常见;如果管制员无法可靠掌握每架飞机的位置,或者难以与机组通话,他们就很难确保每架飞机与其他飞机保持安全距离。

This is where the routers come in. At the press conference, Duffy mentioned problems with communications at Air Route Traffic Control Centers, or A.R.T.C.C.s, which generally oversee high-altitude, long-distance flights. Airliners take off under the supervision of a tower controller, who then transfers the flight to a mid-level facility called a Terminal Radar Approach Control, or TRACON. From there, jurisdiction goes to one of the twenty A.R.T.C.C.s that cover the Lower Forty-eight states. Each transfer depends on a computer network that relies on routers communicating seamlessly. A controller would struggle to do her job if she stopped receiving consistent data and voice communication from flights; the fix is to stop adding planes to the system, through a ground stop.

路由器正是在这个环节发挥作用。在记者会上,达菲提到航路交通管制中心(A.R.T.C.C.)出现通信问题,这些中心通常负责监管高空、长途航班。客机在塔台管制员的监督下起飞,随后塔台将航班移交给一个中层设施,即终端雷达进近管制中心(TRACON)。从那里开始,管辖权移交给覆盖美国本土四十八州的二十个航路交通管制中心之一。每一次移交都依赖计算机网络,而计算机网络又依赖路由器之间的无缝通信。如果管制员无法持续收到来自航班的稳定数据和语音通信,她就很难完成工作;解决办法就是通过地面停飞,停止向系统中增加飞机。

As a reporter who covered aviation for twenty years, I found Duffy’s explanation to be plausible. If a glitch interferes with flight data, then it is prudent to prevent additional flights from taking off. (One question for the agency is why new equipment was being installed during a relatively busy travel period, without the option of reverting to the legacy equipment.) Unfortunately, we should expect such disruptions to happen again. The air-traffic-control system is often described as “aging.” Nick Daniels, the head of the National Air Traffic Controllers Association, the union for U.S. controllers, told NPR that “some of the equipment, when I go into the towers, is older than I am. And I’m only forty-eight.” Updating our aviation infrastructure is not optional; what we don’t modernize will eventually break. Of course, as we learned on Friday, sometimes the cure for aging infrastructure is worse than the disease.

作为一名报道航空业二十年的记者,我认为达菲的解释是可信的。如果某个故障干扰了飞行数据,那么阻止更多航班起飞是审慎之举。(该机构需要回答的一个问题是:为什么在出行相对繁忙的时段安装新设备,却没有保留回退到旧设备的选项。)遗憾的是,我们应当预料到此类中断还会再次发生。空中交通管制系统常被形容为“老化”。美国空中交通管制员工会——全国空中交通管制员协会负责人尼克·丹尼尔斯告诉美国国家公共电台:“我走进塔台时,有些设备比我的年纪还大。而我才四十八岁。”更新我们的航空基础设施不是可选项;我们不加以现代化的东西终将损坏。当然,正如我们周五所领教的,有时候,治疗老化基础设施的药方比疾病本身更糟。

The rest of the Trump Administration’s story, however, is implausible at best. Trump is the first President to have owned an airline, the Trump Shuttle, which operated from 1989 to 1992, and he is clearly fascinated by jetliners. He has claimed that the entire air-traffic-control system needs to be replaced in one go, and he blamed the Biden Administration for its current difficulties. “Everything they touched turned bad,” he wrote on Truth Social. “Big money spent unwisely, making an old and broken system worse than when they began.” Duffy blamed decades of underinvestment across many Presidential Administrations.

然而,特朗普政府说法的其余部分,往好里说也难以令人信服。特朗普是第一位拥有过航空公司的总统——特朗普快线航空,1989年至1992年间运营——而且他显然对喷气式客机着迷。他曾声称整个空中交通管制系统需要一次性全部更换,并把当前的困难归咎于拜登政府。“他们碰过的一切都变糟了,”他在“真相社交”上写道,“大笔资金花得不明智,把一个又老又破的系统搞得比他们接手时更糟。”达菲则归咎于历届总统政府数十年的投资不足。

In fact, the air-traffic-control system has been a work in progress since its creation, in 1958, after a horrific midair collision in Grand Canyon National Park, in Arizona. It will probably always be one. When I started covering aviation, the Clinton Administration was promising to modernize the system; in 1994, at what was then Washington National Airport, the Transportation Secretary, Federico Peña, held up an old vacuum tube. Vice-President Al Gore, who was there, too, said that the tubes had come from active air-traffic-control infrastructure, and that they were so old that only former Communist countries still made them. Our infrastructure was aging even then.

事实上,空中交通管制系统自1958年创建以来——那是在亚利桑那州大峡谷国家公园发生一起惨烈空中相撞事故之后——就一直是项未竟工程。它很可能永远都是。我刚开始报道航空业时,克林顿政府正承诺要实现系统现代化;1994年,在当时的华盛顿国家机场,交通部长费德里科·佩尼亚举起一只老旧的真空管。同样在场的副总统阿尔·戈尔说,这些真空管来自正在服役的空中交通管制基础设施,而且它们老旧到只有前共产主义国家还在生产。我们的基础设施即便在当时就已经老化了。

The Trump Administration did not do the F.A.A. any favors when its Department of Government Efficiency hastily ordered cuts, in 2025, prompting hundreds of employees to retire or resign. About four hundred probationary employees at the F.A.A. were fired, although a hundred and thirty-two were later reinstated by a court. Some of the lost workers supported air-traffic control. A more significant change, however, is that in-house technician work has gradually been outsourced to contractors. After the ground stop, the union representing those technicians, Professional Aviation Safety Specialists, or PASS, issued a statement: “Historically contractors have followed a protocol where FAA employees conduct a risk assessment and coordinate the maintenance of the system or equipment. PASS-represented technicians were not involved in the upgrades that led to the ground stop.”

特朗普政府并没有给联邦航空管理局帮上什么忙:2025年,其政府效率部仓促下令削减,促使数百名员工退休或辞职。联邦航空管理局约四百名试用期员工被解雇,尽管其中一百三十二人后来被法院裁定复职。一些流失的员工原本为空中交通管制提供支持。然而,一个更重要的变化是,内部技术人员的工作已逐渐外包给承包商。地面停飞事件发生后,代表这些技术人员的工会——职业航空安全专家协会(PASS)发表声明:“历史上,承包商一直遵循一项规程,即由联邦航空管理局员工进行风险评估并协调系统或设备的维护。PASS所代表的技术人员并未参与导致此次地面停飞的升级工作。”

Perhaps the most unusual thing about Friday’s ground stop was its scale. Over the years, numerous smaller failures have been caused by technicians inadvertently cutting live communications cables while trying to install new equipment. In the mid-nineties, during upgrades to power supplies, F.A.A. radar-control centers suffered ten major power failures in quick succession. The agency blamed seven of them on personnel operating the new equipment improperly. Changes in aviation also introduce new challenges. It’s more difficult to control air traffic under the hub-and-spoke airport model, in which airlines centralize their flights in a small number of major airports. This method gained popularity among U.S. carriers after the deregulation of the air industry, in the nineteen-seventies.

周五地面停飞最不寻常之处,或许在于其规模之大。多年来,技术人员在尝试安装新设备时无意中切断在用通信电缆,曾引发过无数次较小规模的故障。九十年代中期,在电源升级期间,联邦航空管理局的雷达管制中心接连发生了十起重大电力故障。该机构将其中七起归咎于人员对新设备操作不当。航空业的变化也带来了新的挑战。在枢纽辐射式机场模式下,航空公司把航班集中到少数几个大型机场,空中交通管制变得更加困难。这种模式在七十年代航空业放松管制后,逐渐受到美国航空公司的青睐。

Then there is the Trump Administration’s demand for fifty billion dollars. Over the coming decades, virtually all of the electronic equipment in the system will be replaced. Still, there are limits to how fast the F.A.A. can absorb the money. Under Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which passed in 2025, the agency received twelve and a half billion dollars, but so far it has spent very little of it. This should not surprise us. The air-traffic-control system is spread out over millions of square miles, and it is not replaced in one go as an airplane would be. Components tend to be upgraded one at a time, so that if a part fails or turns out to be incompatible, it can be fixed. We’ve also known for a long time that the F.A.A. is short on air-traffic controllers—but hiring more of them temporarily worsens the shortage, because it means diverting a fully certified controller from day-to-day air-traffic control to training. (It doesn’t help that the federal government is operating without a budget, under a continuing resolution that expires on December 11th, which prevents agencies from pursuing ambitious modernization projects.)

再说特朗普政府提出的五百亿美元拨款要求。未来几十年里,系统中几乎所有的电子设备都将被更换。尽管如此,联邦航空管理局吸纳资金的速度终究有限。根据特朗普2025年通过的《一个大而美的法案》,该机构获得了一百二十五亿美元,但迄今为止实际支出甚少。这不应令我们感到意外。空中交通管制系统分布在数百万平方英里的范围内,它不可能像一架飞机那样一次性整体更换。各个部件往往逐一升级,这样一旦某个部件出现故障或被发现不兼容,就可以单独修复。我们也很早就知道,联邦航空管理局缺少空中交通管制员——但增聘管制员短期内反而会加剧人手短缺,因为这意味着要把一名完全持证的管制员从日常空中交通管制工作中抽调出来去从事培训。(雪上加霜的是,联邦政府目前在没有正式预算的情况下运转,依靠的是一项将于12月11日到期的持续决议,这使各机构无法推进雄心勃勃的现代化项目。)

Lots of big, complicated systems suffer from component failures. Storms, demand spikes, and aging infrastructure can cause localized blackouts in the electric grid. But air traffic is more vulnerable, because its ripple effects can be so extensive. A plane that waits on the ground for an hour, or four, delays not only its passengers and its cargo but also the passengers who were supposed to board for its next leg. Flight crews can work only so many hours before they “time out,” so after four hours there may not be anybody on hand to fly or staff the original flight. In late September, after damage to a communications cable near a rail line in New Jersey, nine hundred flights were cancelled; another five thousand were delayed. This time, more than eighteen thousand flights were cancelled, and more than twenty-eight thousand were delayed. Days later, flights were still running late. ♦

许多庞大而复杂的系统都会遭遇部件故障。暴风雨、需求激增和基础设施老化,都可能导致电网出现局部停电。但空中交通更为脆弱,因为它的连锁反应可能极其广泛。一架在地面等待一小时或四小时的飞机,延误的不仅是它的乘客和货物,还有本应登上它下一航段的乘客。机组人员的工作时长有限,超时就会“到点下班”,因此四小时之后,可能已经没有人在场执飞或为原定航班配备人员。九月下旬,新泽西州一条铁路线附近的通信电缆受损,导致九百架次航班取消,另有五千架次延误。这一次,超过一万八千架次航班被取消,超过两万八千架次延误。数天之后,航班仍在延误。♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month