Annals of Education

How China Learned to Love the Classics

中国如何学会爱上经典
The Chinese Communist Party has embraced the study of Greek and Latin—as, in some ways, an antidote to the modern West.
中国共产党倡导学习希腊语和拉丁语——在某种程度上,这是对现代西方文化的一种反思与借鉴。
greek chinese pottery ceramics broken plate warrior dragon
Illustration by Javier Jaén

In November, 2024, on the day of the U.S. Presidential election, Tim Whitmarsh landed in Beijing, jet-lagged and disoriented. It was the middle of the academic term at the University of Cambridge, where Whitmarsh holds the Regius Professorship in Greek. He had been flown business class halfway around the world and put up at a five-star hotel for what he had been told would be the first World Conference of Classics. What followed, he later wrote, was “the strangest and most momentous” event of his academic career.

2024年11月,美国总统大选日当天,蒂姆·惠特马什(Tim Whitmarsh)抵达北京。时差与陌生感让他有些恍惚。此时正值剑桥大学的学期中段——惠特马什在那里担任希腊学钦定讲席教授。他乘坐商务舱飞越半个地球,下榻五星级酒店,受邀参加据称是首届世界古典学大会的活动。后来他写道,随后发生的事成了他学术生涯中“最离奇也最具转折意义”的经历。

By eight o’clock the next morning, Whitmarsh was north of Beijing at the palatial Yanqi Lake international convention center. The venue, reportedly part of an almost six-billion-dollar construction project, had previously hosted the APEC summit. Whitmarsh was ushered into a side room with distinguished guests, among them Lina Mendoni, the Greek minister of culture. The presiding politician was one of Xi Jinping’s closest confidants: China’s propaganda chief, Li Shulei. Li shook hands with Whitmarsh and exchanged platitudes with the other guests. It wasn’t until Whitmarsh had been herded into the main hall that he grasped what he’d signed up for: “a geopolitical event, not an intellectual one,” as he put it, with hosts including Greece and China’s ministries of culture.

第二天早上八点,惠特马什已经抵达北京北郊的雁栖湖国际会议中心。这座宫殿般的建筑据称是耗资近六十亿美元建设项目的一部分,曾举办过亚太经合组织峰会。惠特马什被引入一间侧厅,与贵宾们会面,其中包括希腊文化部长莉娜·门佐尼。主持仪式的官员是习近平最亲密的幕僚之一:中宣部部长李书磊。李书磊与惠特马什握手,并与其他来宾寒暄。直到被引至主会场,惠特马什才意识到自己参与的是怎样的场合——用他的话说,这是“一场地缘政治活动,而非学术活动”,主办方包括希腊和中国文化部。

Inside a conference hall roughly the size of a football field sat hundreds of people—ambassadors, politicians, and scholars. At the podium, Li read out a letter from Xi, which described ancient Greece and China as two civilizations that have shaped humanity’s development from opposite sides of Eurasia. Xi went on to encourage their cultural exchange and announced the establishment of a Chinese School of Classical Studies in Athens.

在一个足球场大小的会议厅里,坐着数百人——大使、政治家和学者。在讲台上,李宣读了一封来自习近平的信,信中描述古希腊和中国是塑造人类发展的两大文明,它们位于欧亚大陆的两端。习近平接着鼓励两国进行文化交流,并宣布在雅典设立中国古典学学院。

Whitmarsh, who, with other Western-trained scholars, had led a group called the Postclassicisms Collective, realized that he had prepared the wrong speech. In the years since Donald Trump entered politics, emboldening fascists and white supremacists who held rallies deploying Roman imagery, Whitmarsh and the others had come to repudiate a traditional view of their field that he summed up as the “passing of a baton, down through the ages from like-minded person to like-minded person.” When it came time for Whitmarsh to speak, he argued that ancient texts didn’t spring from some timeless ur-culture, and that they should not be treated as such. “ ‘Classical Greece,’ ” he said to the Chinese and Greek dignitaries, is “an invention of the classical Greeks themselves.”

与其他受过西方学术训练的学者一同领导“后古典主义研究小组”的惠特马什意识到,自己准备的演讲词并不合时宜。自唐纳德·特朗普踏入政坛以来,那些挥舞罗马旗帜的法西斯主义者和白人至上主义者愈发猖獗,促使惠特马什与同仁们开始反思古典学领域的传统观念——他将这种观念概括为“跨越时代的接力棒,在思想相近者手中代代相传”。轮到他发言时,他提出古代文献并非源自某种永恒的原初文化,也不应被如此对待。“'古典希腊',”他对中希两国政要说,“本身就是古典希腊人的发明。”

When we met for drinks two months later, Whitmarsh wondered whether he might have accidentally offered a warning for China: “Maybe it was the right speech after all,” he told me.

两个月后我们再次见面小酌时,惠特马什思忖着,自己或许在无意间为中国敲响了警钟:“也许那场演讲终究是对的。”他这样告诉我。

The World Conference of Classics had all the signs of a typical political spectacle, intended to cultivate appreciation for Chinese culture abroad. Yet Li and other scholars—many of whom can recall a time when their own intellectual traditions were denounced by Mao Zedong as “feudal dross”—also expressed admiration for the Western classics. One keynote at the conference was delivered by Liu Xiaofeng, one of the most prolific translators of ancient Greek thought into Chinese, and the gathering’s official theme was about “mutual learning.” The enthusiasm, in China, for Western classics also comes from below. In the years before Secretary of State Marco Rubio threatened to “aggressively” revoke Chinese student visas, nearly three hundred thousand Chinese enrolled at U.S. universities each year. Thousands learned ancient Greek and Latin. Many returning Chinese scholars brought their Western training and methodologies back to the Chinese academy, prompting university officials to find ways to categorize—and make use of—their skills.

这场世界古典学大会有着典型政治秀的一切特征,旨在培养海外对中国文化的欣赏。然而,李猛和其他学者——他们中许多人仍记得毛泽东曾将自身智识传统斥为“封建糟粕”的年代——也表达了对西方经典的推崇。大会主旨演讲者刘小枫是将古希腊思想译介至中文世界最高产的学者之一,会议官方主题亦围绕“互鉴”展开。在中国,对西方经典的热情同样源自民间。在国务卿马可·卢比奥扬言要“强势”吊销中国留学生签证的前些年,每年有近三十万中国学子赴美深造,其中数千人研习古希腊语与拉丁语。许多归国学者将西方学术训练与方法论带回中国学界,促使高校管理者探索如何界定——并善用——这些跨文化学识。

Even as foreign textbooks are banned and news broadcasts portray Western societies as gun-toting hellscapes, Chinese universities are hiring Greco-Roman classicists. One Beijing university recently completed a new translation of Plato. Another university established a research center, led by an Oxford professor, that puts ancient Chinese texts in conversation with other classical textual traditions, including Greek and Latin. The reason for the classics fervor varies depending on whom you ask, but most scholars agree that Chinese officials tend to see the Western classics as a complement to their politics. In recent years, Xi has made “cultural confidence” a cornerstone of national policy, referring to pride in Chinese traditions and values. Across China, archeological museums and exhibitions are multiplying, and neglected villages are being refurbished into stage-set “ancient” towns. At universities, the study of ancient Chinese texts has historically been scattered across disciplines; now, under government direction, universities are trying to gather that scholarship in new classics departments where, one theory goes, ancient truths can be nurtured and passed down. In 2024, Renmin University, in Beijing, became the first university in China to offer an undergraduate major in Chinese classical studies. Last March, Sichuan University opened a classics department, aiming to educate students to be “conversant in both Chinese and Western learning.” “When China looks at the world, they want to be like Greece,” Martin Kern, a Princeton Sinologist and keynote speaker at the World Conference of Classics, told me. “Greece is for Europe what China is for East Asia. You guys have Socrates. We have Confucius.”

尽管外国教科书被禁,新闻广播将西方社会描绘成枪林弹雨的人间地狱,中国大学却在招聘希腊罗马古典学学者。北京一所大学近期完成了柏拉图著作的新译本。另一所大学成立了一个由牛津大学教授领衔的研究中心,致力于将中国古代典籍与希腊、拉丁等其他古典文本传统进行对话研究。 关于这股古典学热潮的成因众说纷纭,但大多数学者认为,中国官方倾向于将西方古典视为其政治理念的补充。近年来,习近平将“文化自信”确立为国策基石,强调对中国传统与价值观的自豪感。全国各地考古博物馆与展览如雨后春笋般涌现,被遗忘的村落被改造成舞台布景式的“古镇”。 在大学层面,中国古代文本研究历来分散于不同学科;如今在政府引导下,各高校正尝试将这些学术力量汇聚到新建的古典学系——有观点认为,这将成为培育与传承古老智慧的土壤。2024年,北京中国人民大学率先在全国开设中国古典学本科专业。去年三月,四川大学成立古典学系,旨在培养“学贯中西”的人才。 “当中国审视世界时,他们想成为希腊那样的存在,”普林斯顿大学汉学家、世界古典学大会主旨演讲人柯马丁告诉我,“希腊之于欧洲,恰如中国之于东亚。你们有苏格拉底,我们有孔子。”

By now, it is almost a cliché to say that the Western classics are in crisis. During the past half dozen years, around ten universities and colleges have closed their classics departments or programs, with some folded into larger humanities units. Western classicists look to the classics revival in China with a mix of awe, envy, and hesitation: a geopolitical rival could very well value their discipline more than their home institutions. In 2023, Shadi Bartsch, a classicist at the University of Chicago, covered the cresting interest among Chinese intellectuals, in ancient Greek and Roman texts, in “Plato Goes to China.” From late Qing reformers inspired by Athenian citizenship to nationalists who draw on Plato to bolster China’s political ideology, Bartsch shows how supple ancient texts are in the hands of interpreters. Yet she also acknowledged the upsides of a foreign government’s support for her field. “There is real interest in the question of whether China is going to become the main protector of the western classics,” she told me over e-mail.

如今,说西方古典学陷入危机几乎已是陈词滥调。过去六年间,约有十所高校关闭了古典学系或相关项目,部分被并入更广泛的人文学科单位。西方古典学者以混杂着惊叹、艳羡与犹疑的目光,注视着中国兴起的古典学热潮:这个地缘政治对手对其学科的重视程度,很可能已超越其本土机构。2023年,芝加哥大学古典学者沙迪·巴奇(Shadi Bartsch)在《柏拉图走向中国》一书中,记录了中国知识分子对古希腊罗马文本日益高涨的兴趣。从受雅典公民精神启发的晚清改革者,到援引柏拉图以巩固中国政治意识形态的民族主义者,巴奇展示了古代文本在阐释者手中何其柔韧。但她亦承认外国政府支持该领域的益处。“中国是否会成为西方古典学的主要守护者,这确实是个引人深思的问题,”她在给我的电子邮件中写道。

When I heard that China was hosting a lavish event with esteemed foreign classicists, I was curious: Who had orchestrated this? The story, according to several scholars I spoke to, begins in 2021, when Chinese and Greek education officials started setting up research centers—one in China and one in Greece—aimed at deepening understanding of the two ancient civilizations. In February, 2023, as Greek administrators prepared to celebrate the opening of a center in Athens, they received an unusual suggestion from the local Chinese Embassy: write a letter to Xi Jinping. One administrator told me that he was baffled, but that the embassy staff seemed confident that something would come of it.

听说中国举办了一场盛大的活动,邀请外国知名古典学家出席,我很好奇:是谁策划了这一切?据几位与我交谈的学者说,故事始于2021年,当时中国和希腊的教育官员开始设立研究中心——一个在中国,一个在希腊——旨在加深对两大古代文明的理解。2023年2月,希腊官员准备庆祝雅典的一个研究中心开幕时,他们收到了当地中国大使馆一个不寻常的建议:给习近平写一封信。一位官员告诉我,他当时很困惑,但大使馆工作人员似乎确信这会带来一些结果。

The inaugural ceremony for the so-called Center of Greek and Chinese Ancient Civilizations was attended by Sun Chunlan, a Chinese Vice-Premier at the time. Sun brought with her a reply letter from Xi Jinping congratulating the Greek scholars on the center’s opening. In the following weeks, Chinese media visited the center to report on how its then president had been honored by Xi’s reply. “Glittering at each other, from each end of the Eurasian continent,” Xi had written, China and Greece should work together to promote mutual learning. The letter codified the idea that the modern West—defined by liberalism, constitutionalism, and multi-party democracy—could be separated, conceptually, from the ancient West, as represented by Greece and Rome. In China’s civilization-building cause, the former was an ideological adversary; the latter could become an ally.

所谓“希腊和中国古代文明中心”的开幕仪式上,时任中国副总理的孙春兰出席。她带来了习近平致希腊学者的回信,祝贺该中心成立。在接下来的几周里,中国媒体纷纷前往该中心采访报道,讲述时任中心主席如何因收到习近平的回信而感到荣幸。“交相辉映,跨越欧亚大陆两端,”习近平在信中写道,中国和希腊应携手促进文明互鉴。这封信确立了一种理念:以自由主义、宪政和多党民主为特征的现代西方,在概念上可以与以希腊和罗马为代表的古代西方区分开来。在中国的文明建设事业中,前者是意识形态上的对手;后者则可以成为盟友。

With Xi’s approval, momentum built quickly. One of the Chinese ministries involved in the joint centers helped organize the World Conference of Classics. They tapped China’s top academic institutions—Peking University, Renmin University, and Tsinghua University, among others—to draw up guest lists, and the universities relied in part on Western-educated faculty to send out the invitations. One of the invited professors, Jonathan Ready, of the University of Michigan, recalled feeling as taken aback as Whitmarsh. He had also flown business class, and had been squired to the front of the assembly for reasons he could not explain. “It was the most lavish conference I have ever, and will ever, go to,” he told me.

在习近平的批准下,联合中心的推进工作迅速展开。参与联合中心建设的一个中国部委协助组织了世界古典学大会。他们邀请中国顶尖学术机构——北京大学、中国人民大学、清华大学等——拟定嘉宾名单,这些大学部分依靠有西方教育背景的教职人员发出邀请。受邀教授之一、密歇根大学的乔纳森·雷迪(Jonathan Ready)回忆说,他和惠特马什一样感到惊讶。他也乘坐了商务舱,并且不知为何被引到会场前排就座。“这是我参加过、也将是未来参加过的最奢华的会议,”他告诉我。

Ready had been invited by a former student named He Yanxiao, whom he had taught at Indiana University, and who eventually went on to a postdoc at Tsinghua University. In December, 2024, I met up with Yanxiao for dinner in Beijing. A lanky bespectacled man in his early thirties, Yanxiao recalled that his interest in classics began during his freshman year of high school, when he encountered a Chinese translation of the Odyssey. Like a true Marxist, he told me, he was searching for references to slavery, but he kept getting distracted by the tale. “I just found it so beautiful,” he said. He resolved to teach himself ancient Greek. Few resources existed for Chinese to study Greek at the time, but a new pair of introductory textbooks had been published recently by Liu Xiaofeng, the prolific translator.

雷迪(Ready)是应一位名叫何彦霄的前学生之邀来到中国的。何彦霄在印第安纳大学时曾师从雷迪,后来在清华大学做博士后。2024年12月,我在北京与彦霄共进晚餐。他三十出头,身材瘦长,戴着眼镜。他回忆说,自己对古典学的兴趣始于高一那年,当时他读到了《奥德赛》的中译本。他告诉我,作为一个真正的马克思主义者,他本想在书中寻找关于奴隶制的记载,却总被故事本身吸引。“我只是觉得它太美了,”他说。他决心自学古希腊语。当时中国人学习希腊语的资源很少,但多产的翻译家刘小枫刚出版了一套新的入门教材。

Liu was then a philosophy professor at Sun Yat-sen University in southern China, where he taught ancient Greek and Latin. He has since produced or edited several hundred translated works and interpretations. He is best known in the West, however, for his popular writings on the philosopher Leo Strauss, in the early two-thousands, which sparked what the Chinese media dubbed “Strauss fever.” In the years following Deng Xiaoping’s turn toward a capitalist economy, some Chinese intellectuals felt a kind of spiritual malaise; Deng’s reforms had failed to provide moral direction for a vast and proud former empire. Liu began to understand China’s aimlessness in the language of Strauss, who famously argued that Western civilization had strayed from its ideals of “Jerusalem and Athens.” (“How could I be so close to this person?” Liu once wrote.) Liu proposed that the aim of Chinese intellectuals should be to “rebuild the spirit of Chinese traditional civilization,” by studying the ancient texts of the West. It was no accident, Liu wrote, that Western superpowers once schooled their future leaders in ancient Greek and Latin. China, Liu concluded, needed a classics department.

刘当时是中国南方中山大学的哲学教授,教授古希腊语和拉丁语。此后,他创作或编辑了数百部译作和阐释作品。然而,他在西方最为人所知的是二十一世纪初关于哲学家列奥·施特劳斯的通俗著作,这些作品引发了被中国媒体称为“施特劳斯热”的现象。在邓小平转向资本主义经济后的几年里,一些中国知识分子感到一种精神上的萎靡;邓小平的改革未能为这个幅员辽阔、曾经骄傲的古老帝国提供道德指引。刘开始用施特劳斯的语言来理解中国的迷茫——施特劳斯曾提出著名论断,认为西方文明已偏离了“耶路撒冷与雅典”的理想(“我怎会与此人如此接近?”刘曾这样写道)。刘提出,中国知识分子的目标应该是通过研究西方古代经典来“重建中华传统文明的精神”。刘写道,西方超级大国曾用古希腊语和拉丁语培养未来领导人,这绝非偶然。刘得出结论:中国需要设立古典学系。

Until recently, Liu was a noisy member of the Chinese intelligentsia, with little influence in politics. But, with Xi Jinping’s endorsement of the classics, Liu’s Straussian ideas have percolated into the upper echelons of the Party. In 2024, three of Liu’s protégés entered a newly established classics research office at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, a state think tank with close ties to policymakers, multiple Chinese classicists told me. They became integral players in the organization of the World Conference of Classics.

直到不久前,刘小枫仍是中国知识界一位高调却对政治影响甚微的人物。但随着习近平对经典的推崇,刘小枫的施特劳斯式思想已渗透至党内高层。多位中国古典学者告诉我,2024年,刘小枫的三位门生进入了中国社会科学院新成立的经典研究办公室——这个国家智库与政策制定者关系密切。他们成为世界古典学大会筹备工作中的核心参与者。

Yanxiao devoted himself to mastering the Confucian classics, and he eventually looked to study abroad, transferring, as a college junior, to Indiana University. There, Yanxiao began to realize how particular Liu’s approach to antiquity was. Classics historiography, which Yanxiao was learning at Indiana, makes you “function like a detective.” “You want to see how history is narrated, so you collect all kinds of evidence,” he told me. For Liu, by contrast, the study of the classics seemed almost subservient to a process of cultural empowerment. In a 2015 article, ten foreign-educated Chinese scholars were interviewed on how to institutionalize classics in China. Among the points they seemed to agree on was their wish to distance themselves from Liu’s approach. “Westerners do not speak of ‘usefulness,’ ” Zhang Wei, of Fudan University, said. In the fall of 2016, Yanxiao entered the Ph.D. program in ancient history at the University of Chicago. Soon after, classics became increasingly embroiled in America’s culture wars. White nationalists at Charlottesville marched hoisting Roman flags, and far-right internet personalities adopted Roman pseudonyms. A field beset by declining enrollments faced a reckoning over its role—complicity, even—in the ideologies of Western superiority that animated white supremacists. These tensions came to the fore in 2019, during an annual meeting, in San Diego, of the Society for Classical Studies. (It happened to be Yanxiao’s first time at the conference.) At a panel titled “The Future of Classics,” a Princeton historian of Rome named Dan-el Padilla Peralta presented data showcasing the underrepresentation of Black and minority authors in top classics journals. During the Q. & A., an independent scholar named Mary Frances Williams stood up to challenge the panelists. “Maybe we should start defending our discipline,” she said. The classics, after all, were the foundation of Western ideals like liberty, democracy, and freedom. Williams went on to say to Padilla Peralta, “You may have got your job because you’re Black, but I would prefer to think you got your job because of merit.” He replied that he wanted nothing to do with the vision of classics that Williams had outlined. “I hope the field dies,” he said. “And that it dies as swiftly as possible.”

严萧潜心钻研儒家经典,后来决定出国深造,大三时转学到印第安纳大学。在那里,严萧开始意识到刘氏治古学的方法有多么独特。严萧在印第安纳大学学习的古典史学,要求你“像侦探一样工作”。“你想了解历史是如何被叙述的,所以你要收集各种证据,”他告诉我。相比之下,刘氏研究经典的方式,似乎几乎从属于一种文化赋权的过程。2015年的一篇文章采访了十位有海外留学背景的中国学者,探讨如何在中国将经典研究制度化。他们似乎达成共识的一点是,希望与刘氏的方法保持距离。“西方人不谈'有用性',”复旦大学的张伟说。2016年秋天,严萧进入芝加哥大学古代史博士项目。不久之后,古典学在美国的文化战争中越陷越深。夏洛茨维尔的白人民族主义者高举罗马旗帜游行,极右翼网络人物采用罗马化名。这个本就因入学人数下降而步履维艰的学科,不得不面对其在助长白人至上主义者所鼓吹的西方优越论意识形态中所扮演的角色——甚至是共谋——的清算。这些紧张关系在2019年圣地亚哥举行的古典学研究学会年会上达到了顶点。(这恰好是严萧第一次参加该会议。)在一场题为“古典学的未来”的小组讨论中,普林斯顿大学罗马史学者丹-埃尔·帕迪利亚·佩拉尔塔展示了数据,揭示顶尖古典学期刊中黑人及少数族裔作者代表性不足的问题。在问答环节,一位名叫玛丽·弗朗西斯·威廉姆斯的独立学者起身质疑小组成员。“也许我们应该开始捍卫我们的学科了,”她说。毕竟,古典学是自由、民主等西方理想的基础。威廉姆斯接着对帕迪利亚·佩拉尔塔说:“你得到这份工作可能是因为你是黑人,但我更愿意认为你是凭实力得到这份工作的。”他回答说,他与威廉姆斯所勾勒的古典学愿景毫无关系。“我希望这个领域消亡,”他说。“而且越快越好。”

For many classicists, the “incident,” as they now call it, made clear that a selective vision of the field had undermined the authority of scholars from marginal communities. “Our field was, like, What are we doing?” Christopher Waldo, an Asian American classicist at the University of Washington, recalled. “There’s not just one thing that Greco-Roman antiquity signifies.” That year, Waldo created the Asian and Asian American Classical Caucus, which promotes the study of how Asian and Asian American cultures have interpreted antiquity. Other affinity groups, including Trans in Classics and CripAntiquity, started congregating around the same time. Padilla Peralta described the aims of like-minded scholars as “de-centering Greece and Rome as the primary or main locus of intellectual innovation.”

在许多古典学者看来,这场如今被他们称为“事件”的风波清楚地表明,这个领域的选择性视野已经削弱了边缘社群学者的权威。“我们当时都在想,这个领域到底在做什么?”华盛顿大学的亚裔古典学者克里斯托弗·沃尔多回忆道,“希腊罗马古代文明所代表的意义远不止一种。”那年,沃尔多创立了亚洲与亚裔古典学者联盟,致力于研究亚洲及亚裔文化如何诠释古代文明。其他志同道合的团体,包括“跨性别古典研究”和“残障视角古代研究”,也几乎在同一时期开始聚集。帕迪亚·佩拉尔塔将志同道合学者们的目标描述为“将希腊和罗马从知识创新的首要或主要中心位置移开”。

For some Chinese scholars, who turned to the Greco-Roman classics for the perceived wisdom and cultural capital it conferred, the focus on marginalized voices in antiquity was grating. In 2021, an anonymous Chinese doctoral student in the United States published an article that circulated widely among Chinese classics students, bemoaning the “absurd reality of American academia.” The author blamed Padilla Peralta for stoking a culture of denunciations, using terms that evoked the Cultural Revolution. A commenter on the article made the link more succinctly: “Down with Confucius, burn the Pantheon—different formula, familiar flavor.”

在一些中国学者看来,转向希腊罗马古典研究是为了获取其中蕴含的智慧与文化资本,因此学界对古代边缘群体的关注令他们颇为不适。2021年,一位在美国攻读博士学位的中国留学生匿名发表文章,痛陈“美国学术界的荒谬现实”,在华人古典学圈内广为流传。作者指责帕迪利亚·佩拉尔塔助长了告密文化,其用词令人联想到文化大革命。一位评论者更精炼地概括了这种关联:“打倒孔夫子,烧毁万神殿——配方不同,味道依旧。”

Yanxiao told me that, in his first few years at the University of Chicago, he had not thought of himself as Asian. “I used to think we were all academics huddled in the ivory tower working toward one intellectual pursuit,” he told me. Yanxiao broke from that view in 2019, when he spent a year as an exchange student at the University of California, Berkeley. Later, he began reading academic work on K-pop. Scholars such as the ethnomusicologist Michael Fuhr saw K-pop as a reversal of long-standing narratives, especially in pop music, that accentuated the flow of culture from West to East. It was an alluring idea for Yanxiao, who was raised in an environment shaped by the reception, and rejection, of Western ideas. K-pop scholarship, Yanxiao said, “shocked him” into embracing his Asian identity.

严晓告诉我,在芝加哥大学的最初几年,他并不认为自己属于亚洲人。“我过去以为,我们都是蜷缩在象牙塔里、为同一个智识追求而努力的学者,”他对我说。2019年,严晓在加州大学伯克利分校交换学习一年,这个想法开始改变。后来,他开始阅读关于K-pop的学术著作。民族音乐学家迈克尔·富尔等学者认为,K-pop扭转了长期以来的叙事——尤其是在流行音乐领域——那种强调文化从西方向东方流动的叙事。对于在接纳与排斥西方思想交织的环境中长大的严晓来说,这是个诱人的想法。严晓说,K-pop研究“震撼了他”,促使他拥抱自己的亚洲身份。

In the enlarged vision of the classics slowly taking shape in the American academy, Yanxiao has found an intellectual foothold. He studies interactions between the eastern half of the Roman Empire and East Asia, and sheds light on how popular art forms were often misunderstood by their ancient critics. In the fall of 2024, he flew to Princeton, where he delivered a lecture on Roman pantomime, a dance form that once dominated theatres across the Mediterranean. Comparing élite Roman accounts that dismissed pantomime as a vulgar import from the East with the way K-pop had been received by some Anglophone critics, Yanxiao reframed pantomime as a transformative hybrid of “East” and “West”—between the Empire’s eastern provinces and Rome—rather than a corrupt derivative. Padilla Peralta, who attended the lecture, called the paper “spectacular.” Yanxiao had proved, Padilla Peralta told me, that people of diverse backgrounds, and the “interventions” they brought to the field, led to a “richening of the historical fabric, not to its impoverishment.”

在美国学界逐渐成形的、视野更为开阔的古典学研究中,严潇找到了自己的学术立足点。他研究罗马帝国东部与东亚之间的互动,并揭示古代评论家如何常常误解流行艺术形式。2024年秋天,他飞往普林斯顿大学,就曾风靡地中海各地剧院的舞蹈形式——罗马哑剧发表演讲。他将罗马精英阶层将哑剧贬为东方粗俗舶来品的论述,与某些英语评论家对K-pop的接受方式进行比较,从而将哑剧重新定义为帝国东部行省与罗马之间“东方”与“西方”的变革性融合,而非堕落的衍生品。出席讲座的帕迪利亚·佩拉尔塔称这篇论文“精彩绝伦”。他告诉我,严潇证明了多元背景的研究者及其为这一领域带来的“介入”,能够“丰富而非削弱历史肌理”。

When the pandemic broke out, in 2020, Yanxiao returned to China to write his dissertation. He hardly recognized the country. Electronic payment methods had become almost universal. Futuristic cafés and boba parlors dotted major cities. The progress didn’t seem to extend to the academy, however. In the fall of 2023, Yanxiao joined Tsinghua University, where his research confused professors who were accustomed to more conventional disciplinary lines. “People at Tsinghua wondered whether my interest in K-pop was a sign that I was intellectually unserious,” Yanxiao told me.

2020年疫情暴发时,严潇回到中国撰写博士论文。眼前的故土让他感到陌生——电子支付几乎无处不在,未来感十足的咖啡馆与奶茶店遍布各大城市。然而学术界的景象似乎并未同步更新。2023年秋季,严潇入职清华大学,他的研究方向让习惯传统学科分野的教授们困惑不已。“清华的师长们怀疑,我对韩国流行音乐的研究兴趣是否意味着学术态度不够严肃。”严潇这样告诉我。

Yanxiao worked to bridge China’s more conservative academy with the post-classicist current in the West. After the Society for Classical Studies published a special issue on race and racism following George Floyd’s murder, he conducted an interview with one of the issue’s editors for the Shanghai Review of Books. In 2020, the University of California, Berkeley, renamed its classics department “Ancient Greek and Roman Studies.” Yanxiao interviewed the Berkeley professor James Porter about the reasons behind the change. Porter, who, with Tim Whitmarsh, was a member of the Postclassicisms Collective, suggested to Yanxiao that, as Chinese scholars develop their own classics field, they need not repeat the West’s problems. They could start with “post-classicism” and “work backwards,” he said.

严霄致力于弥合中国较为保守的学术圈与西方后古典主义思潮之间的鸿沟。乔治·弗洛伊德遇害后,美国古典学学会出版了种族与种族主义特辑,严霄随即为《上海书评》采访了该特辑的一位编辑。2020年,加州大学伯克利分校将其古典学系更名为“古希腊罗马研究系”。严霄就此采访了伯克利教授詹姆斯·波特(James Porter),探讨更名背后的动因。作为“后古典主义研究小组”成员(另一位成员是蒂姆·惠特马什[Tim Whitmarsh]),波特向严霄建议:中国学者在发展本土古典学时,不必重蹈西方的覆辙。他们完全可以从“后古典主义”出发,“逆向构建”自己的学术传统。

In the Western academy, the study of antiquity has moved toward a more fractious, intercultural vision of the past. Yanxiao feels that Chinese classics must make similar accommodations, incorporating different perspectives on culture and class, to remain globally relevant. Straussianism, Yanxiao feared, would “isolate Chinese classics” from his fellow-practitioners in the United States and Europe.

在西方学术界,古典研究正朝着更为多元、更具文化交融性的历史观发展。严晓认为,中国古典研究也必须作出相应调整,纳入文化与阶级的不同视角,才能保持全球影响力。他担心,施特劳斯主义会让中国古典研究“孤立于”欧美同行之外。

In this mission, Yanxiao has found allies, like Jinyu Liu, a professor of Roman history at Emory University, in Atlanta. Around 2014, Liu began bringing American classicists on lecture tours through Chinese universities. She hosts exchanges between Chinese and American classicists, and has created an online, peer-reviewed database with Dickinson College, in Pennsylvania, that works on Chinese translations of Greek and Latin texts. “We’re revolutionizing the way Chinese learn Greek and Latin,” Liu said. In 2017, Martin Kern, the Princeton professor, co-founded the International Center for the Study of Ancient Text Cultures, at Renmin University, with an early China scholar named Xu Jianwei. They invite scholars of various antiquities—Greece, Rome, Mesopotamia, Israel, India, Japan, Egypt, and the Arab world—to present findings in their respective fields. “You realize many of the problems you encounter also exist in other classical traditions,” Xu told me. During one session in August, 2024, Xu discussed a theory as to why educators in ancient China preferred oral recitation as a way to teach: winters in the north were so frigid that basic tools like ink and brushes would freeze. Xu recalled the excitement of some of his interlocutors, including the Western classicist Glenn Most. “He said ‘I never thought of that!’ ” Xu told me with a smile. Questions about the weather’s impact on philological practice, Most thought, could be asked of ancient Greece as well.

在此次使命中,严晓找到了盟友,比如亚特兰大埃默里大学的罗马史教授刘津瑜。大约在2014年,刘津瑜开始带领美国古典学者到中国高校进行巡回讲座。她主持中美古典学者间的交流活动,并与宾夕法尼亚州的迪金森学院合作创建了一个在线同行评审数据库,专门处理希腊语和拉丁语文本的中文翻译工作。“我们正在彻底改变中国人学习希腊语和拉丁语的方式,”刘津瑜说。2017年,普林斯顿大学教授马丁·柯马丁与早期中国研究学者徐建委共同在中国人民大学创立了古代文本文化国际研究中心。他们邀请研究不同古代文明——希腊、罗马、美索不达米亚、以色列、印度、日本、埃及和阿拉伯世界——的学者,展示各自领域的研究成果。“你会发现许多你遇到的问题也存在于其他古典传统中,”徐建委告诉我。在2024年8月的一次研讨会上,徐建委探讨了关于古代中国教育者为何偏爱口诵教学的理论:北方冬季严寒,墨、笔等基本书写工具会冻结。他回忆起包括西方古典学者格伦·莫斯特在内的一些对话者的兴奋之情。“他说'我从未想到这一点!'”徐建委微笑着告诉我。莫斯特认为,关于天气对语文学实践影响的问题,同样可以适用于古希腊。

Yanxiao had mixed feelings about the World Conference of Classics. A part of him felt immense pride when Xi Jinping’s letter was being read out. “This really niche thing I’ve been pursuing since high school got such mainstream attention,” Yanxiao told me. “So many foreign scholars realized that China was investing heavily in classics—something they couldn’t imagine in their own countries.” To be a classicist in Xi’s China was to operate with a halo usually reserved for scientists and engineers. For Yanxiao and other classics scholars, this will translate into more job openings, conferences, and opportunities to publish and lecture. But everything he had learned in America made him chafe at the conference’s emphasis on timeless wisdom. As Whitmarsh put it in the Times Literary Supplement last January, in an article recounting his experience at the conference, “We were enjoined to celebrate diversity and respect between nations—or at least two of them—but not within them.”

燕晓对这场世界古典学大会心情复杂。当习近平的贺信被宣读时,他内心涌起强烈的自豪感。“我从高中就开始钻研的冷门学问,竟然获得了如此主流的关注,”燕晓告诉我,“那么多外国学者意识到中国正在大力投入古典学研究——这在他们自己国家是难以想象的。”在习近平领导的中国,古典学者头顶的光环通常只属于科学家和工程师。对燕晓和其他古典学者而言,这意味着更多职位空缺、学术会议、出版与讲学机会。但他在美国所学的一切,都让他对大会强调的“永恒智慧”感到不适。正如惠特马什去年一月在《泰晤士报文学增刊》回顾参会经历的文章中所言:“我们被要求歌颂国家间的多样性与相互尊重——或至少是两个国家之间——而非国家内部的多样性。”

Last year, I accompanied Yanxiao to the annual Society for Classical Studies conference, held at a Marriott in downtown Philadelphia. Paper titles included “Queer Spaces in Pompeii?,” “Ecofeminist Narratives in Ovid’s Metamorphoses,” and “Ocean Vuong, Allusion, and the Limits of Interpretation.” Defenders of the new classics—with its incorporation of race, gender, pop culture, and comparative frameworks—see it as a more faithful representation of antiquity itself. “When you study the classics,” Whitmarsh told me, coherence is an illusion. “It’s more like a disorganized mash that we try to piece together.”

去年,我陪燕晓参加了在费城市中心万豪酒店举行的古典研究学会年会。论文题目包括《庞贝城中的酷儿空间?》、《奥维德〈变形记〉中的生态女性主义叙事》和《王海洋、典故与阐释的边界》。支持新古典学——融合种族、性别、流行文化和比较研究框架——的人认为,这更能真实地反映古代世界本身。“研究古典学时,”惠特马什告诉我,连贯性只是一种幻觉。“它更像是一团杂乱无章的糊状物,我们试图将其拼凑起来。”

Yanxiao had prepared a talk on the Xiongnu Empire, a formidable power that occupied some lands north of Han Dynasty China. As he stepped up to the lectern, the monitors flashed an image of the first slide: it was a scene from the movie “Crazy Rich Asians.” Yanxiao began to recount the story of Eleanor Young, played by the actress Michelle Yeoh, who arrives at a grand London hotel with her family in the nineteen-nineties. She is turned away by the hotel staff, who, unaware that she is the new owner, claim they are “fully booked” and suggest she try “Chinatown.” On the next slide, Yanxiao shared a list of rejections he’d received from classics journals, along with the reviewer’s comments. “If I have Chinese material or say something about my ethnicity, the reviewers suggest that the research should belong in Sinology journals,” he said. “That’s what I call Chinatown Classics.”

严肖准备了一场关于匈奴帝国的演讲,这个强大的帝国曾占据汉朝以北的部分土地。当他走上讲台时,屏幕上闪现出第一张幻灯片:那是电影《摘金奇缘》中的一个场景。严肖开始讲述杨紫琼饰演的埃莉诺·杨的故事:上世纪九十年代,她带着家人来到伦敦一家豪华酒店,却被酒店员工拒之门外——对方不知道她是新业主,声称“客房已满”,并建议她“去唐人街试试”。下一张幻灯片上,严肖展示了他收到的古典学期刊拒稿信列表,以及审稿人的意见。“如果我研究中国材料或提及自己的族裔背景,审稿人就会建议这项研究应该属于汉学期刊,”他说,“这就是我所谓的'唐人街古典学'。”

Returning to the core of his talk, Yanxiao likened the Xiongnu’s impact on the West to that of the Mongols, who, a millennium later, would alter the cultural topology of Eurasia. To grasp this piece of Roman history, Yanxiao argued, one had to study the Xiongnu—and to understand the Xiongnu, one had to read Chinese.

回到演讲的核心,严晓将匈奴对西方的影响比作千年后改变欧亚文化版图的蒙古人。他认为,要理解这段罗马历史,就必须研究匈奴;而要理解匈奴,就必须阅读中文。

On the last day of the conference, I had coffee with Yanxiao at the Marriott lobby. The conversation turned to the future, and I asked him which country he saw himself settling in. Applying for jobs in China was difficult, Yanxiao told me, because his research still bewilders some scholars, who thought he’d been “brainwashed by American gender-and-identity politics.” Still, he had come to appreciate the convenience and comfort of life in China—its high-speed rail, e-payments, and ultra-fast delivery systems.

会议最后一天,我和严潇在万豪酒店大堂喝咖啡。话题转向未来,我问他觉得自己会在哪个国家定居。严潇告诉我,在中国找工作很难,因为他的研究仍让一些学者感到困惑,他们认为他“被美国的性别与身份政治洗脑了”。不过,他也开始欣赏中国生活的便利与舒适——高铁、电子支付和极速配送系统。

Outside the hotel, the snow had turned into sleet. Yanxiao had just returned from a stroll through the Philly streets, where the cityscape made him feel alienated, he told me. The typical American city was not as comforting to him as a typical Chinese one. At the Marriott, though, a sunny, more sociable side of Yanxiao seemed to come out. Friends waved him over, and younger Chinese scholars sought his attention. Among classicists, Yanxiao told me, he “felt totally at home.” ♦

酒店外,雪已转为雨夹雪。颜潇刚从费城街头散步回来,他告诉我,这座城市的景观让他感到疏离。典型的美国城市对他来说,不如典型的中国城市那样令人安心。然而,在万豪酒店里,颜潇似乎显露出更阳光、更善交际的一面。朋友们向他挥手致意,年轻的中国学者们也渴望得到他的关注。颜潇告诉我,在古典学学者中间,他感到“完全自在”。♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month