Letter from Trump’s Washington

Can You Fire the Vice-President via Truth Social?

你能通过“真相社交”炒掉副总统吗?
Donald Trump came close on Thursday, ousting J. D. Vance as his Iran negotiator days after the Veep blamed the war for the Republicans’ midterm losses.
唐纳德·特朗普周四差点就这么干了。在副总统万斯将共和党中期选举失利归咎于战争几天后,特朗普解除了万斯伊朗谈判代表的职务。
Donald Trump raising his arms out with red and blue overlay
Source photograph by Mandel Ngan / AFP / Getty

Can a temper tantrum last for two full years? In the nine days since the voters of red America administered a brutal takedown of Donald Trump and his Republican Party, the President has announced on “60 Minutes” that he’d rather keep hating his enemies than go to heaven, instructed his aides to threaten prosecution of members of Congress who investigate him, publicly questioned the integrity of the results after promising on Election Night that he would accept them, and promoted Stephen Miller as his new White House chief of staff. Trump may be a lame duck, but he is not going anywhere quietly.

一场脾气能持续整整两年吗?在红州选民对唐纳德·特朗普及其共和党进行残酷清算后的九天里,这位总统在《60分钟》节目中宣布,他宁愿继续仇恨敌人也不愿上天堂;他指示助手威胁起诉调查他的国会议员;他在选举之夜承诺接受选举结果后,又公开质疑结果的公正性;他还提拔斯蒂芬·米勒为新任白宫幕僚长。特朗普或许是一只跛脚鸭,但他绝不会悄无声息地离开。

On Thursday, Trump began his morning meltdown with a 5:50 A.M. Truth Social post complaining about how “viciously” he and his Administration were being accused of corruption by Democrats when they were the ones who were “CORRUPT AND EVIL.” Thirty-eight minutes later, he accused them of “illegally threatening Republicans with knowingly false accusations and charges.” By 7:04 A.M., he had reverted to one of his favored tropes from his first term, warning that “Huge CARAVANS” of illegal immigrants were on their way to invade the U.S. from the south and that, if they weren’t stopped, he would immediately double tariffs on Mexico. At 10:59 A.M., with no public events on his schedule, he was still at it, wondering, in his best who-will-rid-me-of-this-meddlesome-priest mode, when someone would finally get around to prosecuting the “Seditious Six” Democratic members of Congress, who, a year ago, posted a video reminding U.S. military personnel that they were not required to follow illegal orders.

周四,特朗普的清晨崩溃始于凌晨5点50分在“真相社交”上发帖,抱怨民主党人“恶毒地”指责他和他的政府腐败,而真正“腐败又邪恶”的恰恰是对方。三十八分钟后,他指责民主党人“以明知虚假的指控和罪名非法威胁共和党人”。到早上7点04分,他又回到了第一任期时的惯用套路,警告说“庞大的移民大篷车队”正从南部涌来入侵美国,如果无法阻止,他将立即对墨西哥加倍征收关税。上午10点59分,日程表上没有任何公开活动,他还在发帖,以他那种“谁能替我除掉这个多管闲事的神父”的口吻,琢磨着什么时候才会有人终于起诉国会里那“煽动六人组”——这六名民主党议员一年前发布了一段视频,提醒美国军人他们没有义务服从非法命令。

Historians take note: It’s our first-ever case of an American President shit-posting through the pain of a historic midterm defeat. No amount of self-soothing on social media, however, seems to have quelled the President’s rage over the midterms, and I suppose it’s only fitting that his fury should be equal to the scale of the electoral drubbing, which was truly epic. With ballots still being counted, Democrats are pushing close to a fourteen-point lead in the national House popular vote, the widest margin for the Party in more than fifty years. In my lifetime, Republicans have never come close to that big of a popular-vote win in a midterm. Trump’s record thus far in his second term has accomplished the previously unthinkable political feat of uniting Ohio, Kansas, North Carolina, South Carolina, Texas, and even Mississippi against him and his candidates.

历史学家请注意:这是美国历史上首次有总统在历史性中期选举惨败的痛苦中疯狂刷屏发泄。然而,无论多少社交媒体上的自我安慰,似乎都没能平息总统对中期选举的怒火。我想,他的愤怒与这场选举惨败的规模相称,倒也恰如其分——这场惨败堪称史诗级。选票仍在统计中,民主党在全国众议院普选票中的领先优势已逼近十四个百分点,这是该党五十多年来最大的领先幅度。在我有生之年,共和党从未在中期选举中接近过如此之大的普选票优势。特朗普第二任期迄今为止的政绩,完成了一项此前不可想象的政治壮举:将俄亥俄、堪萨斯、北卡罗来纳、南卡罗来纳、得克萨斯,甚至密西西比,统统团结到了他和他的候选人阵营的对立面。

Perhaps most notable among Thursday morning’s posts was Trump’s announcement, at 8:07 A.M., that he was immediately relieving J. D. Vance of responsibility for negotiating a peace deal with Iran. “We don’t need a deal with Iran,” Trump said—he wanted the Vice-President to dedicate his “complete and total attention” to uncovering the “Massive Corruption and Crime” taking place in Democratic-run cities and states across the land. In other words, the feckless Veep has been fired from his effort to bring an end to the war that Vance claims was the reason Republicans lost so bigly in last week’s election.

周四上午的帖子中,最引人注目的或许是特朗普在早上8点07分宣布,他立即解除万斯负责与伊朗谈判和平协议的责任。“我们不需要跟伊朗达成协议,”特朗普说——他希望副总统将“全部注意力”投入到揭露民主党执政的城市和州中正在发生的“大规模腐败和犯罪”。换句话说,这位无能的副总统已被踢出了结束战争的努力——而万斯恰恰声称,这场战争是共和党在上周选举中输得如此惨烈的原因。

It is likely not a coincidence that Vance’s ouster from the Iran portfolio came within hours of the Wall Street Journal reporting that the Vice-President was open to an in-person meeting with Mohsen Rezaei, the hard-liner who is now secretary of Iran’s Supreme National Security Council. Did Trump fear a sellout? He can hardly have expected Vance, with his obvious desperation to end a conflict that seems to be destroying what remaining hope he has of becoming President, to drive a hard bargain. Or maybe it was just that Trump woke up in a bad mood. Whatever the proximate cause of the President’s decision, it has underscored—in the all-caps way that Trump likes his decisions to be underscored—that, on the matter of the conflict in the Middle East, his Vice-President no longer speaks for him.

万斯被解除伊朗事务职责,很可能并非巧合——就在几小时前,《华尔街日报》报道称,副总统对与穆赫辛·雷扎伊举行面对面会谈持开放态度。雷扎伊是强硬派,现任伊朗最高国家安全委员会秘书。特朗普是担心万斯会出卖美国利益吗?他很难指望万斯能谈出强硬条件——万斯显然迫切希望结束这场冲突,因为这场冲突似乎正在摧毁他仅存的当总统的希望。又或许,特朗普只是起床时心情不好。无论总统做出这一决定的直接原因是什么,它都以特朗普喜欢的那种全大写方式强调了一件事:在中东冲突问题上,他的副总统不再代表他发言。

There’s a lot to unpack in this one. Most important, there’s the question of just what Trump is planning to do to exit a war that has dragged down his Presidency. Before Election Day, Trump had suggested that he was considering a new military escalation to end the stalemate with Iran; since then, he has abruptly pivoted in the other direction, telling “60 Minutes” that he did not see “any reason” to do so. By rejecting a new round of fighting and a new round of negotiating in the past few days, Trump appears to be signalling that he’s going for some version of the status quo, a netherworld of neither war nor peace, in which the U.S. tries to crush Iran through a naval blockade and punitive economic sanctions, while averting the humiliation of a deal on Iran’s terms or the shock of another wave of military attacks across the region.

这件事里有太多值得剖析的地方。最重要的是,特朗普究竟打算如何退出这场拖累了他总统任期的战争。选举日之前,特朗普曾暗示他正在考虑新一轮军事升级,以打破与伊朗的僵局;此后,他突然转向相反方向,告诉《60分钟》他看不出“有任何理由”这样做。过去几天里,特朗普既拒绝了新一轮战斗,也拒绝了新一轮谈判,这似乎是在释放信号:他准备维持某种现状——一个非战非和的灰色地带,美国试图通过海上封锁和惩罚性经济制裁来压垮伊朗,同时避免以伊朗的条件达成协议的屈辱,也避免又一轮军事打击席卷整个地区的冲击。

Aaron David Miller, who served as an American negotiator in the Middle East for decades, told me that, since July, when a ceasefire from April fell apart without a long-term truce, “Trump’s had three options—negotiate, escalate, strangulate. None are mutually exclusive if Trump had a strategy.” But since this is Trump, and he doesn’t, Miller argued that the strangulation option is the likeliest course for now. Maybe that can work to keep the Strait of Hormuz mostly open—although, since Wednesday, four oil tankers have struck Iranian mines while attempting to pass through. Maybe gas prices will keep going down. Maybe it doesn’t even matter, since, as Trump claimed in a speech on Wednesday, “we won” the war already and are now only waiting to decide “when we want to end.” Whatever that means.

曾担任美国中东谈判代表数十年的亚伦·戴维·米勒告诉我,自7月一份4月达成的停火协议在没有长期休战的情况下破裂以来,“特朗普有三个选项——谈判、升级、绞杀。如果特朗普有战略的话,这三者并非互斥。”但既然这是特朗普,而他并没有战略,米勒认为绞杀选项是当前最可能的路线。也许这能维持霍尔木兹海峡基本畅通——尽管自周三以来,已有四艘油轮在试图通过时撞上伊朗水雷。也许油价会继续下跌。也许这根本不重要,因为正如特朗普在周三的演讲中所声称的,“我们已经赢了”这场战争,现在只是在等待决定“我们想什么时候结束”。不管那是什么意思。

The point is that ambiguity, for the President, may currently present the least bad option. Waiting it out is also very consistent with Trump’s own preferred approach to a situation when he’s boxed himself into a corner—which has been often in his long and eventful life. As Miller noted, however, buying time almost certainly will not work over the long haul: “The only problem with strangulation—the neither-here-nor-there option—is that it won’t change I.R.G.C. foundational positions and will, over time, compel Iran to break out and escalate.” The Israeli national-security expert Danny Citrinowicz made a similar observation. “The risk of renewed escalation remains significant,” he wrote on X, precisely because neither Trump nor the Iranians are willing to make meaningful concessions to reach the deal that each would theoretically prefer. “Both sides may genuinely want to avoid another confrontation and still find themselves heading toward one.”

关键在于,对总统而言,模糊性目前可能是最不坏的选择。拖延等待也非常符合特朗普自己陷入困境时的首选应对方式——在他漫长而多事的一生中,这种情况屡见不鲜。然而,正如米勒所指出的,拖延时间几乎肯定无法长期奏效:“绞杀——这种不伦不类的选项——唯一的问题在于,它不会改变伊斯兰革命卫队的基本立场,而且随着时间推移,会迫使伊朗突围并升级局势。”以色列国家安全专家丹尼·西特里诺维奇也做出了类似的观察。“重新升级的风险仍然很大,”他在X平台上写道,原因恰恰在于特朗普和伊朗人都不愿做出有意义的让步来达成双方理论上都更愿意达成的协议。“双方可能都真心想避免另一场对抗,却仍然发现自己正朝着对抗的方向走去。”

In the meantime, the confrontation that Trump appears to be having is with his own Vice-President, whose social-media post denouncing the Iran war as the reason for his party’s political calamity was as significant a public break between a President and his No. 2 as I’ve ever seen. (Not counting, that is, Trump’s rift with his first Vice-President, Mike Pence, over Trump’s false claims of a “rigged” 2020 election.) For months, it’s been obvious that Vance never backed Trump’s original decision to launch the war. But his statement after the election—“The reason we lost is the war”—notably avoided any hint of support for the President’s position that the war was a tough but defensible choice to head off the future possibility of an Iranian nuclear bomb.

与此同时,特朗普似乎正在进行的对抗,是与自己的副总统之间的对抗。万斯在社交媒体上发帖谴责伊朗战争是其政党政治灾难的原因,这是我见过的一位总统与其二号人物之间最重大的公开决裂。(当然,这不包括特朗普与其第一任副总统迈克·彭斯之间因特朗普声称2020年大选“被操纵”而产生的裂痕。)几个月来,万斯从未支持特朗普发动战争的最初决定,这一点早已显而易见。但他在选举后的声明——“我们输掉的原因是战争”——明显避免了对总统立场的任何支持。特朗普的立场是,这场战争虽然艰难但可以辩护,是为了防范未来伊朗核弹的可能性。

Initially, Trump pretended not to be bothered by Vance’s apostasy, claiming that he even agreed with the conclusion that the war had been the reason for the Party’s poor showing. But it became increasingly apparent during the past few days that his anger with Vance was growing. On Sunday, he told reporters that “a lot of people didn’t like” Vance blaming the election losses on the war, while also claiming that it had not affected their relationship. “Not at all,” Trump said. That was never going to last.

起初,特朗普假装对万斯的背叛不以为意,声称他甚至同意战争是共和党表现不佳的原因这一结论。但在过去几天里,他对万斯的愤怒日益明显。周日,他告诉记者,“很多人不喜欢”万斯将选举失利归咎于战争,同时声称这并未影响他们之间的关系。“完全没有,”特朗普说。这种话注定撑不了多久。

Being Vice-President is a tough job in the best of circumstances; being Trump’s Vice-President was almost certainly not going to work out well for Vance. In the Elections Have Consequences department, it appears that one swift result of the 2026 midterms was to accelerate the inevitable breakup between a President who ran on “no new wars” and then started one anyway and the Vice-President who never backed him on it in the first place. This is what losing looks like. ♦

即使在最好的情况下,当副总统也是一份苦差事;而当特朗普的副总统,对万斯来说几乎注定不会有好结果。在“选举自有后果”这一栏目下,2026年中期选举的一个迅速结果,似乎就是加速了一场不可避免的分道扬镳:一边是以“不再发动新战争”为竞选口号、随后却发动了一场战争的总统,另一边是从一开始就从未支持过这场战争的副总统。这就是失败的样子。♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month